Ok I'll give it a shot.
I have the graphic novel (comic) but decided not to read it till after the film. Is it any good? Well i might go see it again, but then that's me. I think some people will either love it or hate it. I almost love it, there are many things to like about it. Apart from the characters who are all played wonderfully. IMO.
Watch for the scene where Night Owl drops down from his ship, watch his cape. That's an image that sticks with me. It's the little things that make this worth going to see.
Watchmen is a stunning and vivid adaptation of Moore's work. It's closer to Batman in its darkness than perhaps any other movie so far from this genre. The special effects are great and seemless. The same director brought us 300, and I think this is a step up from that.
It is set on an alternate Earth whose history is similar to ours and yes, they have superheroes or should I say costumed vigilantes. Point being that these "superheroes" are after all just human, with human needs and foibles. I like the fact that it is structured a bit like 1950s film noir, detective story.
The script is dense with dialogue as well as action and some of the action is violent and quite graphic. The cutting between times and characters will require you to pay attentiion otherwise you could get a bit confused. That said it doesn't drain your brain and you wont walk out feeling fatigued or with a headache.
Watchmen is not light entertainment, how could a political satire with shades of philosophy about the human condition ever be. The music is another highlight of the film, Bob Dylan's,
The Times they are a Changin'
, over the opening montage and Simon and Garfunkel's,
The Sounds of Silence
over a funeral, hit the mark, and only add to the moment.
Many people have problems with movies over 90 mins these days, I don't know why, but it runs for over 160 mins, trust me, it will not seem that long. Enjoy the ride.
If I had to rate it, I'd give it
7 out of 10
.