The USGS study:
Quote:The El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) explains much of the interannual variability in sea surface temperature, sea-level pressure and atmospheric forcing across the equatorial Pacific, affecting global climate patterns and economies. For example, global economic losses associated with the extreme El Niño of 1982–1983 have been estimated at over US$11.5 billion (in 2016 dollars), including significant losses along the coast. The extremes of ENSO oscillations, El Niño and La Niña, have been linked to elevated coastal hazards, particularly during boreal winter (December-February) for the Eastern North Pacific (for example, Hawaii, California, . . . and the Oregon and Washington and Southwestern Pacific (for example, New Zealand and Australia). El Niño events have also been associated with hazardous coastal conditions in Japan during the boreal fall, greater frequency of tropical cyclone development in the Eastern Pacific and rotational shifts of embayed beaches in Australia. With seasonally elevated water levels, higher wave energy and southerly wave directional shifts common during El Niño, the North American west coast has historically experienced severe coastal erosion during El Niño winters, as reported during the 1982–1983, 1997–1998 and 2009–2010 events.
All this extensively footnoted in the study. El Nino and La Nina bring drought and flooding to opposite sides of the Pacific, hence the huge economic cost especially of large El Nino events. Add to this the enhanced erosion threatening coastal communities. Then add rising sea levels as land ice continues and even accelerates melting.
Quote:By various metrics, the 2015–2016 El Niño winter was one of the three strongest events in the historical record. For example, in the boreal winter of 2015–2016 the Oceanic Niño Index, a 3-month running mean of sea surface temperatures in the eastern tropical Pacific, reached the highest value in its 66-year history
When the seas absorb more and more heat, as they are, stronger El Nino events are not unexpected.
Quote:By various metrics, the 2015–2016 El Niño winter was one of the three strongest events in the historical record17. For example, in the boreal winter of 2015–2016 the Oceanic Niño Index, a 3-month running mean of sea surface temperatures in the eastern tropical Pacific18, reached the highest value in its 66-year history (Fig. 1a). Based on a reconstruction that dates back to 1871 for the multivariate ENSO index19, a comprehensive assessment of conditions in the tropical Pacific Ocean20—which is significantly correlated with wave energy flux across the Eastern North Pacific5—the 2015–2016 winter was only exceeded by the similarly powerful El Niño events of 1982–1983 and 1997–1998 (Fig. 1b)
The three strongest El Ninos have been from 1982/3 on.
Quote:The study analyzes two decades of winter oceanographic forcing across the US West Coast, focusing on the response of 29 beaches along the California, Oregon and Washington coasts, fronting a population of ≈25 million.
Be nice if there was a corresponding study on Australasian beaches.
Quote:The wave climate in the Eastern North Pacific varies seasonally, with larger waves in the fall and winter months driven by the development and passage of extra-tropical cyclones across the mid-latitudes . . . . High pressure dominates in the spring and summer months, with prevailing northwesterly winds and southern hemisphere storms typically resulting in lower wave energy conditions.
Pretty obvious, winter storms in mid latitude eastern Pacific generate bigger waves while storms on the other side of the Pacific result in much less wave energy on the eastern Pacific in the NH summer.
Quote:As a key driver of coastal change, mean and elevated (that is, top 5%) wave energy flux (a function of wave height and period, see Methods), were ∼50% above normal averaged across all regions during the 2015–2016 El Niño winter. During the 19 years of analysis, mean wave energy flux was only exceeded by the 1997–1998 El Niño (61% above normal), but elevated wave energy flux in 2015–2016 was the highest on record.
Yup, the biggest waves do the most damage and those come (in US West coast) El Nino years. Quite understandable, really. So more and stronger El Ninos are going to do severe erosion and flood damage.
Quote:An unusual aspect of the 2015–2016 oceanographic conditions was the lack of a regionally consistent wave direction anomaly typical of prior El Niño . . . . In . . . 2015–2016 . . . the Southern California region did experience a marked northerly shift in elevated wave energy flux direction of 18° and 24° relative to the 1997–1998 and 2009–2010 winters, respectively, while Oregon recorded a southerly shift of 10° relative to the mean
So ever stronger, higher more destructive waves coming from different directions. How do you erect coastal defences?
cont’d