Forum

 
  Back to OzPolitic.com   Welcome, Guest. Please Login or Register
  Forum Home Album HelpSearch Recent Rules LoginRegister  
 

Pages: 1 2 3 
Send Topic Print
Why should Mr Abbott allow a conscience vote? (Read 2802 times)
matty
Gold Member
*****
Offline


Australian Politics

Posts: 11055
East Sydney
Gender: male
Why should Mr Abbott allow a conscience vote?
Dec 17th, 2011 at 8:49pm
 
As he's said, the Coalition went to the last election with a promise of not changing the marriage act. Labor went in with that exact same promise, but have compromised that with the granting of a conscience vote for its members being allowed to break yet another promise, and vote in favour of changing the act from exclusively man-woman, to man-man and woman-woman marriages.
Back to top
 

BILL SHORTEN WILL NEVER BE PM!!!!
 
IP Logged
 
cods
Gold Member
*****
Offline


Australian Politics

Posts: 88048
Re: Why should Mr Abbott allow a conscience vote?
Reply #1 - Dec 17th, 2011 at 8:55pm
 
has gillard actually spelt out why she is against it??.. we know she doesnt believe in religion.. so what is her reason??..as for Abboitt no he doesnt have to do anything... if the libs are so in favour of it they cn still cross the floor..when it comes up.. it will be interesting to see if anyone does..I am wondering what will happen to her if the vote goes against her..she is very much dependent on the libs NOT crossing the floor..mmmmmm
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Paki gob on a stick
Gold Member
*****
Offline


Australian Politics

Posts: 103521
Re: Why should Mr Abbott allow a conscience vote?
Reply #2 - Dec 17th, 2011 at 9:02pm
 
Maybe a few Libs will cross the floor, but the vote still won't pass.

This is all about saving face. As an issue, it's a bit like the republic. People might feel one way or another, but they know changing the marriage act won't change anything.

Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Dnarever
Gold Member
*****
Offline


Australian Politics

Posts: 62038
Here
Gender: male
Re: Why should Mr Abbott allow a conscience vote?
Reply #3 - Dec 17th, 2011 at 9:37pm
 
Why should Mr Abbott allow a conscience vote?

It would infer that he has one?
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Dnarever
Gold Member
*****
Offline


Australian Politics

Posts: 62038
Here
Gender: male
Re: Why should Mr Abbott allow a conscience vote?
Reply #4 - Dec 17th, 2011 at 10:30pm
 
Why should Mr Abbott allow a conscience vote?

You think he should stick to his normal no conscience position?

In my view every vote should be a conscience vote - any other type should be illegal.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Swagman
Gold Member
*****
Offline


Beware of cheap imitations......

Posts: 15095
Illawarra NSW
Gender: male
Re: Why should Mr Abbott allow a conscience vote?
Reply #5 - Dec 18th, 2011 at 2:35am
 
Dnarever wrote on Dec 17th, 2011 at 10:30pm:
Why should Mr Abbott allow a conscience vote?

You think he should stick to his normal no conscience position?

In my view every vote should be a conscience vote - any other type should be illegal.


Why are you a lefty then?  Shocked
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
____
Gold Member
*****
Offline


Australian Politics

Posts: 33410
Australia
Gender: male
Re: Why should Mr Abbott allow a conscience vote?
Reply #6 - Dec 18th, 2011 at 4:25am
 
Why, because of History and what is ahead of us :

"In recent conferences of the party, Herr Hitler emphasised a determination to stamp out sex perversion among all Nazi organisations. It was recalled that after his 'purge' of June 30, he made a pledge 'to German mothers that their sons would never be contaminated if they joined his Storm Troopers'."

This was the beginning of the Nazi purge against gays. In the following ten years, some 50,000 gays were branded as "criminals and degenerates" by the Third Reich, with between 10,000 and 15,000 being sent to concentration camps. Few survived.

Last week, the German "parliament" has decided to spend €500,000 ($613.00, £350,000) for a building in central Berlin that will be a memorial to Nazism's gay victims.

"Homosexual victims of the Nazi regime were mostly shut out of Germany's culture of remembrance in the past. That is now over,'" commented Volker Beck of Germany's Green party.

The memorial will be built along the Tiergarten Park in Berlin, close to the site of a planned Holocaust memorial.

Unlike the millions of Jews killed on the orders of Hitler's government, the gay victims of the Nazi regime have long struggled for recognition.

It was not until December 2000 that the German parliament officially apologised to gays and lesbians who were persecuted under the Nazi regime. Parliament also expressed regret for the "harm done to homosexual citizens up to 1969", the year when the notorious Paragraph 175 which outlawed homosexuality was repealed after almost 100 years on the statute books.

Most gays were sent to the Sachsenhausen concentration camp in Oranienburg, north of Berlin. At the end of the war, the few that survived Sachsenhausen war were then imprisoned for the remainder of their "Paragraph 175" sentence.

One survivor of Sachsenhausen, L.D. von Classen-Neudegg, told of life in the camp:

"We learned that we were to be segregated in a penal command and the next morning would be transferred as a unit to the Klinkerwerk [the "Brickworks", a notorious part of the Sachsenhausen camp]... We shuddered because these bone mills were more dreaded than any other work detail," he wrote.

"Guarded by staff sergeants with machine guns, we had to sprint in lines of five until we arrived... They kept beating us with rifle butts and bullwhips... Forced to drag along twenty corpses, the rest of us encrusted with blood, entered the cement quarry...Within two months, the special operation had lost two-thirds... To shoot someone "trying to escape" was a profitable business for the guards. For everyone they killed, they received five marks and three days' special furlough... When I weighed less than 40 kilos, one of the sergeants told me one morning, "Well, that's it. You want to go to the other side? It won't hurt. I'm a crack shot."



http://tinyurl.com/7usgtx2


Their lives were not in vain,
2012,
no where in the world could this be replicated.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
____
Gold Member
*****
Offline


Australian Politics

Posts: 33410
Australia
Gender: male
Re: Why should Mr Abbott allow a conscience vote?
Reply #7 - Dec 18th, 2011 at 4:28am
 
Imagine if your family published a newspaper story saying you were evil, and that the story made some neighbours feel obligated to smash your skull with rocks. There are thousands of stories like this in Africa. This one is horrific but has a happy ending.

We know there’s a crisis facing lesbian, gay and transgender people around the globe.

Homosexuality is criminal in about 77 countries, including five with the death penalty, and numbers are growing. Particularly in Africa, queer people are being terrorized into the closet, prison cells or the club-wielding hands of lynch mobs. Many religious groups exacerbate this terror to mobilize against wicked Western morals and the ‘previously unknown’ foreign import – homosexuality.

Laws against homosexuality did not exist in Africa until the late 19th Century under British colonization. Nowadays, African leaders who promote gay hatred maintain the colonialist mentality. Governments cracked down on homosexuals as a way to unite Christians and Muslims in Africa.

This could seem comical, except that modern queer Africans are fleeing homelands where they’ve been imprisoned, blackmailed or tortured because of their sexuality or gender identity. Many are physically or sexually assaulted by police or religious officials.

In 2011, the Canadian Government amended the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act and other legislation claimed to improve Canada’s asylum system for refugees.

Vancouver lawyer Rob Hughes, well-known for representing gay and lesbian refugees over the past 20 years, says Canadian law allows refugee protection for those who can demonstrate a well-founded fear of persecution. They must also prove they cannot be safe in another part of their country and that their own state government is unable or unwilling to protect them.

In Vancouver, Hughes represented newcomer Sombede Korak at a refugee hearing in 2011. Korak is a gay man who recently fled West Africa. He’s from Ghana’s second largest city, Kumasi, in the centre of the country’s Ashanti Region.

Korak’s story Although Korak is now safely in Canada, he prefers to remain anonymous and his name here is a pseudonym. This is his story.

Kumasi is the capital of Ghana’s kente cloth and gold-producing Ashanti Region. Much of Ghana’s wealth and many of its leaders come from this area. The Ashanti ethnic group is estimated to comprise 19 percent of the population, making it the largest cultural group in Ghana.

As a young Ashanti boy, Korak knew he was different. One day, after he wore his sister’s clothes on the street, his father beat him so severely it took several weeks to recover.

His adolescence was difficult, but at age 20, he met his first boyfriend. “We stole time together,” says Korak in an interview in Vancouver.

“That same year, 2001, a male relative demanded that I date a woman and have sex to prove I was a man, not a homosexual. My family forced me into a heterosexual relationship. ”

Because his 18-year-old girlfriend insisted they live together after she had twins, Korak rented two rooms. He attended the Catholic Church, hoping a Christian god might trump African traditions. “Secretly I kept seeing my boyfriend,” said Korak. His traditionalist family was happy he sired children, but after a couple of years, one of the twins died.

“Twins are a good omen, so according to Ashanti tradition, I had to perform a ceremony to make the dead child’s spirit return in the next baby. Our Ashanti religion, a mix of spiritual and supernatural powers, includes ancestor worship. Shaming the ancestors is an unforgivable sin,” he explains.

By 2008, he and his girlfriend produced another child. “Everyone agreed the baby had the same face and spirit as one that died,” he says. “Spiritual beliefs, customary practices and fetish rituals are part of everyday life in Ghana. ”

Korak was rarely home with the babies and their mother. He had a successful business and claimed his trading operation kept him absent, but all along, between 2000 and 2009, he and his boyfriend continued their relationship.

“One afternoon, my boyfriend and I were at a hotel that rented rooms by the hour. Suddenly, my boyfriend’s family broke the door and barged into the room, catching us in bed. The mother and sisters screamed and made a loud scene. There was lots of shouting."

“I ran away. Later, I tried to call my boyfriend several times, but his mobile phone was dead. That was the last time we saw each other. We’d been together nine years. ” Of course, the boyfriend’s family made sure Korak’s relatives found out he’d been caught red-handed as a homosexual.

“Oh, it was bad. In reaction, my family ordered I go to an Ashanti bush shrine to be cleansed of evil spirits. I tried to remind them I was Roman Catholic, but it did not help. They insisted I go for the shrine ritual. ”

Exorcism It is important to note these cleansing rituals are not confined just to African traditionalist religions. For the past several years in Ghana, the fastest growing evangelical and other Christian churches embrace the notion of the Devil, spirit possession and witch demonology. African leaders know that a church without exorcism or so-called deliverance sessions means empty pews.

“A different religion like being Roman Catholic made no difference,” he says. “My family insisted I be cleansed. The shrine priest would perform painful rituals to drive out the Devil and make me straight. ”

When I show Korak my photos of an Ashanti shrine 20 kilometres outside Kumasi, he shakes his head, saying that a painted shrine, a town shrine, does not hold the horror of a bush shrine.

“You have to pay money to be beaten. The priest takes you far into the bush, chains you to a large rock at the shrine, throws stones and clubs you. They would shave my head and poison me – or likely kill me in the bush shrine. Acid could be forced down my throat as part of cleansing the evil, being homosexual. Because I broke a serious taboo, they could treat me the same as a witch."

“When people die in a bush shrine there is rarely a police investigation or autopsy,” he says. Rather than undergo a cleansing ritual that was likely to kill him, Korak ran away. His family searched for him. Relatives gave a story to Ghana’s National Democrat newspaper, announcing they were hunting him for a cleansing ceremony.

The article was as good as signing a death warrant. Ashanti beliefs – that being homosexuality shamed the ancestors – meant anyone could beat him to death on sight. He was known to have an evil spirit. Some religions teach some Africans that killing a homosexual is like beating the Devil.

Realizing he could not stay hidden in Ghana, Korak applied for a visa and came to Canada as a tourist. In Vancouver, the LGBT activist group, the Rainbow Refugee Committee, helped him make an application to be accepted in Canada.

Korak must keep details of his Canadian refugee claim private for his own safety and to protect those Ghanaians who helped him, but he does reveal that after he’d arrived in Canada, a Kumasi friend mailed him a copy of the newspaper story about his family’s hunt. In a strange twist, the news story’s open invitation to violently cleanse the devil saved his life.

Rob Hughes explains: “The Canadian Immigration and Refugee Board member who heard the case said she ruled in favour because of the proven death threat [Korak] faced at home. The newspaper clipping corroborated details given earlier in the refugee application about the danger he faced. ”

Fear Despite being safely in Vancouver, Korak is still in the closet. Old beliefs die hard. He is afraid of being discovered as a homosexual by fellow Ghanaians at his Vancouver church. In a strange new land, he needs continued contact with his own culture. However, many newcomers are still socially conservative. Many still hate gays as a God-given right. He does not feel safe.

Perhaps this can be a reminder for us. Hatred and exorcisms are not confined to African traditional religions. With rapid growth of Pentecostal, charismatic and evangelical churches on that continent, they are harnessing Africans’ fear of witchcraft and supernatural powers. Both religions and governments gain power by demonizing gays and lesbians, denouncing low Western morals. It is cheaper for African governments to look engaged by passing anti-gay laws than to deliver clean water, sewage systems or education.

Media reports such as The Rachel Maddow Show document US fundamentalist churches that finance African pastors who preach against gay rights and women’s rights. African congregations see their hate-speaking pastors quoted internationally by conservative media outlets, getting publicity for outlandish pronouncements that North American pastors would be laughed at or arrested for here – and thus attracting US dollars. African pastors who say the right thing become rich and famous with American Christian help.

American money shaping African morals and African souls – another colonization of the spirit.

Meanwhile, rising immigration from conservative nations into Canada and all of North America and Europe is creating new pressures. Local fundamentalists promote homosexual hatred with evangelical fervor. For Canadian queer people, protecting the right to live safely, be treated with dignity, overcome internalized homophobia, come out and fight back against hate-mongering religious messages must remain a never-ending process.

Human rights workers and queer activists need our continued support both in Canada and around the world.

http://tinyurl.com/88y2tvy


By Abbott trying to make Heterosexuals superior to the Queer Community, via excluding from marriage by denying a conscious vote, Mr Abbott is undermining our wider community's desire to find love, peace and security in everyone's life.

Once marriage equality is achieved here, the queer community can then repair and then be a beacon to the world. We require Mr Abbott's assistance to achieve this.
Back to top
« Last Edit: Dec 18th, 2011 at 4:46am by ____ »  
 
IP Logged
 
cods
Gold Member
*****
Offline


Australian Politics

Posts: 88048
Re: Why should Mr Abbott allow a conscience vote?
Reply #8 - Dec 18th, 2011 at 5:37am
 
Dnarever wrote on Dec 17th, 2011 at 10:30pm:
Why should Mr Abbott allow a conscience vote?

You think he should stick to his normal no conscience position?

In my view every vote should be a conscience vote - any other type should be illegal.



then there would be no need for a party they would all be independents.. is that preferable?
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
cods
Gold Member
*****
Offline


Australian Politics

Posts: 88048
Re: Why should Mr Abbott allow a conscience vote?
Reply #9 - Dec 18th, 2011 at 5:43am
 
____ wrote on Dec 18th, 2011 at 4:25am:
Why, because of History and what is ahead of us :

"In recent conferences of the party, Herr Hitler emphasised a determination to stamp out sex perversion among all Nazi organisations. It was recalled that after his 'purge' of June 30, he made a pledge 'to German mothers that their sons would never be contaminated if they joined his Storm Troopers'."

This was the beginning of the Nazi purge against gays. In the following ten years, some 50,000 gays were branded as "criminals and degenerates" by the Third Reich, with between 10,000 and 15,000 being sent to concentration camps. Few survived.

Last week, the German "parliament" has decided to spend €500,000 ($613.00, £350,000) for a building in central Berlin that will be a memorial to Nazism's gay victims.

"Homosexual victims of the Nazi regime were mostly shut out of Germany's culture of remembrance in the past. That is now over,'" commented Volker Beck of Germany's Green party.

The memorial will be built along the Tiergarten Park in Berlin, close to the site of a planned Holocaust memorial.

Unlike the millions of Jews killed on the orders of Hitler's government, the gay victims of the Nazi regime have long struggled for recognition.

It was not until December 2000 that the German parliament officially apologised to gays and lesbians who were persecuted under the Nazi regime. Parliament also expressed regret for the "harm done to homosexual citizens up to 1969", the year when the notorious Paragraph 175 which outlawed homosexuality was repealed after almost 100 years on the statute books.

Most gays were sent to the Sachsenhausen concentration camp in Oranienburg, north of Berlin. At the end of the war, the few that survived Sachsenhausen war were then imprisoned for the remainder of their "Paragraph 175" sentence.

One survivor of Sachsenhausen, L.D. von Classen-Neudegg, told of life in the camp:

"We learned that we were to be segregated in a penal command and the next morning would be transferred as a unit to the Klinkerwerk [the "Brickworks", a notorious part of the Sachsenhausen camp]... We shuddered because these bone mills were more dreaded than any other work detail," he wrote.

"Guarded by staff sergeants with machine guns, we had to sprint in lines of five until we arrived... They kept beating us with rifle butts and bullwhips... Forced to drag along twenty corpses, the rest of us encrusted with blood, entered the cement quarry...Within two months, the special operation had lost two-thirds... To shoot someone "trying to escape" was a profitable business for the guards. For everyone they killed, they received five marks and three days' special furlough... When I weighed less than 40 kilos, one of the sergeants told me one morning, "Well, that's it. You want to go to the other side? It won't hurt. I'm a crack shot."



http://tinyurl.com/7usgtx2


Their lives were not in vain,
2012,
no where in the world could this be replicated.



hello woody where have you been??.. dont tell exile..

look I think most are horrified by the past and persecution for being gay..I think we have come a long way at least I havent heard of any regime in recent times persecuting gays. I for one am appalled by any persecution of any group not just gays..

its time to move on woody living in the past doesnt change the past... and to bring up this because of a vote that may go against gay marriage is a wee bit over the top I think..and takes away from the real nature of what happened then.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Ex Dame Pansi
Gold Member
*****
Offline


Australian Politics

Posts: 24168
Re: Why should Mr Abbott allow a conscience vote?
Reply #10 - Dec 18th, 2011 at 6:19am
 
I think we have come a long way at least I havent heard of any regime in recent times persecuting gays.
...............................................................

I'm sure there is at least one African country that has the death penalty if a person is proven to be homosexual......still in 2011.

We, in Australia have come a little way, we have a long way to go until we have equality.

I can't imagine the Libs ever passing an act to allow gay marriage, they are too affiliated with the church and that means loss of donations to the party.

You never know, we might get a liberal Liberal leader one day.
Back to top
 

"When the power of love overcomes the love of power, the world will know peace." Hendrix
andrei said: Great isn't it? Seeing boatloads of what is nothing more than human garbage turn up.....
 
IP Logged
 
cods
Gold Member
*****
Offline


Australian Politics

Posts: 88048
Re: Why should Mr Abbott allow a conscience vote?
Reply #11 - Dec 18th, 2011 at 6:24am
 
Ex Dame Pansi wrote on Dec 18th, 2011 at 6:19am:
I think we have come a long way at least I havent heard of any regime in recent times persecuting gays.
...............................................................

I'm sure there is at least one African country that has the death penalty if a person is proven to be homosexual......still in 2011.

We, in Australia have come a little way, we have a long way to go until we have equality.

I can't imagine the Libs ever passing an act to allow gay marriage, they are too affiliated with the church and that means loss of donations to the party.

You never know, we might get a liberal Liberal leader one day.




oh come on pansi.. I believ muslims also have a dim view....slightly less than what was happening in NAZI Germany for gods sakes..they still stone woen to death and chop off hands as well..but we are working on it..geees..the Libs can cross the floor without being expelled pansi... they are not all religious zealots.

and whats gillards excuse for being against it then?
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
olde.sault
Gold Member
*****
Offline


Australian Politics

Posts: 2913
Re: Why should Mr Abbott allow a conscience vote?
Reply #12 - Dec 18th, 2011 at 6:41am
 
cods wrote on Dec 18th, 2011 at 6:24am:
Ex Dame Pansi wrote on Dec 18th, 2011 at 6:19am:
I think we have come a long way at least I havent heard of any regime in recent times persecuting gays.
...............................................................

I'm sure there is at least one African country that has the death penalty if a person is proven to be homosexual......still in 2011.

We, in Australia have come a little way, we have a long way to go until we have equality.

I can't imagine the Libs ever passing an act to allow gay marriage, they are too affiliated with the church and that means loss of donations to the party.

You never know, we might get a liberal Liberal leader one day.




oh come on pansi.. I believ muslims also have a dim view....slightly less than what was happening in NAZI Germany for gods sakes..they still stone woen to death and chop off hands as well..but we are working on it..geees..the Libs can cross the floor without being expelled pansi... they are not all religious zealots.

and whats gillards excuse for being against it then?


Probably wouldn't have liked to have been begotten
by two women and a cold syringe.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
olde.sault
Gold Member
*****
Offline


Australian Politics

Posts: 2913
Re: Why should Mr Abbott allow a conscience vote?
Reply #13 - Dec 18th, 2011 at 6:46am
 
cods wrote on Dec 18th, 2011 at 6:24am:
Ex Dame Pansi wrote on Dec 18th, 2011 at 6:19am:
I think we have come a long way at least I havent heard of any regime in recent times persecuting gays.
...............................................................

I'm sure there is at least one African country that has the death penalty if a person is proven to be homosexual......still in 2011.

We, in Australia have come a little way, we have a long way to go until we have equality.

I can't imagine the Libs ever passing an act to allow gay marriage, they are too affiliated with the church and that means loss of donations to the party.

You never know, we might get a liberal Liberal leader one day.




oh come on pansi.. I believ muslims also have a dim view....slightly less than what was happening in NAZI Germany for gods sakes..they still stone woen to death and chop off hands as well..but we are working on it..geees..the Libs can cross the floor without being expelled pansi... they are not all religious zealots.

and whats gillards excuse for being against it then?


Maybe she wouldn't have liked to have been begotten by two women and a cold syringe.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Armchair_Politician
Gold Member
*****
Offline


Australian Politics

Posts: 29304
Gender: male
Re: Why should Mr Abbott allow a conscience vote?
Reply #14 - Dec 18th, 2011 at 7:00am
 
cods wrote on Dec 17th, 2011 at 8:55pm:
has gillard actually spelt out why she is against it??.. we know she doesnt believe in religion.. so what is her reason??..as for Abboitt no he doesnt have to do anything... if the libs are so in favour of it they cn still cross the floor..when it comes up.. it will be interesting to see if anyone does..I am wondering what will happen to her if the vote goes against her..she is very much dependent on the libs NOT crossing the floor..mmmmmm


Her reason is political - she thinks the majority of voting Australians are against it, so she's decided to jump on that side of the fence. Abbott's stance on the other hand is both religious and personal - but not political. Like him or not, at least he talks on this particular subject from the heart, Gillard from the head (and a rather cavernous one, at that).
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Pages: 1 2 3 
Send Topic Print