Brian Ross wrote on Apr 7
th, 2018 at 12:59pm:
Sir Grappler Truth Teller OAM wrote on Apr 6
th, 2018 at 11:03pm:
Mistress Nicole wrote on Apr 6
th, 2018 at 10:53pm:
Bobby what makes you think Karnal wasn't a soldier in Vietnam? I know she is abrasive, but if she served she deserves our respect and gratitude.
One of my mum's friends is a Vietnam Vet. I don't know him well but I have thanked him for his service.
No female soldiers in Viet Nam - nursing staff maybe, but not even necessarily in-country.
Nurses were members of the Royal Australian Medical Corps and were soldiers too, Graps. They served in South Vietnam, at 3 Base Hospital at Vung Tau. They were also sent out on the occasional Medical support mission to help the Vietnamese people. I'd suggest you read the book, "Minefields and Miniskirts" by Siobhan McHugh. An excellent little history of Australian women during the Vietnam War.
Quote:No dis-respect, but let's just keep the facts straight. It's not like nowadays, when it is distinctly possible for a female soldier to engage in contact, though they are not generally placed in that position as a matter of policy or operational requirement.
Today, all ECNs are now open to women, Graps. Provided they can pass the tests required for that role. Women are not allowed to be banned from serving in any role by "policy or operational requirement."
Quote:Universally, the direct combat role is given to men - for the same old reasons that have been around for millions of years now. Facts do not cause hurt.
Except that ended two years ago (and so it should have). Provided a female can satisfy the (realistic) requirements, there is nothing stopping them from fulfilling that role. I have served beside women who have been just as fit, just as strong and just as smart as any male but they were barred from serving in combat units because of their gender because of sexism like yours. It was pointless and it was silly.
Mainly Nursing Corps, Brian - I was RAAMC and we had three lady Captain nurses attached... good ladies and good nurses. Not sure if there were any nurses stationed at 1AFH Vung Tau. Knew me a quack who served there....
If you read on I suggested that the current division between men and women in Direct Combat roles might change in the future. In some cases I can't see why not. I already stated that my World War IV series had units composed of men and women and all combat soldiers.... some of the women outstanding.
How dare you arbitrarily label me 'sexist' for looking at simple realities? MOST women neither qualify nor wish to engage in Direct Combat roles... but there have been some outstanding performers among them when attached to Combat units - one at least getting an MC for assisting wounded under fire.
Size is less important than physical attributes and mental attributes - remember 'Popeye' Wynn from Band of Brothers?
"When we went into training a lot of the guys lost a lot of weight very quickly - I was only 130lb anyway so I didn't lose one pound". 130 lb is less than ten stone.... in Vietnam the average US Paratrooper was around 5'10" and 140lb of fit.... a lot of OUR SAS (Short And Stupid)* people these days are giants compared to the Brits - but I know which lot I'd prefer first, and it's all about skill and determination.
*That's what the Brits say of themselves...