Quote:Why on earth would I do that?
Because I asked for an example. Can you give one?
Quote:Oh yeah, you got me there FD - I'm totally trying to sneakily spinelessly apologise for the black man - cause you know, he's not white.
Do you blame the black man or the white man Gandalf? If a black man rapes a mexiwoman on a beach in Florida and she contracts AIDS, do you blame the man who gave her the disease, or white people for bringing the disease to the country?
Quote:Take a deep breath, calm down, and think about what you are actually saying - and after that think about what you are actually responding to. Because its not even remotely related to anything I said.
You invited me to call them white, then got upset when i called them white. How else should we interpret it Gandalf?
Also, if there were many instances of a disease being passed on by people of different races with sinister intentions, how do you decide which race to blame? Is it always white people who get the blame?
Are you just making this up as you go along, or is this a Muslim thing you are getting from somewhere?
If a white supremacist started saying European instead of white, would you defend him against charges of racism? Or can only Muslims do this trick?
If the Arabs made the contact between the old and the new world inevitable by cutting Europe off from the rest of civilisation, do they bear any responsibility for the introduction of diseases?
Why does the blame hinge on intentions that had nothing at all to do with disease? If the disease was introduced to the Americas be people trying to find a trade route to India, who do you blame?
If the disease was already there when they invaded, does that mean they are not to blame?
Can any blame be attributed to geographic proximity of the disease source to the people it was passed on to? Or just white people?
Also, why does blame not hinge on whether the disease was deliberately introduced? Are you saying the Europeans who had nothing to do with the introduction of the disease are just as blame worthy as the Americans who deliberately gave smallpox to native Indians?