You claimed:

MeisterEckhart wrote on Apr 28^th, 2026 at 9:44am:


You are either deliberately lying, or incredibly gullible.

You are also incapable of making a point. Are you just here to whinge about the sad facts of history?

Quote:


It is an effort to get you to make a point. What is your point Meister?

If they were not Jews, would you and all your fellow deluded Jew haters be insisting that a country having it's own immigration policy is some kind of crime against humanity?

I have given you examples of Aussie Muslim converts right here in this forum, supporting ongoing war, because the glorious Muslim victory over the Jews is necessary and inevitable. On the other hand Israel has created a beacon freedom and democracy in one of the most backwards and oppressive places on earth. After being slaughtered in Europe and ethnically cleansed from the middle east and north africa, they now give the large Arab Muslim population of Israel more rights and freedoms, and more say in the governance of the country, than in any other middle eastern or north african country. So which group do you think is actually addicted to war?

You are not stating the facts. You are bullshitting.

MeisterEckhart wrote on Apr 28^th, 2026 at 9:44am:


You are either deliberately lying, or incredibly gullible. You are also incapable of making a point. Are you just here to whinge about the sad facts of history? Facts that aren't actually facts, but lies about Jews?

What is your point Meister?

If they were not Jews, would you and all your fellow deluded Jew haters be insisting that a country having it's own immigration policy is some kind of crime against humanity?

I have given you examples of Aussie Muslim converts right here in this forum, supporting ongoing war, because the glorious Muslim victory over the Jews is necessary and inevitable. On the other hand Israel has created a beacon freedom and democracy in one of the most backwards and oppressive places on earth. After being slaughtered in Europe and ethnically cleansed from the middle east and north africa, they now give the large Arab Muslim population of Israel more rights and freedoms, and more say in the governance of the country, than in any other middle eastern or north african country. So which group do you think is actually addicted to war?

Quote:


The root cause is Islam. It has 1400 years of history, all telling the same story.

Islam is why they hate Jews. Islam is why they want to destroy Israel. No other explanation is necessary. It would make absolutely no difference what the history was. Even if 100% of the Jews in Israel were local born and could trace their ancestry in Israel back to Adam and Eve, Muslims would still want to kill them. Because they are Jews.

As an exercise and as research for you extends only to other posters on this site, use your 'common sense' approach, but apply honesty as a novelty for you, to consider this.

Why would Jews residing in Middle Eastern Muslim regions migrate to pre-1948 Palestine, another Muslim region, before they could be confident of protection by the ruling state?

Before 1948, the UN's support for Jewish enclaves was not assured.

US and European backing for them was not assured.

Convincing militant Zionist victories over Arabs in Palestine had not been achieved.

Israel did not yet exist.

The region was exploding in violence, the outcome of which was unknown.

Would you have moved your family from relative peace and from a people you at least knew into a dangerous war zone?

European Jews had lost everything and nothing to lose... Middle Eastern Jews had everything to lose before 1948.

MeisterEckhart wrote on Apr 28^th, 2026 at 11:11am:

Add to that the fact that British Mandate forces were actively, and even violently, discouraging Jewish migration into Palestine.

The only Jews determined to migrate to Israel during this period were European Jews who were being ferried by militant Zionists from European ports by their tens of thousands, having lost everything, most having lost their entire families, let alone everything they owned.

All Arabs at some time came from Arabia and there they should return unless they prepare to abide by  law of host country.

MeisterEckhart wrote on Apr 28^th, 2026 at 11:41am:


What you erroneously call "the creation of greater Israel" in fact is recreation of historical Israel.

tallowood wrote on Apr 28^th, 2026 at 11:46am:

What do you mean by historical Israel? There was a historical Israel, Judea and Samaria within the region. Historically, they were in conflict with each other.