mozzaok
Gold Member
Offline
OzPolitic
Posts: 6741
Melbourne
Gender:
|
Poor Donald, the misunderstood xenophobe.
As far as the issue of Tyler's death is concerned, their is no reason to believe the police had any racial motive for shooting Tyler, as opposed to Martin Luther King, a black, civil rights leader, assassinated while in the middle of the world's biggest ever civil rights campaign, I would think even somewhat as ill equipped to follow logical reasoning, as yourself, could spot the difference there.
Your trying to make the point that his reported altercation earlier that day, contributed to his agitated state of mind, which almost certainly, made him a far greater threat.
So it is worth noting the incident, but until further information is available, it is hard to make a balanced judgement of where, and how much blame, gets attached to the incident.
Now Ammad, I have always agreed that this was a tragedy, and I would have far preferred to see the police having been able to safely subdue him. I have always thought that serious questions needed to be asked about how they came to use such a high degree of force, but I also felt that to prejudge them, which is what you did, was grossly unfair.
If, after an enquiry, and all the facts come to light, any blame is apportioned the police, then would be the right time to make criticisms of them.
I certainly think the idea of attaching malevolent intent to their actions is the most unfair aspect of criticism of them.
Ultimately, we must accept that the boy did threaten people, police and citizens, with death threats, he was armed, and he resisted violently, when non lethal means were tried to subdue him.
Even if the police are found not to have used perfect judgement, Tyler's actions are the ones that precipitated this unfortunate tragedy.
|