freediver wrote on Sep 24
th, 2008 at 3:38pm:
You won't get it anywhere near a referendum if you don't already have a working model. Asking people to vote for one, or expecting some convention to come up with one is a copout - a way to avoid facing the fact that you can't come up with a better system than the one we already have, except for a bit of window dressing. You need to sell the new system, not the idea of change for the sake of change.
The process and circumstances of the HOS's appointment and dismissal warrant a choice on a referendum. For the appointment, my model would be the Sovereign Council (as already discussed).
As the relationship between parliament, the HOG and the HOS is a significant issue with the public (with most preferring a parliamentary majority for appointing/dismissing the HOS) and were this the model to be put to the people, these things would have to be determined by the people :
Is the process of HOS nomination satisfactory ?
Would the presumptive HOS require 2/3 parliamentary majority for ratification?
Would the dismissal of the HOS be effected by the HOG or 2/3 parliamentary majority?