Quote:Nairbe, you said, Dawkins does not do Atheists any service by turning it into a cause to be rallied to by the disaffected, ignorant and insecure. Atheism is not a belief, nor a religion or something to rally around. Such things are for the weak minded and religious.
Now Atheism is not my 'cause'. I'll argue the point when it arises, but it's not a 'core issue'. If anybody wants to make it their cause I don't have a problem with that. I don't think it adds to my credibility or is in anyway useful to sneer at them as, disaffected, ignorant, weak minded or insecure.
While it's true to say you, 'don't have to be a scientist' to see that claiming truth for a hypothesis conjured out of the ether with no corroborating evidence is ridiculous; surely it doesn no harm to bring scientific evidence to support your own position.
Religion is not a statement 'there is a god creator'. There's a whole body of mumbo jumbo that's been built up, a lot of it flying in the face of the known. For a scientist like Dawkins to react to the gall with which people like Pell dismiss their lifes work is right and natural.