Lionel Edriess wrote on Oct 15
th, 2013 at 11:29pm:
I have no problem with cutting a sheep's throat. I've done it myself to provide meat for the table. That having been said, I wouldn't lead animal after animal into the same room for the same purpose.
There are already existing laws governing the live sheep trade and I'm of the opinion that not all these laws are currently being complied with. Of particular concern is the illegal trade in Australian live export sheep into illicit markets in order to satisfy localised demands for sacrificial offerings in upcoming religious observances.
Despite the revenue gained locally from such trade, I could be convinced that suspension of trade would be in the best interests of this country, particularly if endorsed by the relevant reputable bodies. Illegal trading in this, as in any other trading commodity, should be harshly dealt with. If such conditions could not be met, then perhaps a complete suspension would be enacted until such conditions were met.
I do not endorse unnecessary cruelty to animals, not even humans.
As an omnivore, ever mindful of the wishes and desires of the carnivores, I nevertheless ask for the considerate treatment of herbivores in their designated roles.
Lionel,
Thank you for your considered reply.
Again, i was not having a go at you.
I just wanted to highlight the
the influence of 'social imperatives', which we all face, and, which act upon us all.
+++
'It is a matter of conscience.'
A social imperative which we all face in society [in this modern world], is that where we can choose to either make money, OR, we can choose do what is ethical,
the widely accepted social imperative [i.e. 'ethical' choice] is that it is always socially acceptable, to choose to make money [...as the 1st imperative].
Another social imperative which we are all confronted with in society [in this modern world], is that the accepted social imperative [i.e. 'ethical' choice],
is that we should remain silent, when, to say [to expose] publicly what is true, may be judged to be socially offensive [i.e. 'politically incorrect'] to someone, or, to some group of people.
And i am no saint.
We all face ethical [moral] choices in this modern world, but we all often fail to make a 'good' [the 'best'] choice.
Often we fail to make a 'good' choice because, imo, invariably, instead of making the choice which will cause 'least harm', we will choose to do, what will bring us [personally!] worldly pleasure [i.e. money, sex, social position, physical pleasure, etc].
[And some people object to their conscience even being reminded of
that circumstance.]
p.s.
My diet is 70%-90% vegan [i eat fish occasionally].
And i understand that 'needs must' for omnivores, so i do not object to meat eaters using a knife to slaughter the food [the animal] that they will eat.

The intellectual moral high ground, of modern, sophisticated man.