Frank wrote on Dec 28
th, 2020 at 8:33pm:
Ugly modernist concrete slabs (that is ALL modernists ever did) over natural waterfall.
Well, to vary that old saying “Ugliness is in the eye of the beholder”
You may however be interested to know you’re aesthetic judgement of Falling Water is very much in the minority.
Not so with minimalist crap such as Corbusier’s boxes.
____________________________________________________
Maybe this is an appropriate time to raise a few issues.
1. We need to be aware that (more so than with today’s printed reproductions) images of art works as displayed on the web can exhibit huge differences in colouration, focus and definition. Not a good idea to judge them from any digital medium of uncertain veracity.
2. Even reproductions of artworks in expensive printed publications can lead you astray. I was unimpressed by all of Brett Whitely’s work thinking it cartoonish. Dragged along to an exhibition in Sydney I was utterly blown away by his fluid technique and emotional power.
3. Will we ever agree about a definition of something as subjective as ‘beauty’? OK, relatively objective judgements can be arrived at on technique and drawing skill etc but beyond that we’re in very subjective territory.