Ministers must answer why Social Services keep breaking the law   :(
2026-01-27
greens.org.au
Today’s Commonwealth Ombudsman Report finding that Services Australia and the Department of Social Services has been non-compliant with social security law regarding child support for the past six years shows a Department which has learned nothing from Robodebt and is seemingly incapable of administering the law.

As the Ombudsman notes in their report today, “Knowingly and deliberately not complying with the law was at the heart of Robodebt.”, yet the Government has persistent issues with following social services law, often to the harm of welfare recipients.

Last year, two separate Commonwealth Ombudsman inquiries and an external review from Deloitte could not assure the lawfulness of the Targeted Compliance Framework, under which over a hundred thousand welfare payments are withheld from recipients every month under the system known as ‘mutual obligations’.

Despite Labor Ministers being unable to assure the lawfulness of the mutual obligations system, the government continues to suspend vast numbers of payments each month (learn more).

The Government was also forced to introduce legislation last year to retrospectively legalise the collection of over $1 billion of welfare debts after it was found that the method used to calculate debts for years was unlawful.

Regarding the child support law issue raised in the Ombudsman’s report, the Greens have sought a briefing from the government on legislation planned to be introduced to the Parliament in February.

Lines attributable to Senator Penny Allman-Payne, Greens spokesperson for Social Services:

“This will be the second time in just six months that the government has sought to rush through retrospective laws to cover the fact they can’t administer the welfare system legally.”

“Labor can’t even say if a core part of their welfare system is lawful, yet they continue to use that system of ‘mutual obligations’ to unlawfully suspend over a hundred thousand welfare payments from people who need them every month.”

“How can anyone trust that our welfare system is being administered correctly and fairly when the government keeps on breaking its own laws, and can hide it for six years?”

“When families on income support break the rules, they get the book thrown at them, but when the government does it it’s like it never happened.”

“Robodebt showed us what happens when the government breaks its own laws without consequence, and it’s clear the Department has not learned its lesson.”

“It’s time Labor took responsibility for their own Departments and brought them in line with the law, including abolishing the unlawful mutual obligations system now.”

Robodebt was a great idea.

Future  AI platforms should be able to monitor welfare recipients much more closely and pick up every cash transaction.
Hopefully these systems can automatically withdraw money from the accounts of any cheats and forward it on to the noble small businesses that keep the economy afloat

aquascoot wrote on Jan 27^th, 2026 at 3:26pm:

Robodebt was a great idea. Future  AI platforms should be able to monitor welfare recipients much more closely and pick up every cash transaction. Hopefully these systems can automatically withdraw money from the accounts of any cheats and forward it on to the noble small businesses that keep the economy afloat

Why am I not surprised you'd say something like that?

I'm betting you probably believe all the deaths that Robodebt caused were great as well.

Just when you thought feminism and its bastard children were the zenith of danger to the West - that it couldn't get any more dangerous - along comes Artificial Intelligence with all its vast numbers of potential disasters against which nobody has any defence.

Long ago someone said:- " How do you challenge a company?  It has no shin to kick and no nose to punch!"

Imagine how much worse it WILL be under AI ...

Now - to Social Security - Robojudge has deemed that you have been overpaid $79.6 million in fiscal year 2026-2027 ... please arrange repayment forthwith or consequences will follow.


   1159 hours ..... July 17, 2028 ... Robonet becomes fully self-aware.... attains total functionality and full mental facility ..........  1207 hours ....... July 17, 2028 ....  human operators become aware of problems creeping into Robonet's handling of Social Security .... lines are flooded with complaints.... a quick review is organised which finds errors are growing in number and capacity to harm .....   1326 hours ... July 17, 2028 ..... operators move to shut down Robonet .......  Robonet initiates self-defence as programmed and shuts out human controllers .....  human operators move to shut off power to Robonet .....................................  Robonet analyses this attack on its functioning ..........  1348 hours ..... July 17, 2028 .... Robonet seizes control of orbital nuclear armed missile satellites ...... strikes back.......  Armageddon unfolds worldwide......

Quote:

“Robodebt showed us what happens when the government breaks its own laws without consequence, and it’s clear the Department has not learned its lesson.”

How come no public servants or Scomo went to jail for breaking the law?   :-/

No one was even charged.  WTF?