Gandalf have you ever met a Muslim who does not support genocide?
Do you think that being so well versed in justifying and supporting Muhammad's genocide contributes to modern genocides committed by Muslims?
Quote:I'm suggesting its not a genocide because it was an alleged standard run-of-the-mill mass execution of prisoners.
So all you have to do to avoid a charge of genocide is imprison the whole tribe first?
It seems a little strange to use terms like standard and run-of-the mill to describe the mass execution of prisoners.
Quote:It obviously trivialises the intended meaning of genocide which is wholesale indiscriminate killing of an entire ethnic/cultural group - men, women and children.
The tribe ceased to exist as a cultural group after all the men were executed.
Quote:Slaughtering 6 million jews in a deliberate effort to eliminate the entire jewish population counts as genocide. Putting to death a few hundred soldiers for collusion with the enemy - is not.
How did Muhammad identify the soldiers? By inspecting their genitals?