This seems to be boilding down to a question of what really matters and what Australian culture is all about. On the one hand, we have those who think it is important to be able to speak your mind, even to say something you might not like. On the other we have those who think it is more important that what we say does not bother the old fashioned members of our society. On the one hand, we have those who think it is important to be able to choose what to wear. On the other, we have those who think it is more important that people fit in and choose the same thing, even if it means they have no choice. I am truly embarrassed to see so many Australians making the wrong choice, some even being such hypocrits as to pretend they are defending our freedom.
Quote:Nobody is born with burqa or niqab so wearing it is not an inalienable right, just like having a bone through your nose isn't
But having a bone through your nose is a basic human right. It is also perfectly legal in Australia. Yet I bet if some African guy wearing one blew up the harbour bridge, you would find some silly reason why it is an affront to public morality.
No-one is born able to speak, yet freedom of speech is a fundamental human right.
Quote:If Allah wanted women to cover their faces he would have created them with a skin flap growing from their hairline, a kind of facial hymen. But no, face covering by burqa or niqab is a choice, insofar as one has any choice under Islam.
Sorren, all freedom is about choice. That's what freedom is.
Quote:As a choice, it has no special claim to respect.
But this isn't about respect is it? No-one is demanding you respect the choices these women make. It is about freedom, not respect - a freedom some are foolish enough to want to deny for no good reason.
Quote:It is not a choice for an intrinsic, supra-social, transcedent good that most of us recognise as such.
That is not what freedom is. It would not be freedom if we had to justify our choices according to your (or anybody's) definition of an intrinsic, supra social, transcendant good. You seem to have a bit of trouble grasping what freedom is, don't you Soren?
Quote:Paradoxically, one of such central ethical notions in this society is individual freeedom of choice, a notion Islam totally rejects.
The only paradox here is that you defend that freedom while at the same time rejecting it in favour of your busy-body 'supra social good'.
Quote:So while Muslim women can claim the right to cover their faces on the the grounds of our freedoms, they cannot also thereby deny our freedom not to respect them, not to ridicule them.
So you are not in favour of banning the burqa?
Quote:Yet to all the useful idiots, the challenge is to continue to defend Islam on grounds Islam rejects.
This is not about defending Islam. This is about defending the right of a woman (or a man for that matter) to choose what to wear, without interfering men fretting about what signals they can read into those choices and project onto the women.
Quote:What is pissweak is seeing idiotic arguments defending a strangers right to behave strangely in our land
That is not pissweak. That is what our soldiers fought and died for. They did not die so that some idiot could throw those rights away and start telling Australian citizens what they can and cannot wear. To this day, people still die in defending those freedoms. By rejecting it, you signal that you spit in the face of the freedoms they died for. You signal that you, not these Muslim women, reject what Australia stands for and place yourself outside of Australian society.
Quote:for their is no greater symbol of separation from our society than masking your identity from it
Australian citizens have every right to choose a separate path for themselves, especially over something as petty as clothing. It is what makes Australia such a great country.
Quote:So many adults are caught up in trying to appear "tolerant" of differences, that they have lost the ability to discern when those differences are having a negative, and divisive effect upon our community standards.
Trust me Mozz, most Australians are more than capable of recognising which differences have a negative effect on our society, which is why most Australians recognise that it is not a rejection of our dress standards, but a rejection of our fundamental rights and freedoms that is the great threat to our values.
Quote:Take your young kids down to Brunswick, and see how they react when they turn around and see three women dressed in strange clothes that hide their faces, standing behind them.
You know what their reaction is, because you know that kids are honest, and you know that they will not be influenced to invent fanciful reasons to try and explain away what is a rational and reasonable reaction to confronting someone in a mask.
I have seen a child's reaction up close and personal. It is certainly not a reaction of fear or anything else we need to concern ourselves with. Not that I would let the reaction of our child dictate which freedoms we take away from people, especially if they are being lead by an adult who wets his pants every time a strong religious woman walks by.