There’s no ‘obvious’ reason to report the Barnaby Joyce affair
The Australian
12:00AM February 9, 2018
Graham Richardson
Some years ago, I told my friend Laurie Oakes that I did not agree with his outing of the relationship between Cheryl Kernot and Gareth Evans. He remained a good friend after he had pushed the door ever so slightly ajar on a can of worms. Now Sharri Markson has pushed that door wide open.
From this day forward no politician, or journalist I suspect, has any right to privacy. It should be a wild ride from now on because Barnaby Joyce is not Robinson Crusoe in the federal parliament and there are many juicy liaisons ready to have a light shone upon them in state legislatures as well.
The ethics of the airing of the Joyce affair is a hot topic at every dinner table around the country. Given the life I have led, I was never going to be the one who cast the first stone.
There are many journos in Canberra who are in exactly that position. Then along comes Markson. She has come a long way for someone in their early 30s. She has been breaking stories for Sydney’s The Daily Telegraph for the past year or so, and even before this story broke she had make her mark in the Canberra press gallery.
I watched her give a passionate defence of her decision to, as they say, publish and be damned. She is most assuredly correct when she says the affair was all over social media. I used to have a great deal of respect for Tony Windsor, a former MP for New England who was instrumental in maintaining the Gillard Labor government after the nail-biting finish in the 2010 federal election.
I lost much of that respect when he tweeted late last year that the Joyce marriage was in trouble. That tweet was the beginning of the end for any chance of Joyce’s affair with a one-time staff member remaining private.I first heard of the affair around the middle of last year. There can be no question that the fact the woman concerned worked as his media adviser about the time the affair began gave Markson a reason to publish. When you mix business with pleasure within your office, there will be fallout. In the US House of Representatives they are setting up rules to prevent congressmen from having affairs with staff members. It will always be difficult to completely eradicate the whiff of the powerful person in the relationship using that power.
While I have no doubt that is not the case here, it does parade an excuse for the fourth estate to probe even deeper.One of the claims made by Markson on Sky News, however, I would take issue with.
She was adamant that it was “obviously” in the public interest to publish the story. While there is an argument that publication was reasonable in the circumstances, [highlight]there is a real debate about whether it was right or not, so “obviously” is a word that must be coming from exuberance and a steely determination to justify her decision. It goes without saying that Markson is one tough hombre.[/highlight]
There was another thing she said I couldn’t agree with. Because she had offered Joyce and Vikki Campion a sit-down interview and
they had refused, the publication of the front-page photo of a seven-months pregnant Campion dressed in a tracksuit and going for a walk was justified.
It wasn’t, and that is “obvious” to many people I have heard comment on the photo.
Once the decision had been taken to run the story, the pain of those affected was played out in public. The Deputy PM’s admission of “failure” was painful to watch. The hurt injected into every word of the statement put out by Joyce’s wife of 24 years, Natalie, was so real and graphic. With that statement, I felt like a voyeur peering through a window as the scorned woman wrote of how she had put her own career on hold and spoke of the effect the affair had on her four daughters.What happened in the Joyce marriage we will never know. This was a story that was bound to be published at some stage and it comes as no surprise that first cab off the rank was the ballsy Markson. It is a messy business and I will be fascinated to see what revelations about other pollies come to light. Affairs are common in Canberra, where politicians and staff members spend so much time away from home. Whoever came up with the phrase “absence makes the heart grow fonder” was an idiot. In my experience absence makes the heart wander.
Meanwhile, back in parliament, I got my first look at the man no one had heard of whom Joyce promoted into cabinet at the expense of Darren Chester.
Chester had been a strong performer and some say it was he who raised with Joyce his increasingly erratic behaviour last year when the marriage broke up and the affair was under way. Chester was dumped from cabinet but he refused to comment on his boss this week when given the chance.
pt1