The reaction of Dusty Miller is something I've been struggling to put into words for many years..
The best I can come up with is that while there is a deep personal confidence and pride in having done a job and done things that few can even imagine, there remains, at the heart of every good man, a lasting remorse, regret and even guilt over the necessity of having to do those things (and that is outside of these criminal acts alleged - those are in a different category).
You see that in the interview with Dusty Miller, and also in the interviews with Dick Winter of Band of Brothers and quite a few others.....
Very.. VERY ... few tip so far over the edge that they commit the kind of crimes pointed out - as the interviews with other members will show clearly - they want no part of it and feel it is a disgrace - not only on The Regiment, but on the Australian Army as well... and their view that it goes to the top is a fair one....
The killing of prisoners has always been a part of war, often an under-mentioned and even unspoken one, and the US Army reached its peak with the German massacres in the Ardennes and then the NVA .... and responded largely in kind (as did the British and Canadian armies) ... the difference between 'us' and 'them' is that we view such things as crimes - they did and do not.
Anyway - comparing the SAS and Commandoes and Infantry committed to that war, to the SS etc - ifs fatuous... these actions are not part of policy.... though there can be a tendency to just cover it over if and when it happens, for many reasons, not least of which is the age-old thing of 'obey first - protest later'... which is not really workable, and then there is the SOP of - say - removing hands for clear identification of a fallen Muj when taking the body is too difficult and photos may not be workable ........
Such decisions are easy to criticise from a desk... vision after the event, especially if it becomes public - is always 20/20, but the fact remains it is still going to happen at times, for operational reasons.
On the one hand, I am warming to young Hastie - on the other, he should have said - the blame stops with me over the hand removing incident... which is not as uncommon as you may imagine...
P.S. I didn't hear any names mentioned... it's sub judice at the moment... in the hands of the AFP...