Quote:Thats exactly what you asked FD.
Did the constitution of Medina apply to all pagans? Or are you doing the slippery Muslim trick and pretending I was asking what rights he granted to a specific group of pagans?
Quote:You don't specify that it can't be 'temporary' or done only in a position of weakness.
Is this what Muslims mean when they say they support human rights? Is this what they mean when they say Dhimmitude is against oppression - unless they specify always and for all people, they merely mean as and when it suits the Islamist agenda?
Quote:And no, there is no evidence that pagans lost any of the rights Muhammad granted them.
What about the ones that want to visit their pagan shrine in Mecca?
Quote:My understanding is that Muhammad didn't slaughter any jews - save for perhaps maybe a dozen or so
Down from a few hundred eh? Why the need for your embarrassing mindless collective of treacherous Jews meme?
Quote:There is also no evidence he committed the genocide against pagans you constantly allude to.
Can we start with what I actually said?
Let's try again for a straight answer eh?
Other than converting or dying, what legal rights did Muhammad extend to Pagans?
Did the Jews have the right to keep their head attached to their body?
When Muhammad first came into a position where he could get away with slaughtering people, and he celebrated by publicly threatening to slaughter the Medina Jews if they did not convert to Islam, was he defending their right to convert to Islam, or their right to die?