Quote:Here in Australia and the US aswell we have always had an independant media so it comes as expected that the media not be tied to governments.
I gotta disagree there. Our media is extremely biased towards our world view, and always has been. They do try to project an aura of objectivity, but that actually makes it worse, since in reality it's not objective at all, yet deludes a lot of people into thinking it is. But because they sometimes publish the nitty gritty details of the failings of some when it's in the interests of the internal politics of the country or some other powerbrokers to do so, they do.
Quote:Invariably everybody has tehir own bias, and even entire media have bias towards certain things.
Agreed, but a news outlet like al-Jazeerah has a lot less reason to be biased. It's not tied to any great supwerpower or world view that has a deep interest in promoting a certain agenda. Some have tried to claim this about Islam, but al-Jazeerah has no interest in promoting Islam at all, and this is quite obvious in the fact that many of the infamous speakers against Islam, like Wafa Sultan, have had their start on al-Jazeerah.
Quote:But tell me hpow many reporters on Al Jazeera openly support Israel??
The fact you'd ask such a preposterous question just highlights how biased you yourself must be. Openly supporting or not supporting Israel is no measure of how biased a media outlet is, anymore than asking "how many reporters on fox news openly support Hamas" is a measure of how biased fox news is.
Quote:whilst their is a wider range of views on the station than available from reporters on state controlled media.
A wide range of views also doesn't give us an accurate measure of how biased a media outlet is. The most varied of views could still all be biased.
Quote:Their is not the cosmopolitin view that you get from western media.
Come on you gotta be kidding. The Western media, with the exception of the trashy tabloids, and the occasional leftist leaning outlet pretty much all carry the exact same stories. I've worked within one of Australia's largest media outlets, and I'm well aware how they get their media. It's all fed to them by the exact same source that most other Western media outlets get the bulk of their news from. They then put a little network-specific spin on it, re-package it and send it out as their own product.
There's nothing "cosmopolitan" about it at all. And this is the reason al-Jazeerah English has been such a hit, because finally someone is broadcasting real news in English, free from the constraints of the mass media and it's positions.
Just as an example, look at the coverage from the the conflict between Israel and the Palestinians. Whenever an Israeli victim is shown, you get an image of a human being, just like you or me, you hear about their family situation, about their hopes and aspirations for the future etc. Yet whenever you hear about Palestinian victims, you just hear of them as 1 of a number, faceless statistics... The Western media is not even interested in telling their stories. They don't bother (except on the rare occasion, and mostly since several well researched documentaries exposed this glaring bias) to follow up the personal angle of the Palestinian victims whatsoever. Yet almost every single time we hear about Israelis, we get a very in depth picture of their life and their humanity. I'd suggest watching
"Peace propaganda and the Promised land" for a well researched report about this, the bias of the Western media on this issue alone is just striking, yet few ever realise it.
Quote:the SMH or the Australian you are likely to read on teh same day a story from a reporter with every type of veiw possible, from Israel is the demon of the earth to they are the worlds greatest nation.
This just shows that the SMH has several biased views, rather than not being biased. You need to realise the difference between these two things. Just having a range of views, doesn't make them not biased.
And I've never come across an article in the Western media which portrays Israel as the demon of the earth. I think you're being a little excessive there.
Quote:This is something you will never get on Al Jazeera.
That's right, because al-Jazeerah doesn't promote biased views in either direction. It's reporters are under strict guidelines to just report what's there, not what fits in their personal views or beliefs or what's in accordance with their government's position in the world.
Quote:That is why they are biased, because each reporter, even unintentioanllly is from too similar a point of view.
al-Jazeerah has reporters from all over the world. al-Jazeerah english especially has a very wide range of backgrounds for their reporters. And even those of Muslim background are mostly Westerners anyway like Riz Khan, who was a former BBC presenter, and has grown up in the West all his life, being born actually in the British colony in Yemen. But the vast bulk of them are not Muslims nor Arabs.