Hung Uncut Black Muslim Jew wrote on Oct 23
rd, 2026 at 6:33am:
There are no leftwing retards here Bobby.
Retard starts with the letter R for a reason :
Revolting, Racist, Repulsive, Rightwing, Reductive, Reject etc.
There are plenty of Marxist retards here:
The retarded Marxist Kibbutz idea ended up mostly failing in Israel.
Some people sat on their arses all day watching TV while others worked really hard from dawn to dusk -
yet they all received the same rewards.
Human nature says that doesn't work.
https://www.ozpolitic.com/forum/YaBB.pl?num=1660808671/2430#2430Google AIThe traditional strict-communist kibbutz model did not entirely fail—it functioned successfully for decades and helped build early Israel—but its pure egalitarian form declined due to severe economic crises, human nature, and generational shifts.
Key Reasons for the Decline of Traditional Kibbutzim
• The 1980s Economic Crisis: Israel's hyperinflation and financial crash in the 1980s left cumulative kibbutz debt soaring to $6 billion by 1989. Unlike other sectors, the government refused to restructure this debt, forcing deep cuts to living standards and breaking the collective financial model.
•
Lack of Individual Incentives (The "Free-Rider" Problem): In a system where everyone receives an equal share regardless of productivity or output, resentment grew toward slackers or harder workers. Talented and skilled members often left for outside opportunities where individual effort was rewarded.• Generational Disconnect: The founding generation was driven by a deep ideological and Zionist zeal. Their children and grandchildren did not share the same enthusiasm for mandatory collective labor, communal child-rearing, and shared property.
• Shift in Israel’s Economy: As Israel transitioned into a modern, high-tech, and market-driven economy, the isolated, agriculture-heavy communal setup struggled to keep pace.
• Privatization: Facing bankruptcy and changing desires, over two-thirds of Israel’s kibbutzim abandoned strict socialism. Most transitioned to privatized systems, individual home ownership, differential salaries, and outside employment while keeping cooperative social frameworks