Gordon
Gold Member
   
Online

Australian Politics
Posts: 21410
Gordon
Gender:
|
what are the roots of antisemitism
The roots of antisemitism are complex, ancient, and multilayered, combining religious, economic, cultural, political, and racial elements that have mutated over time. Below is a structured overview of its major historical sources and how they evolved.
### 1. Ancient and Pre-Christian Origins (Antiquity–4th century CE) - Pagan Greco-Roman world: Jews were often seen as “misanthropic” for monotheism, refusal to worship emperors or local gods, dietary laws, and circumcision. Writers like Manetho, Apion, and Tacitus spread stereotypes of Jewish separatism and “hatred of mankind.” - Early economic role: In Hellenistic cities (especially Alexandria), Jews formed distinct, often prosperous communities, generating resentment during economic crises.
### 2. Christian Theological Antisemitism (4th–18th centuries) - Core charge: Deicide (“Christ-killers”) – the idea that Jews collectively bore eternal guilt for Jesus’ crucifixion (based on selective readings of New Testament passages, especially Matthew 27:25). - Church Fathers (John Chrysostom, Augustine, Ambrose) developed “teaching of contempt”: Jews as obstinate, cursed, doomed to wander and suffer for rejecting Christ. - Medieval consequences: - Blood libel (first major case: Norwich 1144) – false accusations of ritual murder of Christian children. - Host desecration libels. - Forced wearing of badges or hats, ghettoization, expulsions (England 1290, Spain 1492, etc.). - Association with the Devil and well-poisoning (especially during Black Death 1348–1351 pogroms).
### 3. Economic and Social Antisemitism (Middle Ages–19th century) - Christians were forbidden from usury → Jews filled money-lending roles → stereotype of the greedy, exploitative Jew. - Guilds and landownership bans confined many Jews to trade and finance → simultaneous resentment for both poverty (when restricted) and success (when they prospered). - “Court Jew” phenomenon in early modern Europe reinforced the image of secretive Jewish financial power.
### 4. Modern Racial/Nationalist Antisemitism (late 18th–20th centuries) - Enlightenment and emancipation: As Jews gained citizenship (France 1791, Germany 1871), traditional religious hatred became secularized. - New racial pseudoscience (Gobineau, Chamberlain, H.S. Chamberlain) redefined Jews as a permanently alien “Semitic race,” not just a religion. - Forged “Protocols of the Elders of Zion” (1903) alleged global Jewish conspiracy. - Volksdeutsch and pan-Slavic nationalisms portrayed Jews as rootless cosmopolitans who undermined the “organic” nation. - Culmination in Nazi ideology: combination of medieval Christian antisemitic tropes (blood libel, world conspiracy) with 19th-century racial biology → “Final Solution.”
### 5. Left-Wing and Anti-Capitalist Variants (19th–20th centuries) - Early socialist thinkers (Fourier, Proudhon, some Marx passages) used “Jew” as a synonym for financier or exploiter. - Soviet antisemitism: “Rootless cosmopolitans” campaign (1948–1953), Doctors’ Plot.
### 6. Islamic-World Antisemitism (7th century–present) - Classical Islamic status: Jews (and Christians) as dhimmis – protected but second-class, with jizya tax and restrictions. - 19th–20th centuries: European Christian antisemitic literature (blood libel, Protocols) imported into Arabic via Christian Arabs and European colonists. - Post-1948 fusion of anti-Zionism with older tropes; some Islamist movements (Hamas charter 1988, certain Iranian rhetoric) explicitly cite medieval Christian or Protocols-style accusations.
### 7. Contemporary Forms - Far-right: white nationalist “great replacement” and “Jewish power” conspiracies. - Radical left: some strains of anti-Zionism that slide into classic tropes (Rothschilds, “Zionist lobby controls governments,” dual-loyalty accusations). - Conspiracy culture (QAnon, some COVID narratives) often revives medieval blood libel or Protocols themes in secular form.
### Summary of Persistent Core Themes Across Eras - Scapegoating during crises (plagues, economic collapse, wars). - Resentment of Jewish separateness combined with resentment of Jewish success/integration. - The “eternal Jew” as rootless, conspiratorial, simultaneously capitalist and communist, weak yet all-powerful.
Antisemitism is unusual among prejudices in its adaptability: it survives by constantly reinventing itself—from religious heresy to racial threat to anti-imperialist symbol—while retaining a remarkably stable core of myths and accusations for over two millennia.
|