What Karnal wants us to believe is that the immutable laws of physics are being suspended for this one individual.

For the body to maintain about 37c and not waste away a minimum of 1000 calories is required. It's a very simple case of energy in, energy out. If she's not eating, how are these calories delivered? Some invisible energy stream?

Karnal says she's been observed, maybe so but the key here is observed by who and under what conditions. If by members of her religious organisation, that doesn't cut it.

In closing, I'll hand over to Mr Sagan.

Karnal wrote on Jun 11^th, 2021 at 8:37pm:



I fear that The Age of Aquarius is over and
we now face the End Times as prophesied in the Bible.

Cu Chulainn wrote on Jun 11^th, 2021 at 9:07pm:


There been plenty of occurrences in history of humans being deprived of calories, the most frequent result is cannibalism

Cu Chulainn wrote on Jun 11^th, 2021 at 9:07pm:


We all do, Cu, we all do.

You?

Karnal wrote on Jun 11^th, 2021 at 9:59pm:



He's in our every breath.

It can be done, same as invisibility and the human body flying... it's all in the mind...

Gordon wrote on Jun 11^th, 2021 at 8:52pm:


Said religious organisation does not promote breatharianism, mystic feats or hocus pocus of any kind. It promotes maintaining a balanced diet according to Vedic principles - no onions or garlic, no drinking after meals, chewing each bite carefully before swallowing, etc, etc, etc. As the saying goes, dear, eat your water, drink your food.

Indians are obsessed with food.

But as one ascends upon the Path, lifestyles, interests and metabolisms change. Not all lose an interest in food. No true yogi broadcasts these changes to anyone but their teacher. Self promotion would only undo all the work you've done.

Yes, there are those who promote their magical powers, but they get stunted and stuck, or worse, fall. People with such powers keep them to themselves, or they soon find themselves losing them.

The nun I've mentioned has no need not to eat. All the ashrams and households serve food. I've seen her at mealtimes zipping around, filling up her water bottle or doing chores. She sits near the monks when they eat, and helps clean up afterwards.

But she never discusses it.

If in fact it's others who are making the claim she doesn't eat then she's lying thru omission as she'd be well aware of the claim.  Unless of course the perpetual motion nun is deaf.

2 facts we know about the nun.

1: She eats
2: She lies