falah wrote on Apr 25
th, 2012 at 11:03am:
muso wrote on Apr 24
th, 2012 at 6:00pm:
Baronvonrort wrote on Apr 24
th, 2012 at 5:35pm:
There is a hadith-
Abu Dawud 38:4450- There is no prescribed punishment for one who has sexual intercourse with an animal.
Islam has severe punishments for consenting adults who have sex outside of being married which makes sex with animals attractive since that has no punishment.
Quote:There is no prescribed punishment...
This means no mandatory sentence - not no punishment at all.
You know nothing of the science of hadeeth.
What you quoted is not considered sound by scholars and the hadeeth recorded by Abu Dawood immediatley prior mentions that the beastialist should be punished with death. There are many hadeeth that mention the punishment for beastiality, and also that tell us that the person involved in this crime is cursed.
Would the science of the hadeeth be a form of psuedo science?
The bible says having sex with animals is not allowed in Leviticus so
which verse in the Quran prohibits sex with animals, please cite this verse from the Quran if there is one FalahThe Quran is claimed to be from Allah yet the hadeeth has no divine origins they are 100% man made passed down like a series of chinese whispers over a couple of hundred years after Mohammad died before it was made into a book.
The hadith has no divine origins.
The sunni and shia both follow the Quran yet is is the hadith where they differ,the shia dont respect al Bukhari and have their own hadith which is considered unreliable by the sunni.
Falah you have claimed the shia are not muslims yet they follow the Quran which allah sent and the only doctrinal difference is the hadth which is man made.
Ibn Rushd - Two truths cannot contradict each other.
The hadith contradicts itself which shows it is man made and not divine.
So under Islamic law a unmarried person who has consensual sex is to be flogged 100 times according to the Quran.
Under Islamic law there is the death penalty for adultery which is punishable by stoning to death yet this punishment is not found in the Quran.
Under Islamic law there is no prescribed punishment
for having sex with an animal.
The Taliban stoned people to death, they flogged unmarried people who had consensual sex yet if you are caught having sex with a donkey there is no punishment,is that the superior morality of Islam falah?
http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2004/03/16/1079199226530.htmlSo why did he only get 4 days in jail for having sex with a donkey falah?