freediver wrote on Jan 29
th, 2020 at 7:14pm:
You are confused Gandalf. I never said I think it is wrong.
And I never claimed that you did. What I did claim you said is exactly what you said in the quote I posted in reply# 12.
freediver wrote on Jan 29
th, 2020 at 7:14pm:
You are confused Gandalf. People don't start new threads to distract from the topic.
They do when they don't even mention the topic, and dishonestly pretend that its about something else.
Here I'll remind you what the actual topic is again - your idiotic claim that all muslims support genocide and your idiotic mental gymnastics to claim that its somehow both 'true' and 'theoretically wrong' at the same time.
Funny you don't actually mention what I was referring to when you cherry picked my quote in the OP.
Funny how you've never responded to this when I've pointed out to you repeatedly in this thread. And I'm the one doing 'hey look over there', apparently.
freediver wrote on Jan 29
th, 2020 at 7:14pm:
Is this the correct hierarchy of fallibility Gandalf:
1) God
2) Gandalf, infallible on all topics unless he caveats what he says by acknowledging the theoretical possibility he is wrong.
3) Muhammad, infallible only on matters of Islamic doctrine.
4) Everyone else, who ought to refrain from saying anything just in case Gandalf gets confused about the philosophical implications of mere mortals saying things without first deluding themselves that they are infallible.
?
Do you place yourself above Muhammad?
I am not infalible FD, I never claimed I was. That was your idiotic projection that had nothing to do with what I actually said. And what I said is just plain common sense - don't state something as fact that you acknowledge might not be fact. And if you do want to state it, you need to caveat it with your acknowledgement that it might not be fact. And if I was to state something as fact, I would only do it if I was sure it was actually fact. But unlike you, I don't go around throwing statements of fact around willy nilly. Are you keeping up FD? Please let me know if you are still having trouble with this concept.
Do you stand by your claim (again, quoted in reply# 12) that the claim "all muslims support genocide" is "true"? And if so, can you explain how you can also acknowledge "It is theoretically possible that I am wrong" at the same time?
Think carefully about this one FD. You wouldn't want to be seen to be dodging the question again now would you?