Soren wrote on Feb 17
th, 2014 at 4:09pm:
Mattyfisk wrote on Feb 17
th, 2014 at 9:48am:
Soren wrote on Feb 5
th, 2014 at 7:32pm:
greggerypeccary wrote on Feb 5
th, 2014 at 6:13pm:
More from the Islamophobic Restore Australia.
Run by One Nation's Mike Holt.
If you ask him nicely, he'll sell you some anti-halal stickers.
Which part of the actual text to you disagree with?
Or are you flying on emotion correctness, as usual?
Pull yourself together, old boy.
There are about 3 Islamic states in the world today, possibly a few more if we include territories and local governments. For most Muslims, Islam is solely a religion. For most, Islam is as much a political movement as Leviticus-following, or desert-wandering, Jews.
And for those who are Muslims, Islam has as much hold over their lives as church-going Christians. They follow the festivals, perform a few rituals, and get on with the business of raising their kids and paying off their mortgages.
For a few fundamentalists - largely in the West - Islam is a cult. They attach themselves to independence struggles and generally make a lot of noise. Abu was a good example of this sort of cult-follower. In practice, most of them do nothing but talk.
The ones who do more than talk are far less dangerous than the.myriad of cold war independence struggles and troublemakers that marked the last 60 years. Most are tracked and caught. Most stuff up before they’re caught. They all talk.
So yes, old boy, your energy is wasted. Try to exert it on the production of lunch, One old boy stool for table one.
Coming right up.
Bollocks. To say that Muslims are like Christians in the secular West is utter bollocks.
Even in cuddly and 'moderate' Malaysia and Indonesia, the push for sharia is significant. There is no push for the restoration of the Papal States across Europe and the West, there is no push for restoring ecclesiastical courts in place of secular ones, there are no political parties anywhere in the West that push for the return to the glorious 3rd century when Chritianity became the state religion of the Roman Empire.
In the absence of established separation of politics and religion (state and religion) in Islamic countries, you cannot draw any meaningful parallel between Westerners and Muslims.
And they don't just talk - look at Libya, Egypt, Syria, Saudi, Pakistan, Iraq, Iran, Yemen - in fact in every Muslim country, religion is at the centre of politic and public life.
http://www.pewforum.org/files/2013/04/gsi2-chp2-4.pnghttp://www.pewforum.org/2013/04/30/the-worlds-muslims-religion-politics-society-... And if you asked Christians in the US Bible belt the same question, you'd get a significant number too. Christians in the US have been encroaching into the state since Reagan. Their reasoning for small government is to give religion a bigger role.
And yes, a minority have been involved in significant acts of terrorism.
The social phenomenon you're describing is not confined to one religion. It's a problem with the rise of fundamentalism. I include atheist fundamentalism here too. Dawkins and Hitchens are just as dogmatic in their views as any Christian or Muslim. Their dichotomous stance towards religion creates conflict and a hardening of views.
Fundamentalism has risen due to the dearth of ethics within the current stage of capitaism. People are looking for "answers". They'll only get answers to the questions they ask, of course, and this is the role of religion - to ask the questions. Our reified economic model is devoid of connections, which makes people look for them.
In feudalism, you had planting and harvest festivals, you asked the Supreme being for rain, and you thanked Him for grain. The answers to your questions came with the seasons. You could see and touch Gud's work, and your family and community brought in the fruits of your labour together.
Within capitalism, goods and services are assembled piecemeal. Your bank's call centre is in the Philippines. Your shoes are made in Vietnam. Your food is grown somewhere - you have no idea where. Our human connections are beyond our knowledge, and this makes us want answers. It leads us to metaphysics, and as Weber said, the gates of the church are always open.
The religions who address this question of alienation are the most successful in recruiting. Fixed, hierarchical structures; organised and controlled. This, after all, is what people are looking for. The sense of purpose in these religions is unwavering. For some, the closer they skirt to death, the better - this risk is an important part of the message.
Whether it's Christianity, Islam, or even the atheist fundamentalist movements of the Cold War - Bader Meinhoff, the Red Brigade, Black September - the issue is not their beliefs, but their fundamentalism.