Quote:freediver wrote on Mar 6
th, 2008 at 2:25pm:
What makes you think it is undermining their own system? I think some of the Bali bombers got a similar pardon.
Only that the Indonesian Judges themselves have always emphatically denounced any kind of deviation from the actual process of Indonesian style justice.
They did make a great display of taking a hardline on foreign drug traffickers
And that they were so harsh with Schappelle Corby.[[ no they didnt hang/shoot her, but 20 yrs is ridiculous]]
This is a little surprising I think.
The Bali Bombers dont deserve any softening of laws for what they did.
They were originally sentenced to life prisonment. This was reduced on appeal to 20 years. The prosecution appealed the leniency of the reduction and won. They were sentenced to death. This latest decision has now reverted the sentence back to life because the defence argued that the death penalty was not the original sentence sought by the prosecution nor was it the penalty the prosecution asked for when they appealed.
20 years for importating the quantity of (high grade) cannabis caught on Corby may sound ridiculous in Australia but is quite standard for Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore. In fact, everyone knows that the penalty is death.
The sad things about Corby (and given the alledged corruption within the Indo court system) Corby could have gotten out a lot earlier. Sure, the sentence was 20 years, but after appeal she could have likely gotten a lighter sentence. Corby's case was hardly reported in Indonesia. Therefore, most indonesians did not know about the case. However, the uproar by the Australian public, anti-Indonesian sentiments, letter writings condemning Indonesia as barbaric, Indonesian shops damaged, white powdery substance sent to the Indonesian consulate, Sydney shock jock comparing the judges to monkeys "they don't even speak English, they're straight out of the trees" were reported (understandably). This raised mutually anti-Australian sentiment by the Indonesian public causing the courts to steel themselves to any leniency. Diplomacy is mostly about face-saving (especially in the Asian region). Unfortunately, Australia does not understand the ethos of South East Asia despite being part of the region.
Why do you think Michelle Lesley and DJ Nick Taylor got such lenient sentences? Sure, the quantity they had are significantly less but compare 3 months jail to 20 years. Very little publicity, the Indonesian courts are seen to be tough on drugs but later the sentence will be reduced. However, treat them with arrogance and disdain and you'll get very little sympathy back. Especially, when Australia is largely (rightly or not) seen as a racist country by Asian.