freediver wrote on May 18
th, 2021 at 5:50pm:
True.
But the act is still not the belief. It is not the faith. It is not a tenet. It is an act. They are different things. Thus you misrepresent Islam when you say they are the same thing.
Firstly, the 5 pillars are not 5 "acts" as you are trying to define it. The first, and clearly most important pillar is the shahada - belief in the oneness of God. That is clearly, one hundred percent a belief and nothing else - even in your book.
What else do you expect the Islamic faith to comprise of?
The other 4 pillars should be understood as acts that revolve around this belief or 'faith' - acts that directly affirm and strengthen this belief. Hence 'acts of faith': prayer - remembering the one God and imploring Him to keep you on the straight path; fasting and charity - understanding that the key to being at peace with God is by rejecting material desires and possession (pretty much a universal concept in all mainstream religions); and pilgrimage to Islam's holiest site.
Quote:Also, when you say that the 5 acts summarise the religion as succinctly as possible, you are painting Islam as a behaviour, not belief. Or, an extremely shallow set of beliefs.
Far from it. Belief is absolutely central to everything in Islam - from which all other Islamic acts revolve around. The acts surrounding that belief simply don't make sense outside belief.