Racist pub bans Arabs, Islanders
Exclusive by Shoba Rao

May 03, 2007 12:00

SECURITY staff at one of Sydney's most popular pubs were ordered to refuse entry to patrons of particular ethnic backgrounds in a racist exclusion policy designed to cut crime.

The owner of Scruffy Murphy's Irish pub in the CBD admitted yesterday he had implemented a policy in 2005 denying entry to patrons of Middle Eastern and Pacific Islander origin.

Malcolm McGuinness told the NSW Equal Opportunity Tribunal the exclusion edict was introduced after police threatened to impose sanctions on his hotel after a series of incidents.

The publican and T&B Security Services director Tibi Brandusoiu are being sued by two would-be patrons of Pacific Islander origin for damages for racial discrimination.

Have you been discriminated against because of your background? Tell us via the feedback form below.

Mr McGuinness said the exclusion policy – introduced in November 2005 and scrapped early last year – was designed to prevent problems "related to gangs" and in "my viewpoint it was not discriminating".

"Once we implemented this policy, assaults were reduced," he said.

Samoan Benji Tupou, 31, of Maroubra, told the tribunal he was twice refused entry to Scruffy Murphy's in 2005 because of his ethnic background.

Mr Tupou alleged that on the first occasion, he was pulled out of a queue by a Polynesian security guard who told him: "Yep, no Islanders."

Five months later he tried again. This time he was approached by a member of the security staff who asked: "What nationality are you?"

When Mr Tupou replied: "I'm Samoan or Niuean", the bouncer replied: "Seriously boys, I don't know how to say this, but you guys can't come in to the hotel."

Asked why, the doorman exclaimed: "No Islanders or Lebanese."

Mr Tupou said he had been humiliated by the refusal. "It was belittling to be treated in this way. I was angry about how I was treated," he said.

Also giving evidence yesterday was Marcellus Cook, a New Zealand Maori, who claimed he was refused entry.

Lawyer David Hillard, representing both men, told the tribunal the hotel had made an "uncontested concession" that it breached the Anti-Discrimination Act by refusing entry to Mr Cook at a time when the exclusion policy was in place.

Bryce Cross, counsel for Scruffy Murphy's, told the tribunal that, in Mr Cook's case only, the hotel conceded breaching the Act.

"We have been consistent in the concession that persons not known to staff of Middle Eastern and Pacific Islander appearance were not allowed in to the hotel," he said.

The hearing continues.

Is that illegal ?

Unfortunate but fact that Islanders on alcohol are a problem.
They are big strong boys, so when they fight, is quite something else.

I used to come from N.Z. , lots of islanders there. That has been my experience.

What caused the bans? Two options:

1) The way the Lebanese and Islanders acted?
2) Or the way they look?

I'd imagine it's the way Islanders and Lebanese tend to act that got them banned.

DT, that is pretty much a textbook definition of racism that you are trying to pass off as 'anti-multiculturalism'.

You are judging people based on their race, not their individual merits.

Sprintcyclist wrote on May 3^rd, 2007 at 11:15am:


so just because Islanders are bigger it gives the pub the right to deny them entry.
being bigger doesn't mean that they are violent.

sure, people can get violent when they are drunk, but pubs are allowed to cut you off if they think u have had enough. that's what should be done, rather than denying them entry.

denying entry based on ethnicity is pure racism.