abu_rashid wrote on Dec 1
st, 2012 at 3:08pm:
freediver wrote on Dec 1
st, 2012 at 2:40pm:
Ironically, it was Muslim Arab countries that pushed a lot of the Jews into Israel - nearly a million of them. It was one of the biggest forced migrations in modern history. This dwarfed the number of Jews that migrated to Israel to escape the holocaust (which Abu constantly complains was illegal). These are the same countries that refuse to take Muslim Arab refugees from the area.
More of your fantasy alternate reality I see fd? The vast majority of Jews living in occupied Palestine are not from Arab countries. Please get your facts and figures straight.
Funnily enough, it was your own evidence that allerted me to this Abu - the evidence you presented in trying to back up your mass illegal immigration claim. The Arab Muslim countries contributed nearly 1 million Jewish immigrations. You are right though, the majority were probably born there - all the more reason to 'send them home' eh?
Quote:And it's irrelevant anyway, Arab countries expelled them when they began expelling Palestinians
Oh dear, there you go with that collective punishment thing again Abu. It's always funny watching you complain so bitterly when this happens to Muslims. I hope you are paying attention Gandalf - this is Islam does to previously rational people.
Quote:Let me ask you something fd, if Muslims invaded Australia, UK or US, and expelled most of the Anglos from those lands and pushed the rest into refugee camps, do you think Muslims would be safe in other Anglo countries?
We kept many German, Japanese etc POWs in the wars. This is hardly the same as expelling them then complaining about where they end up.
Quote:Or do you think they'd either 1) be smart and leave, or 2) be expelled anyway?
What do you think Abu?
Quote:I know you won't answer, because you consistently refuse to consider any analogy which places the shoe on the other foot with your own arguments...
It's called a loaded question Abu. As I have already pointed out, most are so absurd that they are completely irrelevant.