falah wrote on Oct 1st, 2011 at 4:30am:

freediver wrote on Sep 30th, 2011 at 7:33pm:

Falah, do you also support the death penalty for apostasy under Islamic law?

That is a bit hypothetical is it not? I do not live in a country run according to Islamic law, so my opinion of certain elements seem to be hardly relevant.

I suggest examining the issue of the apostate. Is there anything wrong with him?

Clearly the answer is yes. An apostate has rejected pure Islamic monotheism.

We are presented with two possibilities. Either the apostate is mentally inadequate, which makes him innocent in Islamic law, or he is a committed polytheist.

The polytheist disrespects God, and therefore earns the reward of the Hellfire. What could be worse for a human than going to the Hellfire?

The apostate is cursed by God for choosing polytheism.

The apostate is particularly harmful to the monotheistic society because he propagates a message of polytheism - if a disbeliever was not interested in propagation of polytheism, then he would either flee the Islamic state or remain quiet.

So the apostate is one who would call people to the Hellfire, and there is nothing worse that can happen to people than going to Hell. Therefore the apostate is a dangerous individual who harms his commuinity.

falah wrote on Oct 1st, 2011 at 4:30am:

I suggest examining the issue of the apostate. Is there anything wrong with him?
Clearly the answer is yes. An apostate has rejected pure Islamic monotheism.

We are presented with two possibilities. Either the apostate is mentally inadequate, which makes him innocent in Islamic law, or he is a committed polytheist.

...... if a disbeliever was not interested in propagation of polytheism, then he would either flee the Islamic state or remain quiet.

.......Therefore the apostate is a dangerous individual who harms his commuinity.

I repeat

Sir Spot of Borg wrote on May 18^th, 2012 at 1:30pm:


SOB

SOB I challenge you to find any other member whose views are as morally void as those of Abu and Falah.