Quote:So in that situation it is true?
In certain contexts it could form part of the foreign policy of an Islamic Caliphate yes. Not in all situations. It is for those states who act with hostility towards the Caliphate.
Quote:Regardless of whether it can help take over the country, it is still a stupid idea that denies people fundamental rights.
It doesn't deny anyone anything. It would be completely voluntary. Such a system exists in Britain now for Jews and Halakhic law, is it stupid? does it deny anyone their fundamental rights?
Not sure if you've noticed, but I am not an advocate of these token courts, but the way they're being spoken about here is completely irrational and hate-filled.
Quote:Abu, this is how freedom of speech works. People can say what they want. If they say something stupid, you criticise them for it.
Well I personally don't see that I have any responsibility to criticise them for it.
If you can show me how I do, then I'm all ears...
Quote:This is not the same as letting Islamic lunatics preach hatred and violence and the 'mainstream' Islamic community using it as an excuse to sit idly by.
If they are preaching hatred and violence, then surely they'll be charged right?
If Aussie-nationalists preach hatred and violence, are you under and obligation to seek them out and put a stop to them?
Sorry, but I thought that's what the law enforcement was there for? Or are you under some weird delusion that non-Muslims aren't obligated to do that, but Muslims are?
Muslims are supposed to form their own vigilante groups, and spend their time hunting down anyone who says something that fd doesn't agree with? Seriously, you're a whacko.
Quote:To suggest so merely reinforces your failure to understand Australian values.
I think you're the one failing to understand them.
And then inventing some supposed extra obligation that Muslims only must fulfil.
Quote:So you will make no attempt to prevent a fellow Muslim from carrying out acts of violence until they actually break the law, and even then you will do nothing because it is the responsibility of the police, not you?
This question operates under the delusion that all Muslims somehow know eachother, and mention to eachother their planning of mass acts of violence, in passing conversation.
Honestly, get a grip on yourself.
Besides the topic is about a political movement, not a violent movement, try to remain generally in context if possible.