Forum

 
  Back to OzPolitic.com   Welcome, Guest. Please Login or Register
  Forum Home Album HelpSearch Recent Rules LoginRegister  
 

Page Index Toggle Pages: 1
Send Topic Print
Sydney trains world's worst (Read 2359 times)
skeptic
Full Member
***
Offline


OzPolitic

Posts: 188
Sydney trains world's worst
Mar 21st, 2007 at 11:23am
 
Sydney trains world's worst
By Heath Aston, Transport Reporter

March 21, 2007 12:00

SYDNEY'S train system is a global laughing stock, with performance levels hopelessly below every major city from Europe to South America, according to a damning independent report buried by CityRail.

Rail experts from Hong Kong were paid by CityRail to compare Sydney with metro systems around the world for efficiency, cost effectiveness, reliability and maintenance.

They found that Sydney lags behind every city on every key indicator – even compared with the rail systems of Santiago in Chile, Bangkok and Moscow.

The results are so embarrassing that, despite having received the report midway through last year, CityRail chief executive Vince Graham still hasn't presented the findings to the RailCorp board or Transport Minister John Watkins.

The findings include:


CITYRAIL trains travel on average just 32km before getting delayed more than five minutes, whereas trains in Hong Kong travel 396km before being delayed;


CITYRAIL'S operating costs are a whopping $6.70 per passenger, compared with 98c in Europe and 69c in Asia;


THE cost of running a Sydney train station is four times the international average; and


CITYRAIL drivers are behind the controls for less than three hours of any seven-hour l shift compared with nearly five in Hong Kong.

Premier Morris Iemma today dismissed as "not valid" the government-commissioned report and claimed the report had made unfair comparisons.
"The comparisons in the report are just not valid," he said at Kingscliff in the marginal northern NSW electorate of Tweed, where he was campaigning today for Saturday's state election.

"To compare the Sydney network, with some 2000 kilometres of track, with the Moscow track which has some 200 is not a valid comparison, nor is the comparison with Hong Kong at 56 stations and the CityRail network with more than 300.

"However, the government has heard the message loud and clear that the people do want their services improved and expanded and rail is the government's number one priority."



Surfacing just a week after the network meltdown that trapped 4000 commuters and stranded 40,000 more, the confidential report by Hong Kong's Mass Transit Railway Corporation vindicates the public perception that Sydney's system is woefully inadequate.

"CityRail shows high overall cost as well as high station staff cost compared to MTR and other railways, coupled with relatively low efficiency," the authors note.

"Reliability levels are well below MTR and international benchmarks."

Last night Mr Graham said the spread of Sydney's network made comparisons with more compact metros fraught.

"This increases the operating costs of the RailCorp network when compared to other rail systems," he said.

"As an example, the London Underground has almost four times the patronage of the RailCorp system (1 billion compared with 275 million), with less than half the network size."

RailCorp executives are well aware of London's peculiarities.

Sources at RailCorp said Station Operations Manager Tony Eid returned this week from a month-long trip to study the Underground.

Last year 17 RailCorp executives flew to mainly European destinations for conferences at a cost to the taxpayer of $250,000.

Despite the insistence of Mr Graham, Mr Watkins and Premier Morris Iemma that CityRail's service is improving, commuters are still waiting too long – particularly in the afternoon peak.

Transport Minister John Watkins said last night he had not been shown the report.

"This report by an overseas operator is clearly flawed and that is why it has not been presented to the Government," he said.

Rail unions last night said they expect RailCorp will use the findings to justify slashing up to 1000 more station staff after Saturday's election.

Contacted in Hong Kong yesterday, MTR declined to comment
Back to top
« Last Edit: Dec 30th, 2007 at 1:22pm by ozadmin »  
 
IP Logged
 
freediver
Gold Member
*****
Offline


www.ozpolitic.com

Posts: 47043
At my desk.
NSW train faults quadruple, report says
Reply #1 - Dec 30th, 2007 at 1:29pm
 
http://news.smh.com.au/nsw-train-faults-quadruple-report-says/20071229-1jgw.html

The number of faults on Sydney's trains has nearly quadrupled, and there were nearly 1,000 collisions, a public transport watchdog has found.

The report says the NSW government faces a major challenge to upgrade the network to allow for both the planned new CityRail fleet and large freight trains.

On Sydney's trains last year 436 faults were found but this year there were 1,693 faults, according to the Annual Transport Industry Safety and Reliability Reports.

The safety report also recorded 217 incidents of drivers passing a red light, 337 cases of signal failure and 181 train fires.

In terms of safety 366 passengers have been seriously endured and seven of eight fatalities arose from injuries to trespassers.
Back to top
 

I identify as Mail because all I do is SendIT!
WWW  
IP Logged
 
RecFisher
Senior Member
****
Offline


OzPolitic

Posts: 347
Re: Sydney trains world's worst
Reply #2 - Jan 2nd, 2008 at 9:12pm
 
It's good to see Sydney winning something again.  It's been a bit quiet since the 2000 Olympics.  Sure, there was APEC, but that was more like just a rotation thing rather than a win.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Page Index Toggle Pages: 1
Send Topic Print