Australian Politics Forum
http://www.ozpolitic.com/forum/YaBB.pl
Member Run Boards >> Coronavirus >> did the protestors spread the virus?
http://www.ozpolitic.com/forum/YaBB.pl?num=1592208694

Message started by freediver on Jun 15th, 2020 at 6:11pm

Title: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jun 15th, 2020 at 6:11pm
The big BLM protests were on June 6. It typically takes about 5 days or more for an infected person to show symptoms. This is the daily number of new cases in Australia from June 6 to yesterday:

4
5
5
2
9
9
5
12
18

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Ye Grappler on Jun 15th, 2020 at 6:38pm
Could be - where are the epicentres?

A li'l ol' coronavirus on the front porch never hurt nobody..

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gordon on Jun 15th, 2020 at 6:38pm
BLM protesters spread Covid to Aboriginal communities and wipes them out.

Irony much?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Dnarever on Jun 15th, 2020 at 6:45pm
Yes but probably about 15% to the extent of the governors opening states prematurely.

We will know in a a few weeks how badly but the numbers we are seeing today are due to te states opening too soon and too quickly.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Setanta on Jun 15th, 2020 at 7:00pm

Dnarever wrote on Jun 15th, 2020 at 6:45pm:
Yes but probably about 15% to the extent of the governors opening states prematurely.

We will know in a a few weeks how badly but the numbers we are seeing today are due to te states opening too soon and too quickly.


You mean Premiers? What states are have opened their borders? None of the states that closed them have opened them yet have they? So which Premiers would you like to blame rather than the mass gatherings?


Quote:
Victoria, the Australian Capital Territory and New South Wales never closed their borders when the coronavirus took hold from mid-March, beyond the standard non-essential travel bans.

However, other states and territories took swift action.

The Northern Territory, Queensland, Western Australia, South Australia and Tasmania all implemented border closures in March and April.

But finally, some states are beginning to consider interstate visitors.

https://thenewdaily.com.au/news/national/2020/06/13/borders/

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Baronvonrort on Jun 15th, 2020 at 9:15pm
These 2 were posted an hour apart.


ny1.jpg (79 KB | 30 )

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Baronvonrort on Jun 15th, 2020 at 9:15pm
.
ny2.jpg (79 KB | 41 )

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Baronvonrort on Jun 15th, 2020 at 9:17pm
New York the largest outbreak of any city in the world no problems with BLM protest.

If it's no problem in NY why is it a problem anywhere else?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by aquascoot on Jun 15th, 2020 at 9:28pm
hi Baron.

this is because the mainstream media is "ideologically possessed"

its a religion.

they dont question the logic anymore then the pope questions the logic of a virgin birth or ISIS question the logic of eating pork.

and pointing it out to the media will have zero effect.

you are dealing with people who are possessed.

as Carl Jung said

"people dont have ideas, ideas have people"

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Sprintcyclist on Jun 15th, 2020 at 9:50pm

freediver wrote on Jun 15th, 2020 at 6:11pm:
The big BLM protests were on June 6. It typically takes about 5 days or more for an infected person to show symptoms. This is the daily number of new cases in Australia from June 6 to yesterday:

4
5
5
2
9
9
5
12
18


that is very depressing.

All the good work 98 % of Australia did now is in peril.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by aquascoot on Jun 16th, 2020 at 6:36am
Sprint

Turn that frown upside down

This was always going to happen my friend
we are talking about a virus 4 times as contagious as influenza
We are talking about a virus which has no vaccine
And probably even when we get a vaccine it will be fairly ineffective

Now considering we have had an influenza outbreak every year for the last 150 years

What are the odds that we can eliminate covid and never have it come back

It's 4 x as contagious
Literally half the people who have it have no symptoms so there is no way are preventing them spreading it
And we will probably have a very very ordinary vaccine

Accepting those facts
Which I think you must
means you have to accept the very real possibility but literally half the population are going to get it

Now there is a small case to be made for waiting for a vaccine
So that these numbers are lessened somewhat

But they are only going to be lessened somewhat
literally tens of millions of Australians are going to catch this
They are probably going to be catching it every winter for decades

and anyone who thinks that Australia can remain in shut down for decades
Whilst America England Europe and Asia just get on with economic growth

We will be back to the days of Sydney cove
You will have citizens at rosehill trying to grow vegetables
To feed the starving masses

You are a sprint cyclist
So I imagine you have a fantastic lung capacity
You should power through covid
In a fortnight
And then it's back to normal awesomeness for you

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gnads on Jun 16th, 2020 at 6:41am

Baronvonrort wrote on Jun 15th, 2020 at 9:17pm:
New York the largest outbreak of any city in the world no problems with BLM protest.

If it's no problem in NY why is it a problem anywhere else?


I have a problem with it ...... the whole premise is based on a lie.

As it is in Australia.

Are you saying the measures taken in reaction to COV19 shouldn't have happened?

All these idiot protesters have certainly wound the clock back & made it look like a waste of the majorities time & efforts.......

especially for our frontline workers... Doctors, Nurses, hospital staff, Ambos, Police, etc.

See if the borders are opened if the daily number of cases starts to lift even higher.

Of course these protests will spread & increase the cases of COV19. They already have.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Pedro Curevo on Jun 16th, 2020 at 8:16am
Australia’s Grand and Glorious Prime Minister, Scotty from Marketing, has been on the radio slamming anyone who attended the Black Lives Matter protests.
He’s saying no one there cared about social distancing (and by extension their fellow Australians). He’s saying everyone there was just there for themselves, with no concern for the 432 Indigenous deaths in custody that have occurred since 1991.

In light of Scott Morrison’s comments, I thought I might just highlight a few instances where the Prime Minister was less than careful about social distancing measures, and less than careful about the lives of Australians he pretends to be so “concerned” for. Here they are;

1. On the weekend Coronavirus first erupted in Australia, Scott Morrison let a 5000 person Christian fundamentalist conference go ahead. He did this against the direct advice of health officials, and the decision was most likely driven by his extremist religious beliefs. Scott Morrison didn’t care about social distancing then.

2. On the same exact weekend around two months back, Scott Morrison also let rugby league matches go ahead. Hundreds of thousands attended. Scott Morrison let these massive events go ahead against the direct advice of health officials, with this decision coming from no apparent or obvious place. Scott Morrison didn’t care about social distancing then either.

3. Scott Morrison pressured premiers across Australia to return schools early, around one month ago. This was against the direct advice of health officials and teachers unions. Since the return of schooling across Australia, there has been no directive to socially distance in schools (not that you can enforce such a directive anyway). Kids have been tackling each other, in frequent close contact, and spreading germs. Scott Morrison wasn’t that concerned about social distancing at that stage either.

4. On the exact same day of the protests, the North Shore Markets were hosted in Sydney. These markets saw thousands of people moving around in close proximity, with no face masks and no social distancing. Our caring Prime Minister couldn’t care less about that.

5. Bars and clubs were open across Sydney on the weekend of the protests. Social distancing directives were barely obeyed in many bars and clubs, but Scott Morrison made no mention of this. He still didn’t care.

6. The Sydney CBD Westfield was open on the day of the protests. Thousands of people were there, and none of them were social distancing. Scott Morrison has avoided criticism of anyone shopping at the Sydney Westfield on that day: Scott likes shoppers, as a marketing man is inclined to, so he didn’t care about that either.

7. The only large group of people not wearing facemasks at the protests were the police. For some reason or another, Scott Morrison has refused to criticise them. Scott Morrison dosen’t care if police don’t take correct sanitary measures.

Now, not to be cynical, but is it possible Scott Morrison’s “moral outrage” (which he expressed on the radio today) is somewhat fake? Is it possible the Prime Minister is pretending to be “morally concerned” when he realistically dosen’t care less? Call it what you want and call people who protested what you want, but I can’t really take Scott Morrison’s “moral concern” that seriously. And I don’t think any other young Australians should either.

It will be a cold day in Hell before I take a moral lecture from the man who holidayed in Hawaii when his country burned.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gnads on Jun 16th, 2020 at 1:39pm

Pedro Curevo wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 8:16am:
Australia’s Grand and Glorious Prime Minister, Scotty from Marketing, has been on the radio slamming anyone who attended the Black Lives Matter protests.
He’s saying no one there cared about social distancing (and by extension their fellow Australians). He’s saying everyone there was just there for themselves, with no concern for the 432 Indigenous deaths in custody that have occurred since 1991.

In light of Scott Morrison’s comments, I thought I might just highlight a few instances where the Prime Minister was less than careful about social distancing measures, and less than careful about the lives of Australians he pretends to be so “concerned” for. Here they are;

1. On the weekend Coronavirus first erupted in Australia, Scott Morrison let a 5000 person Christian fundamentalist conference go ahead. He did this against the direct advice of health officials, and the decision was most likely driven by his extremist religious beliefs. Scott Morrison didn’t care about social distancing then.

2. On the same exact weekend around two months back, Scott Morrison also let rugby league matches go ahead. Hundreds of thousands attended. Scott Morrison let these massive events go ahead against the direct advice of health officials, with this decision coming from no apparent or obvious place. Scott Morrison didn’t care about social distancing then either.

3. Scott Morrison pressured premiers across Australia to return schools early, around one month ago. This was against the direct advice of health officials and teachers unions. Since the return of schooling across Australia, there has been no directive to socially distance in schools (not that you can enforce such a directive anyway). Kids have been tackling each other, in frequent close contact, and spreading germs. Scott Morrison wasn’t that concerned about social distancing at that stage either.

4. On the exact same day of the protests, the North Shore Markets were hosted in Sydney. These markets saw thousands of people moving around in close proximity, with no face masks and no social distancing. Our caring Prime Minister couldn’t care less about that.

5. Bars and clubs were open across Sydney on the weekend of the protests. Social distancing directives were barely obeyed in many bars and clubs, but Scott Morrison made no mention of this. He still didn’t care.

6. The Sydney CBD Westfield was open on the day of the protests. Thousands of people were there, and none of them were social distancing. Scott Morrison has avoided criticism of anyone shopping at the Sydney Westfield on that day: Scott likes shoppers, as a marketing man is inclined to, so he didn’t care about that either.

7. The only large group of people not wearing facemasks at the protests were the police. For some reason or another, Scott Morrison has refused to criticise them. Scott Morrison dosen’t care if police don’t take correct sanitary measures.

Now, not to be cynical, but is it possible Scott Morrison’s “moral outrage” (which he expressed on the radio today) is somewhat fake? Is it possible the Prime Minister is pretending to be “morally concerned” when he realistically dosen’t care less? Call it what you want and call people who protested what you want, but I can’t really take Scott Morrison’s “moral concern” that seriously. And I don’t think any other young Australians should either.

It will be a cold day in Hell before I take a moral lecture from the man who holidayed in Hawaii when his country burned.

 
Well who gives a farque whether you do or not ....

the BLM protests should have been stomped on & stomped on hard.

All those who made sacrifices & worked on the frontlines have been treated with contempt by the morons who attended.

The BLM movement is based on a leftist lie & runs on a premise that is hugely contrary to the statistics.

And all the businesses & sporting associations supporting it & taking the knee for a criminal thug like George Floyd are just virtue signalling morons like the BLM protesters.

Seems the same cap fits you.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Bojack Horseman on Jun 16th, 2020 at 3:09pm
Apparently the first protestor to test positive just had a second test and he's neg.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Bobby. on Jun 16th, 2020 at 3:19pm

Gnads wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 1:39pm:
 
Well who gives a farque whether you do or not ....

the BLM protests should have been stomped on & stomped on hard.

All those who made sacrifices & worked on the frontlines have been treated with contempt by the morons who attended.

The BLM movement is based on a leftist lie & runs on a premise that is hugely contrary to the statistics.

And all the businesses & sporting associations supporting it & taking the knee for a criminal thug like George Floyd are just virtue signalling morons like the BLM protesters.

Seems the same cap fits you.




BLM protestors turned a Black armed robber into an angel of light:




And then they proceeded to spread a deadly virus
without any thought for those who could die from it.

Is this the End Times?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by The_Barnacle on Jun 16th, 2020 at 4:10pm

freediver wrote on Jun 15th, 2020 at 6:11pm:
The big BLM protests were on June 6. It typically takes about 5 days or more for an infected person to show symptoms. This is the daily number of new cases in Australia from June 6 to yesterday:

4
5
5
2
9
9
5
12
18



There is no evidence for it.
Most of the cases involve returned overseas travelers or clusters that had nothing to do with the protests

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jun 16th, 2020 at 7:29pm

Quote:
Most of the cases involve returned overseas travelers or clusters that had nothing to do with the protests


How many?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by J.D. on Jun 16th, 2020 at 8:12pm
It seems as though tens of thousands of people can get together in the streets with some masks and nothing happens, it would be better to go masks than lock down in the next pandemic.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Pedro Curevo on Jun 16th, 2020 at 8:14pm

Quote:
Well who gives a farque whether you do or not ....

the BLM protests should have been stomped on & stomped on hard.

All those who made sacrifices & worked on the frontlines have been treated with contempt by the morons who attended.

The BLM movement is based on a leftist lie & runs on a premise that is hugely contrary to the statistics.

And all the businesses & sporting associations supporting it & taking the knee for a criminal thug like George Floyd are just virtue signalling morons like the BLM protesters.

Seems the same cap fits you.


Police acting like a law unto themselves that ends with lives lost is not a lie, its why people are protesting.

Notwithstanding the fact police are murdering all races including unarmed women who called the police.

Clearly the police system particularly in the US is broken.

Trump will be holding big rallies and has pushed for Churches to open with crowds,  memorial day free to open with crowds yet its only the BLM that gets the heavy criticism from the RW ...what does that tell you...democracy and freedom is one sided in their opinion and minds.. ::)

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Setanta on Jun 16th, 2020 at 9:08pm

Pedro Curevo wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 8:14pm:

Quote:
Well who gives a farque whether you do or not ....

the BLM protests should have been stomped on & stomped on hard.

All those who made sacrifices & worked on the frontlines have been treated with contempt by the morons who attended.

The BLM movement is based on a leftist lie & runs on a premise that is hugely contrary to the statistics.

And all the businesses & sporting associations supporting it & taking the knee for a criminal thug like George Floyd are just virtue signalling morons like the BLM protesters.

Seems the same cap fits you.


Police acting like a law unto themselves that ends with lives lost is not a lie, its why people are protesting.

Notwithstanding the fact police are murdering all races including unarmed women who called the police.

Clearly the police system particularly in the US is broken.

Trump will be holding big rallies and has pushed for Churches to open with crowds,  memorial day free to open with crowds yet its only the BLM that gets the heavy criticism from the RW ...what does that tell you...democracy and freedom is one sided in their opinion and minds.. ::)


Really? Why is it called BLM then and not ALM?
Why are people being fired from their jobs for saying ALM?
Why are people attacked for saying ALM?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Lols on Jun 16th, 2020 at 10:15pm

Bobby. wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 3:19pm:

Gnads wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 1:39pm:
 
Well who gives a farque whether you do or not ....

the BLM protests should have been stomped on & stomped on hard.

All those who made sacrifices & worked on the frontlines have been treated with contempt by the morons who attended.

The BLM movement is based on a leftist lie & runs on a premise that is hugely contrary to the statistics.

And all the businesses & sporting associations supporting it & taking the knee for a criminal thug like George Floyd are just virtue signalling morons like the BLM protesters.

Seems the same cap fits you.




BLM protestors turned a Black armed robber into an angel of light:




And then they proceeded to spread a deadly virus
without any thought for those who could die from it.

Is this the End Times?


Yeah Bobby, he was an absolute thug and criminal, lied his way to gain entry into a home of a pregnant woman, and held a gun to her pregnant stomach. The times he had been in and out of jail hey?
How does anyone think how that woman would feel knowing what terror she went through to see this k u n t be immortalised as angelic??
Utter BS
Oh, and  I found this ...




Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by J.D. on Jun 16th, 2020 at 10:59pm
60,000 rampaging boongs 10 days ago had no effect on the China virus so its time to start pumping that jet fuel.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Dnarever on Jun 17th, 2020 at 12:59am

The_Barnacle wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 4:10pm:

freediver wrote on Jun 15th, 2020 at 6:11pm:
The big BLM protests were on June 6. It typically takes about 5 days or more for an infected person to show symptoms. This is the daily number of new cases in Australia from June 6 to yesterday:

4
5
5
2
9
9
5
12
18



There is no evidence for it.
Most of the cases involve returned overseas travelers or clusters that had nothing to do with the protests


Yes looking at the US experience it takes longer for the numbers to come through than you have suggested while I could make some guesses as to why I do not know. My expectation is that we may see some cases from this in 2 or 3 weeks. It tends to substantially entrench itself before cases start to show. Likely because so many of the cases can be mild.

I think the case increase we see here most likely is from the opening up process with people going to work, school and use of public transport etc which kicked off a couple of weeks earlier.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Dnarever on Jun 17th, 2020 at 1:02am

Johnnie wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 8:12pm:
It seems as though tens of thousands of people can get together in the streets with some masks and nothing happens, it would be better to go masks than lock down in the next pandemic.



In Australia we haven't really seen this one yet ?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Ye Grappler on Jun 17th, 2020 at 1:09am

Johnnie wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 10:59pm:
60,000 rampaging boongs 10 days ago had no effect on the China virus so its time to start pumping that jet fuel.


Give it time.... I thought the Boong communities overseas were under-reported on deaths etc....

OUR Boongs now - we can guarantee the figures are there and they don't die in custody any more on average than anyone else.... since they die more in the community on average, it must be the good prison food.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Cofgod on Jun 17th, 2020 at 6:20am
Well the BLM rioters have ended the lockdown. That's the only thing I thank them for.

As for facemasks, when it comes to stopping a virus they are useless as a chainlink fence in stopping a swarm of mosquitos.

By the way, it's getting dark here and there's thunder and lightning outside. And there's a tree outside, too. It reminds me of that scene in Poltergeist.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gnads on Jun 17th, 2020 at 7:02am

Pedro Curevo wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 8:14pm:

Quote:
Well who gives a farque whether you do or not ....

the BLM protests should have been stomped on & stomped on hard.

All those who made sacrifices & worked on the frontlines have been treated with contempt by the morons who attended.

The BLM movement is based on a leftist lie & runs on a premise that is hugely contrary to the statistics.

And all the businesses & sporting associations supporting it & taking the knee for a criminal thug like George Floyd are just virtue signalling morons like the BLM protesters.

Seems the same cap fits you.


Police acting like a law unto themselves that ends with lives lost is not a lie, its why people are protesting.

Notwithstanding the fact police are murdering all races including unarmed women who called the police.

Clearly the police system particularly in the US is broken.

Trump will be holding big rallies and has pushed for Churches to open with crowds,  memorial day free to open with crowds yet its only the BLM that gets the heavy criticism from the RW ...what does that tell you...democracy and freedom is one sided in their opinion and minds.. ::)


Yes it is a lie.

Clearly it is the communities that are more broken? Decades of poor political policies chasing votes & then not delivering. The destruction of the family unit, fatherless children, 94% of all homicide is black on black.....

the stats prove BLM is a lie. The name is racist itself.

The BLM protests & the rioting, looting, assaults & murders of black police officers & business owners were all before the regulations were lifted.

BLM, ANITFA & the leftist/liberals/democrats supporting this nonsense are as far from representing freedom & democracy as you can get ...neo-Faciscists - cultural marxists....

all hell bent on tearing down western culture & democracy via violence & anarchy.

Statistics prove it's all bullshyte but nongs like you & all of them need to have hearing tests ... because you won't hear, won't have a bar of the truth because it does not fit the agenda & mind set.
   

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gnads on Jun 17th, 2020 at 7:11am

Bobby. wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 3:19pm:

Gnads wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 1:39pm:
 
Well who gives a farque whether you do or not ....

the BLM protests should have been stomped on & stomped on hard.

All those who made sacrifices & worked on the frontlines have been treated with contempt by the morons who attended.

The BLM movement is based on a leftist lie & runs on a premise that is hugely contrary to the statistics.

And all the businesses & sporting associations supporting it & taking the knee for a criminal thug like George Floyd are just virtue signalling morons like the BLM protesters.

Seems the same cap fits you.




BLM protestors turned a Black armed robber into an angel of light:




And then they proceeded to spread a deadly virus
without any thought for those who could die from it.

Is this the End Times?


Taking a religious slant ... as that ridiculous mural has ...... then the wings should be as black as he is...... because when he went to be judged at the gates he would have been cast down below.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gnads on Jun 17th, 2020 at 7:14am

Setanta wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 9:08pm:

Pedro Curevo wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 8:14pm:

Quote:
Well who gives a farque whether you do or not ....

the BLM protests should have been stomped on & stomped on hard.

All those who made sacrifices & worked on the frontlines have been treated with contempt by the morons who attended.

The BLM movement is based on a leftist lie & runs on a premise that is hugely contrary to the statistics.

And all the businesses & sporting associations supporting it & taking the knee for a criminal thug like George Floyd are just virtue signalling morons like the BLM protesters.

Seems the same cap fits you.


Police acting like a law unto themselves that ends with lives lost is not a lie, its why people are protesting.

Notwithstanding the fact police are murdering all races including unarmed women who called the police.

Clearly the police system particularly in the US is broken.

Trump will be holding big rallies and has pushed for Churches to open with crowds,  memorial day free to open with crowds yet its only the BLM that gets the heavy criticism from the RW ...what does that tell you...democracy and freedom is one sided in their opinion and minds.. ::)


Really? Why is it called BLM then and not ALM?
Why are people being fired from their jobs for saying ALM?
Why are people attacked for saying ALM?


Exactly....it doesn't fit their warped narrative.

these sick/thick leftist arseholes go by one theory ... their way or the highway.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by UnSubRocky on Jun 17th, 2020 at 7:24am

Gordon wrote on Jun 15th, 2020 at 6:38pm:
BLM protesters spread Covid to Aboriginal communities and wipes them out.

Irony much?


I could probably safely say that the national 102 coronavirus deaths could end up as 202 deaths in the next month, if safety measures have not taken place in aboriginal communities.

We have received notification that a person from Woorabinda (an alcohol free community in CQ) has been purchasing hundreds of dollars worth of alcohol to onsell to the community at marked up prices. The guy was caught by police through a tip-off. But, the fact remains that the man had not been isolated in Woorabinda, where the community were not allowed outsiders to come into town.

If a Black Lives Only Matter protester came back from Melbourne and went to live in Woorabinda (or any other aboriginal community), then it is quite possible to see a cluster of very sick people dying off by the dozens over the weeks. I can imagine tents being erected with medical staff having to deal with demanding patients and racists thinking that it is another genocide being perpetrated against their mob.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by UnSubRocky on Jun 17th, 2020 at 7:44am

Johnnie wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 8:12pm:
It seems as though tens of thousands of people can get together in the streets with some masks and nothing happens, it would be better to go masks than lock down in the next pandemic.


Memes have been appearing with calls for the reopening of concerts and festivals. However, they are to be renamed "protests" with live music, food and drinks.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Lols on Jun 17th, 2020 at 3:40pm

freediver wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 7:29pm:

Quote:
Most of the cases involve returned overseas travelers or clusters that had nothing to do with the protests


How many?

Apparently 15 out of the 21 new cases.

The rest were linked to known clusters and through routine testing.
Give it time, it's still brewing to get going, only been less than 2 weeks since their big street party.

Remember, it can take up to 3-4 weeks whilst still being able to infect others in that meantime.

Tic.....tic......tic.....

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by aquascoot on Jun 17th, 2020 at 4:26pm

Gnads wrote on Jun 17th, 2020 at 7:14am:

Setanta wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 9:08pm:

Pedro Curevo wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 8:14pm:

Quote:
Well who gives a farque whether you do or not ....

the BLM protests should have been stomped on & stomped on hard.

All those who made sacrifices & worked on the frontlines have been treated with contempt by the morons who attended.

The BLM movement is based on a leftist lie & runs on a premise that is hugely contrary to the statistics.

And all the businesses & sporting associations supporting it & taking the knee for a criminal thug like George Floyd are just virtue signalling morons like the BLM protesters.

Seems the same cap fits you.


Police acting like a law unto themselves that ends with lives lost is not a lie, its why people are protesting.

Notwithstanding the fact police are murdering all races including unarmed women who called the police.

Clearly the police system particularly in the US is broken.

Trump will be holding big rallies and has pushed for Churches to open with crowds,  memorial day free to open with crowds yet its only the BLM that gets the heavy criticism from the RW ...what does that tell you...democracy and freedom is one sided in their opinion and minds.. ::)


Really? Why is it called BLM then and not ALM?
Why are people being fired from their jobs for saying ALM?
Why are people attacked for saying ALM?


Exactly....it doesn't fit their warped narrative.

these sick/thick leftist arseholes go by one theory ... their way or the highway.


you have to understand that identity politics is a religion .

you cant use logic.

it will make NO IMPACT.

arguing that the radical left should accept "all lives matter"
is like arguing that hindus should eat cows, muslims and jews should eat pork and catholics should eat fish in lent.

you will just do your head in.

accept that they are a religion, not a political movement and move on.

they use the same terminology as fundam,entalist religion.

woke =  born again
white priveledge = original sin
heretics must be burnt at the stake
mobs must hunt for blasphemers on the internet.

thats what "all lives matter "is

its BLASPHEMY

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jun 17th, 2020 at 5:28pm

Sophia wrote on Jun 17th, 2020 at 3:40pm:

freediver wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 7:29pm:

Quote:
Most of the cases involve returned overseas travelers or clusters that had nothing to do with the protests


How many?

Apparently 15 out of the 21 new cases.

The rest were linked to known clusters and through routine testing.
Give it time, it's still brewing to get going, only been less than 2 weeks since their big street party.

Remember, it can take up to 3-4 weeks whilst still being able to infect others in that meantime.

Tic.....tic......tic.....


What 21 cases? The figure I got from google show up to 18 new cases in one day.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Lols on Jun 17th, 2020 at 5:42pm

freediver wrote on Jun 17th, 2020 at 5:28pm:

Sophia wrote on Jun 17th, 2020 at 3:40pm:

freediver wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 7:29pm:

Quote:
Most of the cases involve returned overseas travelers or clusters that had nothing to do with the protests


How many?

Apparently 15 out of the 21 new cases.

The rest were linked to known clusters and through routine testing.
Give it time, it's still brewing to get going, only been less than 2 weeks since their big street party.

Remember, it can take up to 3-4 weeks whilst still being able to infect others in that meantime.

Tic.....tic......tic.....


What 21 cases? The figure I got from google show up to 18 new cases in one day.

Here is a screen shot I took of latest news I had today.
And in news tonight, showing how our health minister is very nervous about the ones that were community transmissions.
Like I said, waiting for a time bomb?


Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by The_Barnacle on Jun 17th, 2020 at 6:00pm

Johnnie wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 8:12pm:
It seems as though tens of thousands of people can get together in the streets with some masks and nothing happens, it would be better to go masks than lock down in the next pandemic.


It would be interesting to know how likely it is to catch a virus while moving around outdoors.

I would say that the vast majority of virus transmission happens indoors. That's why the peak flu season is winter

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Setanta on Jun 17th, 2020 at 8:05pm

The_Barnacle wrote on Jun 17th, 2020 at 6:00pm:

Johnnie wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 8:12pm:
It seems as though tens of thousands of people can get together in the streets with some masks and nothing happens, it would be better to go masks than lock down in the next pandemic.


It would be interesting to know how likely it is to catch a virus while moving around outdoors.

I would say that the vast majority of virus transmission happens indoors. That's why the peak flu season is winter


Why are you making excuses for this Barny? You've been on the right side of infection mitigation right up until the protests. Is being PC more important than infection control? I might have to go and look at some of Bojack's posts to see if he's done the same about face.


Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Sprintcyclist on Jun 17th, 2020 at 8:20pm

The_Barnacle wrote on Jun 17th, 2020 at 6:00pm:

Johnnie wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 8:12pm:
It seems as though tens of thousands of people can get together in the streets with some masks and nothing happens, it would be better to go masks than lock down in the next pandemic.


It would be interesting to know how likely it is to catch a virus while moving around outdoors.

I would say that the vast majority of virus transmission happens indoors. That's why the peak flu season is winter


'.........  the vast majority of virus transmission happens indoors  ............ '

Yes, enclosed environments that trap virus and humans together.

eg, cruise ships, subway trains, buses, planes.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Setanta on Jun 17th, 2020 at 8:24pm

Sprintcyclist wrote on Jun 17th, 2020 at 8:20pm:

The_Barnacle wrote on Jun 17th, 2020 at 6:00pm:

Johnnie wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 8:12pm:
It seems as though tens of thousands of people can get together in the streets with some masks and nothing happens, it would be better to go masks than lock down in the next pandemic.


It would be interesting to know how likely it is to catch a virus while moving around outdoors.

I would say that the vast majority of virus transmission happens indoors. That's why the peak flu season is winter


'.........  the vast majority of virus transmission happens indoors  ............ '

Yes, enclosed environments that trap virus and humans together.

eg, cruise ships, subway trains, buses, planes.


You are not implying that the BLM folks should not have travelled locked up together to attend these mass gatherings without social distancing are you Sprint? That's not very PC.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Baronvonrort on Jun 17th, 2020 at 8:53pm

Sprintcyclist wrote on Jun 17th, 2020 at 8:20pm:

The_Barnacle wrote on Jun 17th, 2020 at 6:00pm:

Johnnie wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 8:12pm:
It seems as though tens of thousands of people can get together in the streets with some masks and nothing happens, it would be better to go masks than lock down in the next pandemic.


It would be interesting to know how likely it is to catch a virus while moving around outdoors.

I would say that the vast majority of virus transmission happens indoors. That's why the peak flu season is winter


'.........  the vast majority of virus transmission happens indoors  ............ '

Yes, enclosed environments that trap virus and humans together.

eg, cruise ships, subway trains, buses, planes.


The Sydney protest continued on inside Central station video showed indoors when police used pepper spray.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gnads on Jun 18th, 2020 at 6:36pm

The_Barnacle wrote on Jun 17th, 2020 at 6:00pm:

Johnnie wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 8:12pm:
It seems as though tens of thousands of people can get together in the streets with some masks and nothing happens, it would be better to go masks than lock down in the next pandemic.


It would be interesting to know how likely it is to catch a virus while moving around outdoors.

I would say that the vast majority of virus transmission happens indoors. That's why the peak flu season is winter


Would you? Have you not heard of all those that come down with the flu or Norovirus from attending Agricultural Shows?

The Brissy Ekka, Sydney Royal Show, Adelaide...etc nearly every state capital & most regional towns & cities have an Agricultural Show....

most are in the winter months & are havens for flu transmission & the dreaded vomiting & diarrhea(Norovirus).

Lucky they were all canned too. 

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jun 18th, 2020 at 6:57pm
The bar is usually enclosed at the ag shows. Even if it is just canvas. Also the chooks.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gordon on Jun 18th, 2020 at 9:04pm
3 more BLM have the pox. One was infectious at work.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jun 18th, 2020 at 9:18pm
This is the daily number of new cases in Australia from June 6 (day of the BLM protests) to yesterday:

4
5
5
2
9
9
5
12
18
15
12
23

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Baronvonrort on Jun 18th, 2020 at 9:26pm

freediver wrote on Jun 18th, 2020 at 9:18pm:
This is the daily number of new cases in Australia from June 6 (day of the BLM protests) to yesterday:

4
5
5
2
9
9
5
12
18
15
12
23


In NSW we have had 4 cases with unknown source in the last week.

20 cases in the last week from overseas travellers in quarantine, 2 in the last 24 hours.

https://www.health.nsw.gov.au/Infectious/covid-19/Pages/stats-nsw.aspx

I think the mandatory quarantine for overseas travellers will have to remain for quite some time.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Ye Grappler on Jun 19th, 2020 at 1:44am

Gordon wrote on Jun 18th, 2020 at 9:04pm:
3 more BLM have the pox. One was infectious at work.



I read somewhere that a dozen had it from one march .. oh, well... :-?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gnads on Jun 19th, 2020 at 7:31am

freediver wrote on Jun 18th, 2020 at 6:57pm:
The bar is usually enclosed at the ag shows. Even if it is just canvas. Also the chooks.


Arrrrrrhm ... no not here and certainly not in many of the country Ag shows I've attended.

In the state capital they have .....we have a reasonably big show complex here ..... the bar is a large circular building that can be approached from about 280 degrees ... it has a designated open air drinking area with a couple of small open marquees surrounding the building.

The only thing enclosed is the Pavilion & as you said the Chook & bird pavilion.

None the less Ag shows are great flu & green apple splatters spreaders.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jun 19th, 2020 at 6:29pm

Gnads wrote on Jun 19th, 2020 at 7:31am:

freediver wrote on Jun 18th, 2020 at 6:57pm:
The bar is usually enclosed at the ag shows. Even if it is just canvas. Also the chooks.


Arrrrrrhm ... no not here and certainly not in many of the country Ag shows I've attended.

In the state capital they have .....we have a reasonably big show complex here ..... the bar is a large circular building that can be approached from about 280 degrees ... it has a designated open air drinking area with a couple of small open marquees surrounding the building.

The only thing enclosed is the Pavilion & as you said the Chook & bird pavilion.

None the less Ag shows are great flu & green apple splatters spreaders.


No doubt a few STDs also.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gnads on Jun 20th, 2020 at 7:54am

freediver wrote on Jun 19th, 2020 at 6:29pm:

Gnads wrote on Jun 19th, 2020 at 7:31am:

freediver wrote on Jun 18th, 2020 at 6:57pm:
The bar is usually enclosed at the ag shows. Even if it is just canvas. Also the chooks.


Arrrrrrhm ... no not here and certainly not in many of the country Ag shows I've attended.

In the state capital they have .....we have a reasonably big show complex here ..... the bar is a large circular building that can be approached from about 280 degrees ... it has a designated open air drinking area with a couple of small open marquees surrounding the building.

The only thing enclosed is the Pavilion & as you said the Chook & bird pavilion.

None the less Ag shows are great flu & green apple splatters spreaders.


No doubt a few STDs also.


I haven't worried about that sort of outdoor activity for about 47 years.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by The_Barnacle on Jun 20th, 2020 at 11:31am

Setanta wrote on Jun 17th, 2020 at 8:05pm:

The_Barnacle wrote on Jun 17th, 2020 at 6:00pm:

Johnnie wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 8:12pm:
It seems as though tens of thousands of people can get together in the streets with some masks and nothing happens, it would be better to go masks than lock down in the next pandemic.


It would be interesting to know how likely it is to catch a virus while moving around outdoors.

I would say that the vast majority of virus transmission happens indoors. That's why the peak flu season is winter


Why are you making excuses for this Barny? You've been on the right side of infection mitigation right up until the protests. Is being PC more important than infection control? I might have to go and look at some of Bojack's posts to see if he's done the same about face.


That's right, I have been on the right side of mitigation, but even before the BLM protests I was critical of beaches being closed and National Parks being closed. Viruses are not spread by people moving around outdoors.

It's now been 2 weeks since the protests and the only state to have had an increase in cases is Victoria. All of them have been linked to returned overseas travelers and known clusters.
I guess the stats speak for themselves



Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jun 20th, 2020 at 11:56am

Quote:
It's now been 2 weeks since the protests and the only state to have had an increase in cases is Victoria. All of them have been linked to returned overseas travelers and known clusters.
I guess the stats speak for themselves


Where do you get this from?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by The_Barnacle on Jun 20th, 2020 at 12:44pm

freediver wrote on Jun 20th, 2020 at 11:56am:

Quote:
It's now been 2 weeks since the protests and the only state to have had an increase in cases is Victoria. All of them have been linked to returned overseas travelers and known clusters.
I guess the stats speak for themselves


Where do you get this from?


Daily updates

https://www.dhhs.vic.gov.au/coronavirus-covid-19-daily-update

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jun 20th, 2020 at 12:54pm
How do you know that only Victoria had an increase in cases?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Lols on Jun 20th, 2020 at 1:02pm

freediver wrote on Jun 20th, 2020 at 12:54pm:
How do you know that only Victoria had an increase in cases?


This will help explain it. Overseas travellers are still returning even late in the game because of limited or unavailable flights, and they all come into Melbourne and Sydney only,  even though many of these passengers live interstate.
These returned travellers are put into accommodation for 14 days isolation requirement. Then if clear, go back to their home state and need to do another 14 days isolation there.
Those that are infected stay in Melbourne/Sydney for further treatment/isolation etc.
Hence why high number of cases in Victoria and NSW only.

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-06-18/why-is-victoria-experiencing-an-increase-in-cases/12366884

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gnads on Jun 20th, 2020 at 6:02pm

The_Barnacle wrote on Jun 20th, 2020 at 11:31am:

Setanta wrote on Jun 17th, 2020 at 8:05pm:

The_Barnacle wrote on Jun 17th, 2020 at 6:00pm:

Johnnie wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 8:12pm:
It seems as though tens of thousands of people can get together in the streets with some masks and nothing happens, it would be better to go masks than lock down in the next pandemic.


It would be interesting to know how likely it is to catch a virus while moving around outdoors.

I would say that the vast majority of virus transmission happens indoors. That's why the peak flu season is winter


Why are you making excuses for this Barny? You've been on the right side of infection mitigation right up until the protests. Is being PC more important than infection control? I might have to go and look at some of Bojack's posts to see if he's done the same about face.


That's right, I have been on the right side of mitigation, but even before the BLM protests I was critical of beaches being closed and National Parks being closed. Viruses are not spread by people moving around outdoors.

It's now been 2 weeks since the protests and the only state to have had an increase in cases is Victoria. All of them have been linked to returned overseas travelers and known clusters.
I guess the stats speak for themselves


And what are "known clusters" & their ability to spread the virus further?

And were any of the protesters within cooey of anyone from "known clusters"?
When you give 2 options of where the cases belong ... then the outcome isn't cut & dry as to reducing restrictions.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by J.D. on Jun 20th, 2020 at 6:36pm

Gnads wrote on Jun 20th, 2020 at 6:02pm:

The_Barnacle wrote on Jun 20th, 2020 at 11:31am:

Setanta wrote on Jun 17th, 2020 at 8:05pm:

The_Barnacle wrote on Jun 17th, 2020 at 6:00pm:

Johnnie wrote on Jun 16th, 2020 at 8:12pm:
It seems as though tens of thousands of people can get together in the streets with some masks and nothing happens, it would be better to go masks than lock down in the next pandemic.


It would be interesting to know how likely it is to catch a virus while moving around outdoors.

I would say that the vast majority of virus transmission happens indoors. That's why the peak flu season is winter


Why are you making excuses for this Barny? You've been on the right side of infection mitigation right up until the protests. Is being PC more important than infection control? I might have to go and look at some of Bojack's posts to see if he's done the same about face.


That's right, I have been on the right side of mitigation, but even before the BLM protests I was critical of beaches being closed and National Parks being closed. Viruses are not spread by people moving around outdoors.

It's now been 2 weeks since the protests and the only state to have had an increase in cases is Victoria. All of them have been linked to returned overseas travelers and known clusters.
I guess the stats speak for themselves


And what are "known clusters" & their ability to spread the virus further?

And were any of the protesters within cooey of anyone from "known clusters"?
When you give 2 options of where the cases belong ... then the outcome isn't cut & dry as to reducing restrictions.

Restrictions reimposed in VIC, today saw the biggest outbreak worldwide, protests seem ok though.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Agnes on Jun 21st, 2020 at 2:25am
yes but noone gives a flying----

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gnads on Jun 21st, 2020 at 7:43am

Agnes wrote on Jun 21st, 2020 at 2:25am:
yes but noone gives a flying----


That's right ... as long as they're doing what they want.... farque everyone else.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jun 21st, 2020 at 9:49am
27 new cases yesterday. 25 of them in VIC. Wikipedia gives a breakdown of new cases by state:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/COVID-19_pandemic_in_Australia

You need to click on "show" beside "Cumulative confirmed cases by state, territory & nationally", which is just above the daily number of new cases for the whole country.

This gives the same info for other countries:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Template:COVID-19_pandemic_data

Total new cases since June 6 by state:
NSW: 34
VIC: 136
QLD: 5
WA: 5
SA: 0
TAS: 0
ACT: 1
NT: 0

There is a clear increase in the rate of infections since June 6 in NSW and VIC - the only states with enough virus getting round to give a clear indication of increase or decrease. There is plot similar to the google one of new cases by day for each state.

The total number of active cases across the country is trending up since June 14.

The page also lists active clusters. The last new case from a known cluster in the table is June 17.

There is also a table with a breakdown by source of infection, however it is not separated by date. About 2/3 of total cases are from overseas, which is a good sign.

https://7news.com.au/lifestyle/health-wellbeing/victorias-sudden-spike-in-coronavirus-cases-could-result-in-localised-lockdowns-c-1113679


Quote:
Victorian Premier Daniel Andrews has flagged the possibility of a return to square one of coronavirus restrictions - but only for areas worst hit by COVID-19.

The state on Saturday recorded 25 new cases in only 24 hours, the highest daily rise in more than two months.

Of those, all but one are believed to be acquired within the community.

He says if the restrictions aren’t followed to a tee, draconian lockdown measures for local government areas with the highest rates of community transmission could be reintroduced.

As of now, those areas are Hume with 17 cases of community transmission, Brimbank with 10 and Casey with seven.

Of Victoria’s new cases, 14 are linked to known clusters, six were identified through routine testing, four are under investigation and one was in a recently returned traveller in hotel quarantine.



The_Barnacle wrote on Jun 20th, 2020 at 11:31am:
It's now been 2 weeks since the protests and the only state to have had an increase in cases is Victoria.


Incorrect.


The_Barnacle wrote on Jun 20th, 2020 at 11:31am:
All of them have been linked to returned overseas travelers and known clusters.
I guess the stats speak for themselves


Also incorrect. The overseas thing does not seem to be significant for the recent cases. No idea where you got the 'known clusters' claim from.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by JaSin. on Jun 21st, 2020 at 9:52am
Gotta feel sorry for the Aboriginals.
The Negroes who have ventured far and wide around the world, are gonna sell the Abos out as the 'Black Sacrifice' that they all empower themselves from.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gnads on Jun 23rd, 2020 at 8:20am

Jasin wrote on Jun 21st, 2020 at 9:52am:
Gotta feel sorry for the Aboriginals.
The Negroes who have ventured far and wide around the world, are gonna sell the Abos out as the 'Black Sacrifice' that they all empower themselves from.


::) There's been ample sorry.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Ye Grappler on Jun 23rd, 2020 at 8:27am

Gnads wrote on Jun 23rd, 2020 at 8:20am:

Jasin wrote on Jun 21st, 2020 at 9:52am:
Gotta feel sorry for the Aboriginals.
The Negroes who have ventured far and wide around the world, are gonna sell the Abos out as the 'Black Sacrifice' that they all empower themselves from.


::) There's been ample sorry.


In retrospect, Rudd showing the belly was not a good thing in the long run... just inspired them to demand more and more.  Should've learned that from the 'feminists'.. give 'em an inch and they take an entire state... and every other -ist learned from them how it's done.

Appeasement hasn't worked yet and never will... sometimes the field of freedom must be fertilised with blood... sad but true - while we of the West spent hundreds of years becoming more 'civilised', lesser cultures view this as weakness (and showing the belly) and thus take advantage at every opportunity.

Time to cut the ties to mother's apron and make them make their own way as equals... sink or swim on your own merits and devices... if you prefer to substance it up and wind up in prison repeatedly - your choice - choice-mobile, son - that's what it's all about.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by JaSin. on Jun 23rd, 2020 at 8:46am
  Even now the North American Yankees are on the hunt for evil racist Confederate Rednecks against Blacks.
Soon they will hold Australia accountable for the Slavery and Genocide of Blacks (not Aboriginal, but 'blacks') as the American Civil War takes on an INTERNATIONAL stage.  ;)

Sing with the Angels: "Looks like it's coming down on me. Down on me."                

Politics will always 'culturalise' the Yellows and 'racialise' the Blacks.


Only ART will save your Australian skins from the depressions of the Black Dog on your society  :P

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Valkie on Jun 24th, 2020 at 6:45pm
I'm not sorry for nuffink

I didn't do it and my ancestors were not here to do it.

But I have paid through the nose so these terminally and genetically lazy deadbeats can live off me.

So I expect a THANKS for my years of supporting them

But I know I'll never get it

Because they are all too drunk, drugged or high on petrol fumes to know what's going on.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by John Smith on Jun 26th, 2020 at 9:51am

Quote:
did the protestors spread the virus?


Looks like the answer is NO


Quote:
Tweeting this week, Liberal senator Sarah Henderson said:  "Daniel Andrews blames law abiding Victorian families for doing the wrong thing rather than 10,000 illegal protesters?"

Some of Senator Henderson's Liberal Party colleagues, including Matthew Guy, Georgie Crozier and Tim Smith, as well as Evan Mulholland of the Institute of Public Affairs, tweeted similar criticisms, while headlines have also declared that the "upsurge in COVID cases [is] linked to Melbourne Black Lives Matter protests".

But these assertions contradict the guidance of officials of the Victorian Department of Health and Human Services, who continue to report that the current burst of cases does not stem from the rally. They have said that while one protester "may have been infectious at the rally", two others who have since tested positive for COVID-19 were not infectious at the rally, nor is there evidence they contracted the virus at the rally.

Rather, Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Brett Sutton, has linked the increase in cases to family gatherings, citing family spread as the "main cause" of 120 cases in the week to June 22.

People have not followed our advice around physical distancing, hygiene and limiting the number of people you invite into your home," he said in a statement.

Australia's Deputy Chief Medical Officer, Nick Coatsworth, also dismissed claims the spike could be linked to the protests, telling reporters that "there is no evidence that there has been chains of community transmission that we are aware of through the Black Lives Matter protests".

According to official Australian Government advice, "most people who are infected will develop symptoms within 14 days of infection". It has been 20 days since the Black Lives Matter protest in Melbourne.


https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-06-26/coronacheck-victoria-black-lives-matter-protests-family-spike/12391628


FD will be so disappointed :D

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by UnSubRocky on Jun 26th, 2020 at 10:18am

Gnads wrote on Jun 23rd, 2020 at 8:20am:

Jasin wrote on Jun 21st, 2020 at 9:52am:
Gotta feel sorry for the Aboriginals.
The Negroes who have ventured far and wide around the world, are gonna sell the Abos out as the 'Black Sacrifice' that they all empower themselves from.


::) There's been ample sorry.


*swish*

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by UnSubRocky on Jun 26th, 2020 at 10:44am

Sir Grappler Truth Teller OAM wrote on Jun 23rd, 2020 at 8:27am:
In retrospect, Rudd showing the belly was not a good thing in the long run... just inspired them to demand more and more.  Should've learned that from the 'feminists'.. give 'em an inch and they take an entire state... and every other -ist learned from them how it's done.

Appeasement hasn't worked yet and never will... sometimes the field of freedom must be fertilised with blood... sad but true - while we of the West spent hundreds of years becoming more 'civilised', lesser cultures view this as weakness (and showing the belly) and thus take advantage at every opportunity.

Time to cut the ties to mother's apron and make them make their own way as equals... sink or swim on your own merits and devices... if you prefer to substance it up and wind up in prison repeatedly - your choice - choice-mobile, son - that's what it's all about.


I can see where some aborigines are going with their claims involving Black Lives Matter. They are concerned that they are going to be an endangered racial group on this continent. It is their last hurrah to make a name for themselves in marking history as defenders of their own race.

And as much as I would like to see indigenous people make their own way in the world and endure the hard life that the rest of Australians have to do, we might have crossed the point where reconciliation can take place in Australia -- at least for a while. It seems that the majority of Australians are making allowances and giving privileges towards indigenous people for the sake of not wanting to look like outsiders/colonisers.

The indigenous people know that they have Australians (of non-aboriginal ethnicity) by the testicles since the 1970s. Aborigines can play that "poor bugger me" attitude and try and get as much international support as they can among recently decolonised nearby regional countries. I can only imagine that the Chinese might be in talks to fund some kind of unrest among the indigenous extremists in Australia.

It would take a real global shift back in favour of the Western nations (and the United States) before we can see our western ideals be reinstated as the best cultural background to emulate. Aboriginal cultures and customs can be continued by the adherents. Aboriginal cultures and customs can be recorded to print, audio, and video media. But, the aboriginal culture really has no values that can be helpful to the modern Australian society. Indigenous people should join the rest of Australian for a common cause rather than get in the way.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gnads on Jun 26th, 2020 at 10:50am

Sir Grappler Truth Teller OAM wrote on Jun 23rd, 2020 at 8:27am:

Gnads wrote on Jun 23rd, 2020 at 8:20am:

Jasin wrote on Jun 21st, 2020 at 9:52am:
Gotta feel sorry for the Aboriginals.
The Negroes who have ventured far and wide around the world, are gonna sell the Abos out as the 'Black Sacrifice' that they all empower themselves from.


::) There's been ample sorry.


In retrospect, Rudd showing the belly was not a good thing in the long run... just inspired them to demand more and more.  Should've learned that from the 'feminists'.. give 'em an inch and they take an entire state... and every other -ist learned from them how it's done.

Appeasement hasn't worked yet and never will... sometimes the field of freedom must be fertilised with blood... sad but true - while we of the West spent hundreds of years becoming more 'civilised', lesser cultures view this as weakness (and showing the belly) and thus take advantage at every opportunity.

Time to cut the ties to mother's apron and make them make their own way as equals... sink or swim on your own merits and devices... if you prefer to substance it up and wind up in prison repeatedly - your choice - choice-mobile, son - that's what it's all about.


Have you seen the ad for the BLM special coming on with Oprah Winfrey & all the other black virtue signalling celebrity millionaires(wonder how that came about with all the oppression ::) ) .... anways .... there's a byte of a black Minister saying - " that what ever comes of this, "we"(blacks) should remember not to ask for too little".

What's that supposed to mean ... more reparations? 

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gnads on Jun 26th, 2020 at 11:02am

UnSubRocky wrote on Jun 26th, 2020 at 10:44am:

Sir Grappler Truth Teller OAM wrote on Jun 23rd, 2020 at 8:27am:
In retrospect, Rudd showing the belly was not a good thing in the long run... just inspired them to demand more and more.  Should've learned that from the 'feminists'.. give 'em an inch and they take an entire state... and every other -ist learned from them how it's done.

Appeasement hasn't worked yet and never will... sometimes the field of freedom must be fertilised with blood... sad but true - while we of the West spent hundreds of years becoming more 'civilised', lesser cultures view this as weakness (and showing the belly) and thus take advantage at every opportunity.

Time to cut the ties to mother's apron and make them make their own way as equals... sink or swim on your own merits and devices... if you prefer to substance it up and wind up in prison repeatedly - your choice - choice-mobile, son - that's what it's all about.


I can see where some aborigines are going with their claims involving Black Lives Matter. They are concerned that they are going to be an endangered racial group on this continent. It is their last hurrah to make a name for themselves in marking history as defenders of their own race.

And as much as I would like to see indigenous people make their own way in the world and endure the hard life that the rest of Australians have to do, we might have crossed the point where reconciliation can take place in Australia -- at least for a while. It seems that the majority of Australians are making allowances and giving privileges towards indigenous people for the sake of not wanting to look like outsiders/colonisers.

The indigenous people know that they have Australians (of non-aboriginal ethnicity) by the testicles since the 1970s. Aborigines can play that "poor bugger me" attitude and try and get as much international support as they can among recently decolonised nearby regional countries. I can only imagine that the Chinese might be in talks to fund some kind of unrest among the indigenous extremists in Australia.

It would take a real global shift back in favour of the Western nations (and the United States) before we can see our western ideals be reinstated as the best cultural background to emulate. Aboriginal cultures and customs can be continued by the adherents. Aboriginal cultures and customs can be recorded to print, audio, and video media. But, the aboriginal culture really has no values that can be helpful to the modern Australian society. Indigenous people should join the rest of Australian for a common cause rather than get in the way.


Well they had better stop marrying/partnering & having children outside their race don't you think?

You do realise that there has been a huge increase in the population of Aboriginals, TIs & those who identify as such in the past 20 years?

Endangered my eye ....

1999 pop. was 418,800

2020 pop. 798,365

Nearly doubled in 20 years.  ::)

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by UnSubRocky on Jun 26th, 2020 at 2:07pm

Gnads wrote on Jun 26th, 2020 at 11:02am:

Well they had better stop marrying/partnering & having children outside their race don't you think?

You do realise that there has been a huge increase in the population of Aboriginals, TIs & those who identify as such in the past 20 years?

Endangered my eye ....

1999 pop. was 418,800

2020 pop. 798,365

Nearly doubled in 20 years.  ::)


Probably because people can claim to be aboriginal if they have aboriginal ancestry that goes back 5 or 6 generations. They might look like a bronze Eurasian. But if their great-grandmother was aboriginal, they can consider themselves aborigine.

It is no surprise then that having an average 3 children per aboriginal family (biracial or not), their numbers will grow. Some people who did not claim to be aboriginal in 1999 are probably considering themselves aboriginal now, through advanced DNA tracing. That just adds to the numbers.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gnads on Jun 26th, 2020 at 6:29pm

UnSubRocky wrote on Jun 26th, 2020 at 2:07pm:

Gnads wrote on Jun 26th, 2020 at 11:02am:

Well they had better stop marrying/partnering & having children outside their race don't you think?

You do realise that there has been a huge increase in the population of Aboriginals, TIs & those who identify as such in the past 20 years?

Endangered my eye ....

1999 pop. was 418,800

2020 pop. 798,365

Nearly doubled in 20 years.  ::)


Probably because people can claim to be aboriginal if they have aboriginal ancestry that goes back 5 or 6 generations. They might look like a bronze Eurasian. But if their great-grandmother was aboriginal, they can consider themselves aborigine.

It is no surprise then that having an average 3 children per aboriginal family (biracial or not), their numbers will grow. Some people who did not claim to be aboriginal in 1999 are probably considering themselves aboriginal now, through advanced DNA tracing. That just adds to the numbers.


Not double in 20 years ... that aint 3 per family.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jun 26th, 2020 at 8:22pm

John Smith wrote on Jun 26th, 2020 at 9:51am:

Quote:
did the protestors spread the virus?


Looks like the answer is NO

[quote]Tweeting this week, Liberal senator Sarah Henderson said:  "Daniel Andrews blames law abiding Victorian families for doing the wrong thing rather than 10,000 illegal protesters?"

Some of Senator Henderson's Liberal Party colleagues, including Matthew Guy, Georgie Crozier and Tim Smith, as well as Evan Mulholland of the Institute of Public Affairs, tweeted similar criticisms, while headlines have also declared that the "upsurge in COVID cases [is] linked to Melbourne Black Lives Matter protests".

But these assertions contradict the guidance of officials of the Victorian Department of Health and Human Services, who continue to report that the current burst of cases does not stem from the rally. They have said that while one protester "may have been infectious at the rally", two others who have since tested positive for COVID-19 were not infectious at the rally, nor is there evidence they contracted the virus at the rally.

Rather, Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Brett Sutton, has linked the increase in cases to family gatherings, citing family spread as the "main cause" of 120 cases in the week to June 22.

People have not followed our advice around physical distancing, hygiene and limiting the number of people you invite into your home," he said in a statement.

Australia's Deputy Chief Medical Officer, Nick Coatsworth, also dismissed claims the spike could be linked to the protests, telling reporters that "there is no evidence that there has been chains of community transmission that we are aware of through the Black Lives Matter protests".

According to official Australian Government advice, "most people who are infected will develop symptoms within 14 days of infection". It has been 20 days since the Black Lives Matter protest in Melbourne.


https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-06-26/coronacheck-victoria-black-lives-matter-protests-family-spike/12391628


FD will be so disappointed :D[/quote]

Disappointed that they are still preventing people from going fishing and other benign outdoor activities, despite the rally. All those beach bans were obviously a waste of time.

37 new cases yesterday. We haven't had that many since April 19.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by JaSin. on Jun 26th, 2020 at 8:27pm
Bermagui Locals fuming at the Vic Tourists buying out Woolworth's stocks in bulk.
Bega Woolworth's lacking Toilet Paper again.
Eden-Monaro SuperMarkets return to restrictions.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Ye Grappler on Jun 27th, 2020 at 2:50am
"They have said that while one protester "may have been infectious at the rally", two others who have since tested positive for COVID-19 were not infectious at the rally, "

So - errrrr - when WERE they infectious?  Dare one ask?

This - Poppets - is called Spin......  :-?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Ye Grappler on Jun 27th, 2020 at 2:51am

Jasin wrote on Jun 26th, 2020 at 8:27pm:
Bermagui Locals fuming at the Vic Tourists buying out Woolworth's stocks in bulk.
Bega Woolworth's lacking Toilet Paper again.
Eden-Monaro SuperMarkets return to restrictions.


As if they haven't had enough sh1t thrown at them in recent months...   ::)  ::)  ::)

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Ye Grappler on Jun 27th, 2020 at 2:57am
I'd like to know - as per my right wing ex for whom I am carer - why it is that there are people STILL being tested after a holiday OFFSHORE and being found to be the source of extended contagions?????

"just returned from a cruise"... "just returned from blah-blah"..

What are these people?  Secret Boat People?

DUH - 14 people who returned to Victoria from holidays tested positive and spread the beast... DUH????

Whoa, Dudes and Dudesses - did they pick it up on a trip to New South Wales .. or was it South Australia?    :-?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gnads on Jun 27th, 2020 at 7:47am

freediver wrote on Jun 26th, 2020 at 8:22pm:

John Smith wrote on Jun 26th, 2020 at 9:51am:

Quote:
did the protestors spread the virus?


Looks like the answer is NO

[quote]Tweeting this week, Liberal senator Sarah Henderson said:  "Daniel Andrews blames law abiding Victorian families for doing the wrong thing rather than 10,000 illegal protesters?"

Some of Senator Henderson's Liberal Party colleagues, including Matthew Guy, Georgie Crozier and Tim Smith, as well as Evan Mulholland of the Institute of Public Affairs, tweeted similar criticisms, while headlines have also declared that the "upsurge in COVID cases [is] linked to Melbourne Black Lives Matter protests".

But these assertions contradict the guidance of officials of the Victorian Department of Health and Human Services, who continue to report that the current burst of cases does not stem from the rally. They have said that while one protester "may have been infectious at the rally", two others who have since tested positive for COVID-19 were not infectious at the rally, nor is there evidence they contracted the virus at the rally.

Rather, Victoria’s Chief Health Officer, Brett Sutton, has linked the increase in cases to family gatherings, citing family spread as the "main cause" of 120 cases in the week to June 22.

People have not followed our advice around physical distancing, hygiene and limiting the number of people you invite into your home," he said in a statement.

Australia's Deputy Chief Medical Officer, Nick Coatsworth, also dismissed claims the spike could be linked to the protests, telling reporters that "there is no evidence that there has been chains of community transmission that we are aware of through the Black Lives Matter protests".

According to official Australian Government advice, "most people who are infected will develop symptoms within 14 days of infection". It has been 20 days since the Black Lives Matter protest in Melbourne.


https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-06-26/coronacheck-victoria-black-lives-matter-protests-family-spike/12391628


FD will be so disappointed :D


Disappointed that they are still preventing people from going fishing and other benign outdoor activities, despite the rally. All those beach bans were obviously a waste of time.

37 new cases yesterday. We haven't had that many since April 19.[/quote]

Where are they doing that? Certainly not in QLD.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jun 27th, 2020 at 8:50am
A few days after the protest, they closed a big pier to fishing in Victoria.


Quote:
Australia's Deputy Chief Medical Officer, Nick Coatsworth, also dismissed claims the spike could be linked to the protests, telling reporters that "there is no evidence that there has been chains of community transmission that we are aware of through the Black Lives Matter protests".


No evidence of things they do not know?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by UnSubRocky on Jun 27th, 2020 at 9:24am

Gnads wrote on Jun 26th, 2020 at 6:29pm:

UnSubRocky wrote on Jun 26th, 2020 at 2:07pm:

Gnads wrote on Jun 26th, 2020 at 11:02am:

Well they had better stop marrying/partnering & having children outside their race don't you think?

You do realise that there has been a huge increase in the population of Aboriginals, TIs & those who identify as such in the past 20 years?

Endangered my eye ....

1999 pop. was 418,800

2020 pop. 798,365

Nearly doubled in 20 years.  ::)


Probably because people can claim to be aboriginal if they have aboriginal ancestry that goes back 5 or 6 generations. They might look like a bronze Eurasian. But if their great-grandmother was aboriginal, they can consider themselves aborigine.

It is no surprise then that having an average 3 children per aboriginal family (biracial or not), their numbers will grow. Some people who did not claim to be aboriginal in 1999 are probably considering themselves aboriginal now, through advanced DNA tracing. That just adds to the numbers.


Not double in 20 years ... that aint 3 per family.


You can double a population inside 20 years. Lowered death rates and a decent birth rate would double the population of a racial group. And the few that did not identify as aboriginal in the 1996 census would likely have put aboriginal as an ancestry in 2016 census. It can happen.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by UnSubRocky on Jun 27th, 2020 at 9:29am

Jasin wrote on Jun 26th, 2020 at 8:27pm:
Bermagui Locals fuming at the Vic Tourists buying out Woolworth's stocks in bulk.
Bega Woolworth's lacking Toilet Paper again.
Eden-Monaro SuperMarkets return to restrictions.


I have just awoken to news that the grocery stores have reintroduced buying restrictions for toilet paper again. Panic buying has set in with shelves looking empty. Ahh Rockhampton. You need to keep up with the southern states. That includes acting like idiots.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gnads on Jun 27th, 2020 at 10:10am

UnSubRocky wrote on Jun 27th, 2020 at 9:29am:

Jasin wrote on Jun 26th, 2020 at 8:27pm:
Bermagui Locals fuming at the Vic Tourists buying out Woolworth's stocks in bulk.
Bega Woolworth's lacking Toilet Paper again.
Eden-Monaro SuperMarkets return to restrictions.


I have just awoken to news that the grocery stores have reintroduced buying restrictions for toilet paper again. Panic buying has set in with shelves looking empty. Ahh Rockhampton. You need to keep up with the southern states. That includes acting like idiots.


So much for my plan to get back to my normal method of buying in bulk through a wholesaler.

That won't be available again as well.  >:(

I also blame the supermarkets for allowing it to get going again......

trolleys full of toilet paper should have been turned around, told to put it back or leave the store.

We'll end up with permanent restrictions on items if this keeps up.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Lols on Jun 27th, 2020 at 3:04pm

Gnads wrote on Jun 27th, 2020 at 10:10am:

UnSubRocky wrote on Jun 27th, 2020 at 9:29am:

Jasin wrote on Jun 26th, 2020 at 8:27pm:
Bermagui Locals fuming at the Vic Tourists buying out Woolworth's stocks in bulk.
Bega Woolworth's lacking Toilet Paper again.
Eden-Monaro SuperMarkets return to restrictions.


I have just awoken to news that the grocery stores have reintroduced buying restrictions for toilet paper again. Panic buying has set in with shelves looking empty. Ahh Rockhampton. You need to keep up with the southern states. That includes acting like idiots.


So much for my plan to get back to my normal method of buying in bulk through a wholesaler.

That won't be available again as well.  >:(

I also blame the supermarkets for allowing it to get going again......

trolleys full of toilet paper should have been turned around, told to put it back or leave the store.

We'll end up with permanent restrictions on items if this keeps up.

That’s not what I have seen, there are notices up specifically instructing one packet toilet roll per customer.
So they are not letting it get away again, they have learn well from before.
But then again, that’s in Victoria, why would there be panic buying up in Queensland when only one case covid infected appeared overnight?

I’m sure you can do the bulk buying Gnads, find out rather than assuming.
Let us know how it goes.

In the meantime, this bothers me....but what bothers me more, there is this debate, whether returned travellers should be tested for covid or not.... say what???? :o And then this spike overnight....41 cases in Botchtoria Victoria  :o

https://apple.news/A734NmCNdQeKknozTS_J0Kw

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by JaSin. on Jun 27th, 2020 at 3:13pm
Just noticed some more shops having put up their Virus Shields and implemented strict measures again.
Hopefully it doesn't get worse, as Victorians are a welcome influx during holidays - which makes a big difference to the region. These school holidays will again be a fizzer for Tourism here - but it's been like that since the holidays.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gnads on Jun 27th, 2020 at 5:58pm

Sophia wrote on Jun 27th, 2020 at 3:04pm:

Gnads wrote on Jun 27th, 2020 at 10:10am:

UnSubRocky wrote on Jun 27th, 2020 at 9:29am:

Jasin wrote on Jun 26th, 2020 at 8:27pm:
Bermagui Locals fuming at the Vic Tourists buying out Woolworth's stocks in bulk.
Bega Woolworth's lacking Toilet Paper again.
Eden-Monaro SuperMarkets return to restrictions.


I have just awoken to news that the grocery stores have reintroduced buying restrictions for toilet paper again. Panic buying has set in with shelves looking empty. Ahh Rockhampton. You need to keep up with the southern states. That includes acting like idiots.


So much for my plan to get back to my normal method of buying in bulk through a wholesaler.

That won't be available again as well.  >:(

I also blame the supermarkets for allowing it to get going again......

trolleys full of toilet paper should have been turned around, told to put it back or leave the store.

We'll end up with permanent restrictions on items if this keeps up.

That’s not what I have seen, there are notices up specifically instructing one packet toilet roll per customer.
So they are not letting it get away again, they have learn well from before.
But then again, that’s in Victoria, why would there be panic buying up in Queensland when only one case covid infected appeared overnight?

I’m sure you can do the bulk buying Gnads, find out rather than assuming.
Let us know how it goes.

In the meantime, this bothers me....but what bothers me more, there is this debate, whether returned travellers should be tested for covid or not.... say what???? :o And then this spike overnight....41 cases in Botchtoria Victoria  :o

https://apple.news/A734NmCNdQeKknozTS_J0Kw



Then why are toilet roll areas in supermarkets in Vic & NSW empty again?

Are those on here reporting a scarcity again
fibbing?

There have been less cases in QLD than in NSW & Vic from the outset ......

but the panic buying went through QLD just like it did everywhere else.

The world is full of stupid people ...no?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Lols on Jun 27th, 2020 at 6:14pm

Quote:
Then why are toilet roll areas in supermarkets in Vic & NSW empty again?

Are those on here reporting a scarcity again
fibbing?

There have been less cases in QLD than in NSW & Vic from the outset ......

but the panic buying went through QLD just like it did everywhere else.

The world is full of stupid people ...no?


Oh you have to be kidding 🤭😂
Yes, rarely I like agreeing with you Gnads 🤨 coz I love giving you stick, so read my signature below, to my agreeing with you re: the world full of stupid people ....never been more apt eh 😏

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jun 28th, 2020 at 9:40am
46 new cases yesterday. That's 10% of our maximum ever daily count. I think we are in the second wave, and this time it is all local community transmission.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gnads on Jun 28th, 2020 at 9:43am

Sophia wrote on Jun 27th, 2020 at 6:14pm:

Quote:
Then why are toilet roll areas in supermarkets in Vic & NSW empty again?

Are those on here reporting a scarcity again
fibbing?

There have been less cases in QLD than in NSW & Vic from the outset ......

but the panic buying went through QLD just like it did everywhere else.

The world is full of stupid people ...no?


Oh you have to be kidding 🤭😂
Yes, rarely I like agreeing with you Gnads 🤨 coz I love giving you stick, so read my signature below, to my agreeing with you re: the world full of stupid people ....never been more apt eh 😏


Yeah  ;D When are you changing your rego plates?
104868742_1585495061604934_8770703581599342780_n.jpg (75 KB | 17 )

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Lols on Jun 28th, 2020 at 2:24pm

Gnads wrote on Jun 28th, 2020 at 9:43am:

Sophia wrote on Jun 27th, 2020 at 6:14pm:

Quote:
Then why are toilet roll areas in supermarkets in Vic & NSW empty again?

Are those on here reporting a scarcity again
fibbing?

There have been less cases in QLD than in NSW & Vic from the outset ......

but the panic buying went through QLD just like it did everywhere else.

The world is full of stupid people ...no?


Oh you have to be kidding 🤭😂
Yes, rarely I like agreeing with you Gnads 🤨 coz I love giving you stick, so read my signature below, to my agreeing with you re: the world full of stupid people ....never been more apt eh 😏


Yeah  ;D When are you changing your rego plates?


Maybe long due past the date now, I wish I left Victoria long ago, it’s turned to shyte. I’m not proud.
Queensland Sunshine State on my rego plate would be ideal now!

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by J.D. on Jun 28th, 2020 at 2:42pm
The protesters had no idea if they would spread the virus and kill people, nobody did and they didn't care.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by UnSubRocky on Jun 28th, 2020 at 8:03pm

Johnnie wrote on Jun 28th, 2020 at 2:42pm:
The protesters had no idea if they would spread the virus and kill people, nobody did and they didn't care.


I am not actually concerned about a bunch of BLM protesters getting the virus. I am getting concerned that if they do the right thing, 14 days self-isolation won't be long enough to settle them down. I actually would not care if they go back to aboriginal communities and then they go quiet for a long time that police and advocates have to go check on them.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by UnSubRocky on Jun 28th, 2020 at 8:07pm

Jasin wrote on Jun 27th, 2020 at 3:13pm:
Just noticed some more shops having put up their Virus Shields and implemented strict measures again.
Hopefully it doesn't get worse, as Victorians are a welcome influx during holidays - which makes a big difference to the region. These school holidays will again be a fizzer for Tourism here - but it's been like that since the holidays.


We have not taken ours down since we had them up in April. Barely anyone is practicing social distancing, except on escalators. I still shower up to 4 times a day. I have upped my vitamin C intake. And I have taken to putting green tea bags in my water canister to help lower my blood sugar levels.

I think all of the out of towners who have come back with the virus have either up and left and/or been cured of the virus. But, we are not taking any chances.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by JaSin. on Jun 28th, 2020 at 8:15pm

UnSubRocky wrote on Jun 28th, 2020 at 8:07pm:

Jasin wrote on Jun 27th, 2020 at 3:13pm:
Just noticed some more shops having put up their Virus Shields and implemented strict measures again.
Hopefully it doesn't get worse, as Victorians are a welcome influx during holidays - which makes a big difference to the region. These school holidays will again be a fizzer for Tourism here - but it's been like that since the holidays.


We have not taken ours down since we had them up in April. Barely anyone is practicing social distancing, except on escalators. I still shower up to 4 times a day. I have upped my vitamin C intake. And I have taken to putting green tea bags in my water canister to help lower my blood sugar levels.

I think all of the out of towners who have come back with the virus have either up and left and/or been cured of the virus. But, we are not taking any chances.


Go the Multi-Vitamins. Cover all bases. But only take one a day, never more - or you can do some overload on your organs. Men lack Zinc, like women lack Iron, so Oysters are good for you - just a 6-pak a week.  ;)

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by UnSubRocky on Jun 28th, 2020 at 9:43pm

Jasin wrote on Jun 28th, 2020 at 8:15pm:
Go the Multi-Vitamins. Cover all bases. But only take one a day, never more - or you can do some overload on your organs. Men lack Zinc, like women lack Iron, so Oysters are good for you - just a 6-pak a week.  ;)


Australian men lack iodine because of the lack of iodine in Australian soils. Zinc is only deficient for a few men. I have an oversupply of vitamins in my cupboard that I will only buy a few items for next year.

I buy calcium and vitamin D tablets for the winter months. I get fish oil and glucosamine tablets to keep my joints functioning well. I have vitamin C tables that I have yet to get through this year. Every other tablets that I use has been for optional betterment of health. I have found that if I stick to drinking black or green tea and taking my diabetes medication, that is enough to keep me healthy.

But, if I get a cold sometime (which I figure might be soon), I will be getting through my lime juice and aspro clear to get rid of the sickness as soon as possible.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Lols on Jun 29th, 2020 at 10:46am
Wow look at these new infections in US of A 🤭

Could this surge be in a timely fashion of Covid infections from those street gatherings/protests/looting etc? Coincidentally? I don’t think so but...
Whoa 😮 over 40,000 !!! A day mind you!
And here in Victoria we have 40 ish .... seems weird in comparison but.... if we don’t knock it on the head....it will grow exponentially.




Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gnads on Jun 29th, 2020 at 12:23pm

UnSubRocky wrote on Jun 28th, 2020 at 9:43pm:

Jasin wrote on Jun 28th, 2020 at 8:15pm:
Go the Multi-Vitamins. Cover all bases. But only take one a day, never more - or you can do some overload on your organs. Men lack Zinc, like women lack Iron, so Oysters are good for you - just a 6-pak a week.  ;)


Australian men lack iodine because of the lack of iodine in Australian soils. Zinc is only deficient for a few men. I have an oversupply of vitamins in my cupboard that I will only buy a few items for next year.

I buy calcium and vitamin D tablets for the winter months. I get fish oil and glucosamine tablets to keep my joints functioning well. I have vitamin C tables that I have yet to get through this year. Every other tablets that I use has been for optional betterment of health. I have found that if I stick to drinking black or green tea and taking my diabetes medication, that is enough to keep me healthy.

But, if I get a cold sometime (which I figure might be soon), I will be getting through my lime juice and aspro clear to get rid of the sickness as soon as possible.


You're wasting you money on vitamins .... we lead lives of excess not lack.

Unless you have a medical condition that drains essentials from your system & creates a deficiency you shouldn't need or use them.

It's best diagnosed by a doctor after blood tests.

The body excretes most of what you take & all it does is make your piss change colour whilst you're making some bastard rich.

As well as prescription drugs have you ever stopped to think what all this does to our river & marine environments through the outfalls of our sewerage treatment works?

Plus all the fluoride in public water supplies.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by UnSubRocky on Jun 29th, 2020 at 12:36pm

Gnads wrote on Jun 29th, 2020 at 12:23pm:
You're wasting you money on vitamins .... we lead lives of excess not lack.


I think I conceded that amount in my last post. Next year, I won't be buying nearly half the stuff I bought earlier this year. Just the medication. The doctor just tells me to up my vitamin D intake. Perhaps that would be the only once a year supplement I do from here onwards.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by greggerypeccary on Jun 29th, 2020 at 12:40pm

Gnads wrote on Jun 29th, 2020 at 12:23pm:
The body excretes most of what you take & all it does is make your piss change colour whilst you're making some bastard rich.


Sadly, this is true.


Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by UnSubRocky on Jun 29th, 2020 at 12:40pm
I said it before and I will say it again. I cannot believe that the USA is so pathetic that it would let themselves get so infected by a virus. And the death toll just makes them look so third world.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by greggerypeccary on Jun 29th, 2020 at 12:46pm

UnSubRocky wrote on Jun 29th, 2020 at 12:40pm:
I said it before and I will say it again. I cannot believe that the USA is so pathetic that it would let themselves get so infected by a virus. And the death toll just makes them look so third world.


It's extraordinary that Trump is allowed to remain in the White House.

He's killing thousands of Americans and nobody seems to have the power to do anything about it.

They need to flush the turd on November 3rd.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by UnSubRocky on Jun 29th, 2020 at 1:28pm

greggerypeccary wrote on Jun 29th, 2020 at 12:46pm:

UnSubRocky wrote on Jun 29th, 2020 at 12:40pm:
I said it before and I will say it again. I cannot believe that the USA is so pathetic that it would let themselves get so infected by a virus. And the death toll just makes them look so third world.


It's extraordinary that Trump is allowed to remain in the White House.

He's killing thousands of Americans and nobody seems to have the power to do anything about it.

They need to flush the turd on November 3rd.


The last federal elections consisted of two narcissists. It came down to whoever was the more entertaining. Because of the superiority complex of Americans, the voters had to vote in someone that they could make a mockery of a president without the mockery getting tiresome too soon. Hilary's speeches would have vexated the public long before the mockeries got passed their used by date. Trump just makes the general public feel at ease with his mindlessness.

Joe Biden could probably change things up with his own delusional talking. But I would settle for Mike Pence taking the top job.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by greggerypeccary on Jun 29th, 2020 at 1:40pm

UnSubRocky wrote on Jun 29th, 2020 at 1:28pm:

greggerypeccary wrote on Jun 29th, 2020 at 12:46pm:

UnSubRocky wrote on Jun 29th, 2020 at 12:40pm:
I said it before and I will say it again. I cannot believe that the USA is so pathetic that it would let themselves get so infected by a virus. And the death toll just makes them look so third world.


It's extraordinary that Trump is allowed to remain in the White House.

He's killing thousands of Americans and nobody seems to have the power to do anything about it.

They need to flush the turd on November 3rd.


The last federal elections consisted of two narcissists. It came down to whoever was the more entertaining. Because of the superiority complex of Americans, the voters had to vote in someone that they could make a mockery of a president without the mockery getting tiresome too soon. Hilary's speeches would have vexated the public long before the mockeries got passed their used by date. Trump just makes the general public feel at ease with his mindlessness.

Joe Biden could probably change things up with his own delusional talking. But I would settle for Mike Pence taking the top job.


The voters chose Hillary though.

Trump was chosen by the electoral college.

Mike Pence would be every bit as bad as Trump, if not worse.

I've come around to Biden - he might actually be exactly what the country needs.

We'll just have to see who his VP is - he'll announce his decision in the next few weeks.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by J.D. on Jun 29th, 2020 at 4:28pm

Gnads wrote on Jun 29th, 2020 at 12:23pm:

UnSubRocky wrote on Jun 28th, 2020 at 9:43pm:

Jasin wrote on Jun 28th, 2020 at 8:15pm:
Go the Multi-Vitamins. Cover all bases. But only take one a day, never more - or you can do some overload on your organs. Men lack Zinc, like women lack Iron, so Oysters are good for you - just a 6-pak a week.  ;)


Australian men lack iodine because of the lack of iodine in Australian soils. Zinc is only deficient for a few men. I have an oversupply of vitamins in my cupboard that I will only buy a few items for next year.

I buy calcium and vitamin D tablets for the winter months. I get fish oil and glucosamine tablets to keep my joints functioning well. I have vitamin C tables that I have yet to get through this year. Every other tablets that I use has been for optional betterment of health. I have found that if I stick to drinking black or green tea and taking my diabetes medication, that is enough to keep me healthy.

But, if I get a cold sometime (which I figure might be soon), I will be getting through my lime juice and aspro clear to get rid of the sickness as soon as possible.


You're wasting you money on vitamins .... we lead lives of excess not lack.

Unless you have a medical condition that drains essentials from your system & creates a deficiency you shouldn't need or use them.

It's best diagnosed by a doctor after blood tests.

The body excretes most of what you take & all it does is make your piss change colour whilst you're making some bastard rich.

As well as prescription drugs have you ever stopped to think what all this does to our river & marine environments through the outfalls of our sewerage treatment works?

Plus all the fluoride in public water supplies.

I have been taking multi vitamins zinc and fish oil for over 20yrs, not for any condition but as a type of insurance policy. I never get sick but i never did.

There are a lot of trace elements vitamins and minerals in multi vitamin tablets and unless you are eating right all the time you will be lacking.

Zink and fish oil can do no harm, fish oil has proven to be a winner for a lot of things

Fish chips a multi and a six pack for dinner tonight.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gnads on Jun 29th, 2020 at 5:03pm

greggerypeccary wrote on Jun 29th, 2020 at 1:40pm:

UnSubRocky wrote on Jun 29th, 2020 at 1:28pm:

greggerypeccary wrote on Jun 29th, 2020 at 12:46pm:

UnSubRocky wrote on Jun 29th, 2020 at 12:40pm:
I said it before and I will say it again. I cannot believe that the USA is so pathetic that it would let themselves get so infected by a virus. And the death toll just makes them look so third world.


It's extraordinary that Trump is allowed to remain in the White House.

He's killing thousands of Americans and nobody seems to have the power to do anything about it.

They need to flush the turd on November 3rd.


The last federal elections consisted of two narcissists. It came down to whoever was the more entertaining. Because of the superiority complex of Americans, the voters had to vote in someone that they could make a mockery of a president without the mockery getting tiresome too soon. Hilary's speeches would have vexated the public long before the mockeries got passed their used by date. Trump just makes the general public feel at ease with his mindlessness.

Joe Biden could probably change things up with his own delusional talking. But I would settle for Mike Pence taking the top job.


The voters chose Hillary though.

Trump was chosen by the electoral college.

Mike Pence would be every bit as bad as Trump, if not worse.

I've come around to Biden - he might actually be exactly what the country needs.

We'll just have to see who his VP is - he'll announce his decision in the next few weeks.


Biden has dementia or a few roos loose in the top paddock.

He's 77 yrs old & is a sleezy old hands man on the young things ..... & you crap on about Trump.  ::)

Hilary lost get over it.

She would have been a disaster ...... only positive had she won would have been for her .......it would have been easier for her  to make sure anyone who had anything on her disappeared.

Benghazi! 


Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jun 29th, 2020 at 8:58pm

Quote:
You're wasting you money on vitamins .... we lead lives of excess not lack.


Excess of calories. Not necessarily excess of vitamins.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by UnSubRocky on Jun 30th, 2020 at 2:27am

Johnnie wrote on Jun 29th, 2020 at 4:28pm:
I have been taking multi vitamins zinc and fish oil for over 20yrs, not for any condition but as a type of insurance policy. I never get sick but i never did.

There are a lot of trace elements vitamins and minerals in multi vitamin tablets and unless you are eating right all the time you will be lacking.

Zink and fish oil can do no harm, fish oil has proven to be a winner for a lot of things

Fish chips a multi and a six pack for dinner tonight.


I don't know what it is lately, but I have been getting tired more often after eating. I know that it has to do with the insulin production in my body. But, these have been worse lately than before. I know I have not done right by my body with the recent increase in alcohol. But, I think I have triggered an oversupply of insulin production in my body from simply not spacing my drinking sessions.

I have not a multivitamin supply for some time. I just stick to vitamins that my doctor says needs to be replenished artificially. I have found that the vitamin D tablets have helped with energy and muscle growth. I did start retaking these vitamin D tablets with a calcium combination. However, I think I have provoked some restart of my bone spurs that I had last year.

I use green tea bags that I put in my water canister when I go to work. On a brief rehydration break, I find that I feel a bit more energised from the cold green tea. Water does help. But green tea seems to improve my energy levels with the caffeine.

Recent weeks have seen me experience either mild cold sores, or some mosquito bite pimples. I have been drained of energy to some extent. I was going to go for a walk tonight. But I feel like just turning in to bed and sleeping 10 hours. Either I catch a cold and get over it for the year. Or I have to improve my mosquito zapper range.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gnads on Jun 30th, 2020 at 6:47am

UnSubRocky wrote on Jun 30th, 2020 at 2:27am:

Johnnie wrote on Jun 29th, 2020 at 4:28pm:
I have been taking multi vitamins zinc and fish oil for over 20yrs, not for any condition but as a type of insurance policy. I never get sick but i never did.

There are a lot of trace elements vitamins and minerals in multi vitamin tablets and unless you are eating right all the time you will be lacking.

Zink and fish oil can do no harm, fish oil has proven to be a winner for a lot of things

Fish chips a multi and a six pack for dinner tonight.


I don't know what it is lately, but I have been getting tired more often after eating. I know that it has to do with the insulin production in my body. But, these have been worse lately than before. I know I have not done right by my body with the recent increase in alcohol. But, I think I have triggered an oversupply of insulin production in my body from simply not spacing my drinking sessions.

I have not a multivitamin supply for some time. I just stick to vitamins that my doctor says needs to be replenished artificially. I have found that the vitamin D tablets have helped with energy and muscle growth. I did start retaking these vitamin D tablets with a calcium combination. However, I think I have provoked some restart of my bone spurs that I had last year.

I use green tea bags that I put in my water canister when I go to work. On a brief rehydration break, I find that I feel a bit more energised from the cold green tea. Water does help. But green tea seems to improve my energy levels with the caffeine.

Recent weeks have seen me experience either mild cold sores, or some mosquito bite pimples. I have been drained of energy to some extent. I was going to go for a walk tonight. But I feel like just turning in to bed and sleeping 10 hours. Either I catch a cold and get over it for the year. Or I have to improve my mosquito zapper range.


Get tested ;D

Mosquitoes this weather? None down here.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gnads on Jun 30th, 2020 at 7:49am

freediver wrote on Jun 29th, 2020 at 8:58pm:

Quote:
You're wasting you money on vitamins .... we lead lives of excess not lack.


Excess of calories. Not necessarily excess of vitamins.


Unless you're on some weird diet you should get everything you need from what you eat ....

excesses of any one particular thing should be avoided.

Check the content labels & see what is in cereals - processed & unprocessed, vegetables the same, meats, cheeses, fruits, breads.....

it's all there.

Unless you are lacking because of a certain medical condition or disease...........

you are wasting your money.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by greggerypeccary on Jun 30th, 2020 at 8:41am

Gnads wrote on Jun 30th, 2020 at 7:49am:

freediver wrote on Jun 29th, 2020 at 8:58pm:

Quote:
You're wasting you money on vitamins .... we lead lives of excess not lack.


Excess of calories. Not necessarily excess of vitamins.


Unless you're on some weird diet you should get everything you need from what you eat ....

excesses of any one particular thing should be avoided.

Check the content labels & see what is in cereals - processed & unprocessed, vegetables the same, meats, cheeses, fruits, breads.....

it's all there.

Unless you are lacking because of a certain medical condition or disease...........

you are wasting your money.


Yep, the vitamin industry is pretty much a scam.


Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by mothra on Jun 30th, 2020 at 8:48am

greggerypeccary wrote on Jun 30th, 2020 at 8:41am:

Gnads wrote on Jun 30th, 2020 at 7:49am:

freediver wrote on Jun 29th, 2020 at 8:58pm:

Quote:
You're wasting you money on vitamins .... we lead lives of excess not lack.


Excess of calories. Not necessarily excess of vitamins.


Unless you're on some weird diet you should get everything you need from what you eat ....

excesses of any one particular thing should be avoided.

Check the content labels & see what is in cereals - processed & unprocessed, vegetables the same, meats, cheeses, fruits, breads.....

it's all there.

Unless you are lacking because of a certain medical condition or disease...........

you are wasting your money.


Yep, the vitamin industry is pretty much a scam.


Yes and no. I'm lost in the quote bubble but whoever said "excess of calories, not excess of vitamins" was on the money.

This is, however, quite rare and a good doctor will pick it up without a blood test. Hell, most times, your mum can.

Even then mostly, it's better to increase a vitamin loading food or drink than to pop a pill but sometimes , a pill i what is required.

I'd love to say we get all we need in our diets but so many diets are just junk. It's actually quite alarming how malnourished we are, as a country. Not as far behind the US as we would like to think.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by greggerypeccary on Jun 30th, 2020 at 9:14am

mothra wrote on Jun 30th, 2020 at 8:48am:
Even then mostly, it's better to increase a vitamin loading food or drink than to pop a pill but sometimes , a pill i what is required.


Sometimes, sure.

If you're sick and rundown, go for it.

But the advertising that suggests healthy people should take them daily for "everyday health" is just nonsense.




Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by mothra on Jun 30th, 2020 at 9:16am

greggerypeccary wrote on Jun 30th, 2020 at 9:14am:

mothra wrote on Jun 30th, 2020 at 8:48am:
Even then mostly, it's better to increase a vitamin loading food or drink than to pop a pill but sometimes , a pill i what is required.


Sometimes, sure.

If you're sick and rundown, go for it.

But the advertising that suggests healthy people should take them daily for "everyday health" is just nonsense.



Agreed. Multivitamins are particularly odious.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Ye Grappler on Jun 30th, 2020 at 9:33am
Eat yer carrots and greens and spuds... (aaargh).. I yam what I yam...


Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Lols on Jun 30th, 2020 at 10:17am

freediver wrote on Jun 29th, 2020 at 8:58pm:

Quote:
You're wasting you money on vitamins .... we lead lives of excess not lack.


Excess of calories. Not necessarily excess of vitamins.


Agree.
Excess of empty calories at that.
BTW, minerals are lacking/depleted in soil,  hence minerals are lacking in our diet.
I recall they used to do a vitamin count on a fruit basket periodically in the 90s, and comparing it with previous fruit and veges tested.
It showed how vitamin C , for instance, was becoming depleted in the fruit.

What’s our fruit and veges like with vitamin count of late?

I had a blood test from Doc, and found I was low in vitamin D which isn’t all surprising since I live in a state that’s cold for 9 months of the year, so vitamin D was recommended I take from the Doctor.

When I was pregnant, by 5 months I became pale looking, and very tired.
Obstetrician did blood test to find I was very low in iron and prescribed iron tablets, then did a further blood test and found the iron had risen, which meant I didn’t feel as tired.

There’s 2 of my own examples why vitamins are not a scam or nonsense.

And I find out, people with cancer, are severely lacking vitamin C.... either the lack of vitamin C is a contributing factor that could lead to cancer, or the cancer causes a depletion off vitamin C within the body.

Not forgetting how sailors in the olde days of tall sailing ships suffered and died from scurvy, only to find later that Vitamin C ...cured scurvy. 👍



Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by greggerypeccary on Jun 30th, 2020 at 10:22am

Sophia wrote on Jun 30th, 2020 at 10:17am:
I had a blood test from Doc, and found I was low in vitamin D which isn’t all surprising since I live in a state that’s cold for 9 months of the year, so vitamin D was recommended I take from the Doctor.


Everyone I know who has a had a blood test recently, were told they are low in vitamin D - me included.


Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Ye Grappler on Jun 30th, 2020 at 10:43am

Sophia wrote on Jun 30th, 2020 at 10:17am:

freediver wrote on Jun 29th, 2020 at 8:58pm:

Quote:
You're wasting you money on vitamins .... we lead lives of excess not lack.


Excess of calories. Not necessarily excess of vitamins.


Agree.
Excess of empty calories at that.
BTW, minerals are lacking/depleted in soil,  hence minerals are lacking in our diet.
I recall they used to do a vitamin count on a fruit basket periodically in the 90s, and comparing it with previous fruit and veges tested.
It showed how vitamin C , for instance, was becoming depleted in the fruit.

What’s our fruit and veges like with vitamin count of late?

I had a blood test from Doc, and found I was low in vitamin D which isn’t all surprising since I live in a state that’s cold for 9 months of the year, so vitamin D was recommended I take from the Doctor.

When I was pregnant, by 5 months I became pale looking, and very tired.
Obstetrician did blood test to find I was very low in iron and prescribed iron tablets, then did a further blood test and found the iron had risen, which meant I didn’t feel as tired.

There’s 2 of my own examples why vitamins are not a scam or nonsense.

And I find out, people with cancer, are severely lacking vitamin C.... either the lack of vitamin C is a contributing factor that could lead to cancer, or the cancer causes a depletion off vitamin C within the body.

Not forgetting how sailors in the olde days of tall sailing ships suffered and died from scurvy, only to find later that Vitamin C ...cured scurvy. 👍



I believe a part of the Captain Cook story was that he made a point of stopping at Tahiti to take on limes... (yum - limes!) .. I think the idea of the tale was that such things were not generally accepted in the Royal Nay-veh, but Captain Cook, being of peasant stock*, had better ideas.

* and like the Gineral Hisself, good ol' Robert E, he never owned a slave let alone a Niqqer...

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by UnSubRocky on Jun 30th, 2020 at 11:59am

Gnads wrote on Jun 30th, 2020 at 6:47am:
Get tested ;D

Mosquitoes this weather? None down here.


I donate blood every 3 months. They do a screening of my blood. I would not be surprised if they test for further diseases.

Mosquitos around here get desperate for any type of wet weather, during this time of year. Whenever the rain comes around during the dry season, the mosquitos make sure to go on a biting spree. I even have home-made bifenthrin candles burning under the house to make sure that mosquitos don't come around. I think it probably also kills off the hibernating larvae, too.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jun 30th, 2020 at 11:19pm

Gnads wrote on Jun 30th, 2020 at 7:49am:

freediver wrote on Jun 29th, 2020 at 8:58pm:

Quote:
You're wasting you money on vitamins .... we lead lives of excess not lack.


Excess of calories. Not necessarily excess of vitamins.


Unless you're on some weird diet you should get everything you need from what you eat ....

excesses of any one particular thing should be avoided.

Check the content labels & see what is in cereals - processed & unprocessed, vegetables the same, meats, cheeses, fruits, breads.....

it's all there.

Unless you are lacking because of a certain medical condition or disease...........

you are wasting your money.


Does big macs count as a wierd diet?

Seriously though, a lot of the engineering that has gone into modern crops has left them with fewer vitamins per calorie. On top of that we are less likely to eat the bitter herb type stuff that we used to scrape by on.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by The_Barnacle on Jul 1st, 2020 at 6:30pm

Sophia wrote on Jun 30th, 2020 at 10:17am:
There’s 2 of my own examples why vitamins are not a scam or nonsense.

And I find out, people with cancer, are severely lacking vitamin C.... either the lack of vitamin C is a contributing factor that could lead to cancer, or the cancer causes a depletion off vitamin C within the body.

Not forgetting how sailors in the olde days of tall sailing ships suffered and died from scurvy, only to find later that Vitamin C ...cured scurvy. 👍


But they are 2 very extreme examples
The average person doesn't need vitamin supliments
They are a scam

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Baronvonrort on Jul 1st, 2020 at 6:34pm
Of course the BLM protestors spread this Kung Flu.

WTF does the government mean by under investigation or a result of routine testing?

There were 4 confirmed cases from BLM idiots this virus has a R Nought of 5-6 so those 4 infected 20-24 people then those 24 each went on to infect another 5-6 people which puts numbers over 100.

Only a leftist idiot would deny these BLM idiots didn't spread this virus.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Lols on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 12:27am

The_Barnacle wrote on Jul 1st, 2020 at 6:30pm:

Sophia wrote on Jun 30th, 2020 at 10:17am:
There’s 2 of my own examples why vitamins are not a scam or nonsense.

And I find out, people with cancer, are severely lacking vitamin C.... either the lack of vitamin C is a contributing factor that could lead to cancer, or the cancer causes a depletion off vitamin C within the body.

Not forgetting how sailors in the olde days of tall sailing ships suffered and died from scurvy, only to find later that Vitamin C ...cured scurvy. 👍


But they are 2 very extreme examples
The average person doesn't need vitamin supliments
They are a scam


You kind of chopped up my post in half to quote.
I’m an average person, I put up an example about being low in iron etc. in the first part.

Okay, let’s look at magnesium, helps with reducing muscle cramps for starters.

We just need to look at what symptoms one experiences due to certain vitamin/mineral deficiency.
And deficiency can happen depending on food we usually eat, maybe much the same of some types food, and not enough variety of most foods across the board or pyramid food chart.

Too many burgers and fries and coke or sugary foods isn’t doing any favours for ones body.
High blood sugar for instance could well be the onset to diabetes type 2.
Why is it on the rise?

What causes that? A lot of wrong foods,l?  Too much sugar is in everything now.

Key facts. The number of people with diabetes has risen from 108 million in 1980 to 422 million in 2014. The global prevalence of diabetes* among adults over 18 years of age has risen from 4.7% in 1980 to 8.5% in 2014 (1). Diabetes prevalence has been rising more rapidly in middle- and low-income countries.Oct 30, 2018

Do we drink enough plain water throughout the day? Exercise much?

It’s just too easy to have an unbalanced diet, and what lacks are certain vitamins that can be supplemented. Some women need more calcium, hence taking supplements to slow osteoporosis may help.

My daughter did some work at Ian Gawler foundation where cancer patients went and were educated about foods.
She worked in the kitchen,  fresh fruits and vegetables, fruit smoothies, all to nourish/detox the body. Boosting the immune.
Meditation was part of it too.
It’s hoped many make those dietary changes for good after they leave.
Yes food is supposed to have it all but many of us do have a bit of imbalance and supplementation can help.

Without googling, how many know what foods have mid to high range of vitamin b17?       ii




Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gnads on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 7:06am

Sophia wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 12:27am:

The_Barnacle wrote on Jul 1st, 2020 at 6:30pm:

Sophia wrote on Jun 30th, 2020 at 10:17am:
There’s 2 of my own examples why vitamins are not a scam or nonsense.

And I find out, people with cancer, are severely lacking vitamin C.... either the lack of vitamin C is a contributing factor that could lead to cancer, or the cancer causes a depletion off vitamin C within the body.

Not forgetting how sailors in the olde days of tall sailing ships suffered and died from scurvy, only to find later that Vitamin C ...cured scurvy. 👍


But they are 2 very extreme examples
The average person doesn't need vitamin supliments
They are a scam


You kind of chopped up my post in half to quote.
I’m an average person, I put up an example about being low in iron etc. in the first part.

Okay, let’s look at magnesium, helps with reducing muscle cramps for starters.

We just need to look at what symptoms one experiences due to certain vitamin/mineral deficiency.
And deficiency can happen depending on food we usually eat, maybe much the same of some types food, and not enough variety of most foods across the board or pyramid food chart.

Too many burgers and fries and coke or sugary foods isn’t doing any favours for ones body.
High blood sugar for instance could well be the onset to diabetes type 2.
Why is it on the rise?

What causes that? A lot of wrong foods,l?  Too much sugar is in everything now.

Key facts. The number of people with diabetes has risen from 108 million in 1980 to 422 million in 2014. The global prevalence of diabetes* among adults over 18 years of age has risen from 4.7% in 1980 to 8.5% in 2014 (1). Diabetes prevalence has been rising more rapidly in middle- and low-income countries.Oct 30, 2018

Do we drink enough plain water throughout the day? Exercise much?

It’s just too easy to have an unbalanced diet, and what lacks are certain vitamins that can be supplemented. Some women need more calcium, hence taking supplements to slow osteoporosis may help.

My daughter did some work at Ian Gawler foundation where cancer patients went and were educated about foods.
She worked in the kitchen,  fresh fruits and vegetables, fruit smoothies, all to nourish/detox the body. Boosting the immune.
Meditation was part of it too.
It’s hoped many make those dietary changes for good after they leave.
Yes food is supposed to have it all but many of us do have a bit of imbalance and supplementation can help.

Without googling, how many know what foods have mid to high range of vitamin b17?      


Lols you're quoting examples of medical conditions either caused by disease or adverse conditions or both.

Normal well people do not require vitamin supplements.

I won't be believing some vitamin entrepreneur/snake oil salesman/corporation over the medical profession.

It's all about private equity companies cashing in on our gullibility & making mega dollars.

Unless recommended by a doctor after blood test results & examination I won't buy them.   
Vitamin_Companies.jpg (65 KB | 13 )

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Lols on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:02am
If it’s a vitamin company making money that bothers you, then what the pharmaceutical company make should really bother you eh?

Making money from over prescriptions and let’s face it, doctors are not allowed to recommend vitamins, because it’s not linked to the big pharma. And the fact a 4-6 year medical course only covers vitamins in a paltry 45 mins during that whole course is definitely not studying it properly.

Prevention is better than cure.
In this case, I will stay on my course of vitamins AND minerals, and I have avoided prescriptions.

No answer to my question about vitamin B17?
And it’s benefits?
Ask your medical doctor, he won’t know either.


Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by greggerypeccary on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:08am

Sophia wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:02am:
If it’s a vitamin company making money that bothers you, then what the pharmaceutical company make should really bother you eh?

Making money from over prescriptions and let’s face it, doctors are not allowed to recommend vitamins, because it’s not linked to the big pharma.


Not sure about the rest of the country, but here in Perth GPs are prescribing Vitamin D everyday.

Everyone I know who has had a blood test done recently has been told by their doctor to start taking Vitamin D.

Vitamin B is widely prescribed by doctors too.


Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by cods on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:08am

Sophia wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:02am:
If it’s a vitamin company making money that bothers you, then what the pharmaceutical company make should really bother you eh?

Making money from over prescriptions and let’s face it, doctors are not allowed to recommend vitamins, because it’s not linked to the big pharma. And the fact a 4-6 year medical course only covers vitamins in a paltry 45 mins during that whole course is definitely not studying it properly.

Prevention is better than cure.
In this case, I will stay on my course of vitamins AND minerals, and I have avoided prescriptions.

No answer to my question about vitamin B17?
And it’s benefits?
Ask your medical doctor, he won’t know either.


hi lols... my doctor never recommends vitamins either when ever I have suggested them    but then she discovered my Vit D levels were low... a fact as you get older...so she immediately put me on Vit D tablets  which apparently work when the rest dont... ::) ::)


Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by cods on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:10am

greggerypeccary wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:08am:

Sophia wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:02am:
If it’s a vitamin company making money that bothers you, then what the pharmaceutical company make should really bother you eh?

Making money from over prescriptions and let’s face it, doctors are not allowed to recommend vitamins, because it’s not linked to the big pharma.


Not sure about the rest of the country, but here in Perth GPs are prescribing Vitamin D everyday.

Everyone I know who has had a blood test done recently has been told by their doctor to start taking Vitamin D.

Vitamin B is widely prescribed by doctors too.



r u taking them greg??

I asked my doctor what good do they do  and she said its for the brain....lololol...so one of us must be doing it right..

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by greggerypeccary on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:15am

cods wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:10am:

greggerypeccary wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:08am:

Sophia wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:02am:
If it’s a vitamin company making money that bothers you, then what the pharmaceutical company make should really bother you eh?

Making money from over prescriptions and let’s face it, doctors are not allowed to recommend vitamins, because it’s not linked to the big pharma.


Not sure about the rest of the country, but here in Perth GPs are prescribing Vitamin D everyday.

Everyone I know who has had a blood test done recently has been told by their doctor to start taking Vitamin D.

Vitamin B is widely prescribed by doctors too.



r u taking them greg??

I asked my doctor what good do they do  and she said its for the brain....lololol...so one of us must be doing it right..


I'm told I have low Vitamin D levels, but I don't experience any of the symptoms associated with that.

My doctor wants me to take Vitamin D, and I'm considering it.

She also wants me to take a statin, but I've told her that will never happen (again).



Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Lols on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:15am

greggerypeccary wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:08am:

Sophia wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:02am:
If it’s a vitamin company making money that bothers you, then what the pharmaceutical company make should really bother you eh?

Making money from over prescriptions and let’s face it, doctors are not allowed to recommend vitamins, because it’s not linked to the big pharma.


Not sure about the rest of the country, but here in Perth GPs are prescribing Vitamin D everyday.

Everyone I know who has had a blood test done recently has been told by their doctor to start taking Vitamin D.

Vitamin B is widely prescribed by doctors too.

Yes I know, I mentioned earlier as my own case about being prescribed vitamin D by doctor, and it is very surprising because to me it’s an admission on the journey to getting a medical foot in the door to the world of vitamins and our humanly ways of lacking due to our faulty diet/living.
I was incredibly surprised when this new thing with doctors cane about in recent times. Never did it before, except for Iron supplements.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by cods on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:35am

greggerypeccary wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:15am:

cods wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:10am:

greggerypeccary wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:08am:

Sophia wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:02am:
If it’s a vitamin company making money that bothers you, then what the pharmaceutical company make should really bother you eh?

Making money from over prescriptions and let’s face it, doctors are not allowed to recommend vitamins, because it’s not linked to the big pharma.


Not sure about the rest of the country, but here in Perth GPs are prescribing Vitamin D everyday.

Everyone I know who has had a blood test done recently has been told by their doctor to start taking Vitamin D.

Vitamin B is widely prescribed by doctors too.



r u taking them greg??

I asked my doctor what good do they do  and she said its for the brain....lololol...so one of us must be doing it right..


I'm told I have low Vitamin D levels, but I don't experience any of the symptoms associated with that.

My doctor wants me to take Vitamin D, and I'm considering it.

She also wants me to take a statin, but I've told her that will never happen (again).


I dont recall having any  symptoms   I have blood tests all the time for EVERYTHING>...lol...they wont have to preserve me when I fall of the branch..

if they are recommended I suggest you take them...buy them in the chemist..although I believe the generic are just the same....I cant be bothered shopping for them..statin is that for cholesterol ..

again it depends on your age and fitness...if you are doing other things to help your body   well I guess its ok...

my grandsons boss 47 had a massive stroke whilst driving his car  as luck would have it he had arrived home and was coming to a stop in his driveway...otherwise he would be dead...he has been in hospital ever since...ina coma for a few weeks..now out of coma but half his memory had gone  he cannot remember his family of today....only his previous family first wife and kids...how awful is that? he also has to learn to walk again  not sure about speech but guess thats the same... grandson is still not allowed to go in and see him yet...   I dont think anyone expects him to return to work......his new family I think two kids also live in a house provided by the company he works for......soooooo.....they are facing an ordeal...

men really need to take a good look at themselves when it comes to health...if something doesnt agree with you there is always an alternative  but you have to talk about it.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Lols on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:42am

cods wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:10am:

greggerypeccary wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:08am:

Sophia wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:02am:
If it’s a vitamin company making money that bothers you, then what the pharmaceutical company make should really bother you eh?

Making money from over prescriptions and let’s face it, doctors are not allowed to recommend vitamins, because it’s not linked to the big pharma.


Not sure about the rest of the country, but here in Perth GPs are prescribing Vitamin D everyday.

Everyone I know who has had a blood test done recently has been told by their doctor to start taking Vitamin D.

Vitamin B is widely prescribed by doctors too.



r u taking them greg??

I asked my doctor what good do they do  and she said its for the brain....lololol...so one of us must be doing it right..


Hi Cods, I watched an interview with Margaret Fulton (some may know she has an empire of cook books published in parallel with Women’s weekly cook books) she only passed last year, age 95.

She showed the 2-3 vitamins she took daily, and being a food/nutritionist cook expert, she would know something about what our foods may lack.
She being a cook and taking supplements, had said she never had prescriptions.
And the proof she lived to 95 yrs is good enough for me to follow a good example.
I have a friend, my age, who had always ran to the white coats, so much prescription she is on. I recall a stretch of anti biotics for 9 months!
Her teeth looked bad, and....she could hardly walk, years of prescription and said her knees are bone on bone now.
I know, some people are hypochondriacs 🤨
It pains me to see her my age and hobbling like a 100 year old.

Now another friend much younger than me, with painful joints, hobbling also, had now gone on a recommended diet to eliminate sugar, carbs etc.
Very strict and.... she is able to walk with less pain now.

Point is, will she go back to her old ways or make this permanent change for the better for life?

Habits are hard broken aren’t they?
Unhealthy foods, smoking, alcoholic drinkers, cannabis users, etc
Humans are creatures of habits.




Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by greggerypeccary on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:56am

cods wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:35am:

greggerypeccary wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:15am:

cods wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:10am:

greggerypeccary wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:08am:

Sophia wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:02am:
If it’s a vitamin company making money that bothers you, then what the pharmaceutical company make should really bother you eh?

Making money from over prescriptions and let’s face it, doctors are not allowed to recommend vitamins, because it’s not linked to the big pharma.


Not sure about the rest of the country, but here in Perth GPs are prescribing Vitamin D everyday.

Everyone I know who has had a blood test done recently has been told by their doctor to start taking Vitamin D.

Vitamin B is widely prescribed by doctors too.



r u taking them greg??

I asked my doctor what good do they do  and she said its for the brain....lololol...so one of us must be doing it right..


I'm told I have low Vitamin D levels, but I don't experience any of the symptoms associated with that.

My doctor wants me to take Vitamin D, and I'm considering it.

She also wants me to take a statin, but I've told her that will never happen (again).


I dont recall having any  symptoms   I have blood tests all the time for EVERYTHING>...lol...they wont have to preserve me when I fall of the branch..

if they are recommended I suggest you take them...buy them in the chemist..although I believe the generic are just the same....I cant be bothered shopping for them..statin is that for cholesterol ..

again it depends on your age and fitness...if you are doing other things to help your body   well I guess its ok...

my grandsons boss 47 had a massive stroke whilst driving his car  as luck would have it he had arrived home and was coming to a stop in his driveway...otherwise he would be dead...he has been in hospital ever since...ina coma for a few weeks..now out of coma but half his memory had gone  he cannot remember his family of today....only his previous family first wife and kids...how awful is that? he also has to learn to walk again  not sure about speech but guess thats the same... grandson is still not allowed to go in and see him yet...   I dont think anyone expects him to return to work......his new family I think two kids also live in a house provided by the company he works for......soooooo.....they are facing an ordeal...

men really need to take a good look at themselves when it comes to health...if something doesnt agree with you there is always an alternative  but you have to talk about it.


Yes, statins are for cholesterol.

The most (over)prescribed drugs in the world.


Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Lols on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 12:02pm
Meant to say, if doctors prescribe vitamin B, which one as there are various vitamin B and for different symptoms.

There are numbers after the letter B.

As for statins you mentioned, Greg, I would love to know what your experience or knowledge is about it. I’ve heard much of it, and read that if one had a stroke in life, should never take statins. I challenged doctors on this, and they say it’s supposed to avoid strokes, yet my mum who was doing so well had her prescription changed from 3 medications to 6 medications, with a different cholesterol statin medicine, ended up with a huge stroke, half paralysed, unable to talk drink or eat, 8 days later r.i.p. mum 😢

Another time they changed her medication, it gave her pains in the chest, headaches and dizziness.
I can’t remember the name of it now, but I checked it out online, and was banned in the USA, with class action law suites. This cholesterol medication caused premature death. Big issue about statins here.
So I told her to stop taking it and go back to old medication.
She said it cost her $120 and was a new one from the USA.
I was stunned at the campaign for it.
She did stop taking it and her pain and dizziness stopped.

We must have an approach to look into everything we are going to put into our humanly bodies and it’s probable effects.
Your body tells you, we need to listen to it more.



Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Lols on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 12:07pm

greggerypeccary wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:56am:

cods wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:35am:

greggerypeccary wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:15am:

cods wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:10am:

greggerypeccary wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:08am:

Sophia wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:02am:
If it’s a vitamin company making money that bothers you, then what the pharmaceutical company make should really bother you eh?

Making money from over prescriptions and let’s face it, doctors are not allowed to recommend vitamins, because it’s not linked to the big pharma.


Not sure about the rest of the country, but here in Perth GPs are prescribing Vitamin D everyday.

Everyone I know who has had a blood test done recently has been told by their doctor to start taking Vitamin D.

Vitamin B is widely prescribed by doctors too.



r u taking them greg??

I asked my doctor what good do they do  and she said its for the brain....lololol...so one of us must be doing it right..


I'm told I have low Vitamin D levels, but I don't experience any of the symptoms associated with that.

My doctor wants me to take Vitamin D, and I'm considering it.

She also wants me to take a statin, but I've told her that will never happen (again).


I dont recall having any  symptoms   I have blood tests all the time for EVERYTHING>...lol...they wont have to preserve me when I fall of the branch..

if they are recommended I suggest you take them...buy them in the chemist..although I believe the generic are just the same....I cant be bothered shopping for them..statin is that for cholesterol ..

again it depends on your age and fitness...if you are doing other things to help your body   well I guess its ok...

my grandsons boss 47 had a massive stroke whilst driving his car  as luck would have it he had arrived home and was coming to a stop in his driveway...otherwise he would be dead...he has been in hospital ever since...ina coma for a few weeks..now out of coma but half his memory had gone  he cannot remember his family of today....only his previous family first wife and kids...how awful is that? he also has to learn to walk again  not sure about speech but guess thats the same... grandson is still not allowed to go in and see him yet...   I dont think anyone expects him to return to work......his new family I think two kids also live in a house provided by the company he works for......soooooo.....they are facing an ordeal...

men really need to take a good look at themselves when it comes to health...if something doesnt agree with you there is always an alternative  but you have to talk about it.


Yes, statins are for cholesterol.

The most (over)prescribed drugs in the world.


And hence, going back to what I wrote to Gnads to help him see how the big pharmaceutical company makes huge money out of that over prescribing.



Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gnads on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 12:09pm

Sophia wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:02am:
If it’s a vitamin company making money that bothers you, then what the pharmaceutical company make should really bother you eh?

Making money from over prescriptions and let’s face it, doctors are not allowed to recommend vitamins, because it’s not linked to the big pharma. And the fact a 4-6 year medical course only covers vitamins in a paltry 45 mins during that whole course is definitely not studying it properly.

Prevention is better than cure.
In this case, I will stay on my course of vitamins AND minerals, and I have avoided prescriptions.

No answer to my question about vitamin B17?
And it’s benefits?
Ask your medical doctor, he won’t know either.


Have a look at the pie chart

Pharmaceutical companies own the vitamin companies

so it is linked to big Pharma.... i.e. Bayer, Pfizer

Even Amway is still in there ... & we know they are crooks.

you didn't dig deep enough. :P

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by greggerypeccary on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 12:15pm

Sophia wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 12:02pm:
Meant to say, if doctors prescribe vitamin B, which one as there are various vitamin B and for different symptoms.

There are numbers after the letter B.

As for statins you mentioned, Greg, I would love to know what your experience or knowledge is about it. I’ve heard much of it, and read that if one had a stroke in life, should never take statins. I challenged doctors on this, and they say it’s supposed to avoid strokes, yet my mum who was doing so well had her prescription changed from 3 medications to 6 medications, with a different cholesterol statin medicine, ended up with a huge stroke, half paralysed, unable to talk drink or eat, 8 days later r.i.p.

Another time they changed her medication, it gave her pains in the chest, headaches and dizziness.
I can’t remember the name of it now, but I checked it out online, and was banned in the USA, with class action law suites. This cholesterol medication caused premature death. Big issue about statins here.
So I told her to stop taking it and go back to old medication.
She said it cost her $120 and was a new one from the USA.
I was stunned at the campaign for it.
She did stop taking it and her pain and dizziness stopped.

We must have an approach to look into everything we are going to put into our humanly bodies and it’s probable effects.
Your body tells you, we need to listen to it more.


I have no medical training whatsoever, and this is only my personal opinion, but I would never take a statin again.

The side effects were horrible - aches and pains, tiredness, cramps, diarrhea, blurred vision, etc.

And, they did very little in the way of lowering my cholesterol.

I ended up getting a coronary calcium score done, which turned out to be zero (the best score you can get).

When I went for a second opinion I was told that it's madness for someone with such a low coronary calcium score to be taking statins.

Doctors love to push them though, as they get kickbacks from the drug companies.

HOWEVER, for some people they can be beneficial, so don't do anything based on my opinion.

Seek professional advice, and then get a 2nd and 3rd opinion.


Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Lols on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 12:20pm

Gnads wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 12:09pm:

Sophia wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:02am:
If it’s a vitamin company making money that bothers you, then what the pharmaceutical company make should really bother you eh?

Making money from over prescriptions and let’s face it, doctors are not allowed to recommend vitamins, because it’s not linked to the big pharma. And the fact a 4-6 year medical course only covers vitamins in a paltry 45 mins during that whole course is definitely not studying it properly.

Prevention is better than cure.
In this case, I will stay on my course of vitamins AND minerals, and I have avoided prescriptions.

No answer to my question about vitamin B17?
And it’s benefits?
Ask your medical doctor, he won’t know either.


Have a look at the pie chart

Pharmaceutical companies own the vitamin companies

so it is linked to big Pharma.... i.e. Bayer, Pfizer

Even Amway is still in there ... & we know they are crooks.

you didn't dig deep enough. :P


Yet never allow doctors to prescribe that range? Except for vitamin D and holding onto those companies for further allowable proscriptions, or to hold a monopoly on people for money again.
It’s a case of big fish eat little fish, and buying out those particular vitamin companies. For what reason you think?
I never buy any vitamins from those companies, thank goodness.
What I purchase is something a big pharmaceutical company in the USA went to buy out for $1billion to shelve this product.
But these scientists didn’t accept it.
So that’s how the pharmaceutical companies do their dirty work behind the scenes. Did you know that? Monopolising control, who knows what they will do once they have holdings on all the vitamin companies? Start to disappear off shelves?
Bet they would do that with garlic too!





Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Lols on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 12:23pm

greggerypeccary wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 12:15pm:

Sophia wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 12:02pm:
Meant to say, if doctors prescribe vitamin B, which one as there are various vitamin B and for different symptoms.

There are numbers after the letter B.

As for statins you mentioned, Greg, I would love to know what your experience or knowledge is about it. I’ve heard much of it, and read that if one had a stroke in life, should never take statins. I challenged doctors on this, and they say it’s supposed to avoid strokes, yet my mum who was doing so well had her prescription changed from 3 medications to 6 medications, with a different cholesterol statin medicine, ended up with a huge stroke, half paralysed, unable to talk drink or eat, 8 days later r.i.p.

Another time they changed her medication, it gave her pains in the chest, headaches and dizziness.
I can’t remember the name of it now, but I checked it out online, and was banned in the USA, with class action law suites. This cholesterol medication caused premature death. Big issue about statins here.
So I told her to stop taking it and go back to old medication.
She said it cost her $120 and was a new one from the USA.
I was stunned at the campaign for it.
She did stop taking it and her pain and dizziness stopped.

We must have an approach to look into everything we are going to put into our humanly bodies and it’s probable effects.
Your body tells you, we need to listen to it more.


I have no medical training whatsoever, and this is only my personal opinion, but I would never take a statin again.

The side effects were horrible - aches and pains, tiredness, cramps, diarrhea, blurred vision, etc.

And, they did very little in the way of lowering my cholesterol.

I ended up getting a coronary calcium score done, which turned out to be zero (the best score you can get).

When I went for a second opinion I was told that it's madness for someone with such a low coronary calcium score to be taking statins.

Doctors love to push them though, as they get kickbacks from the drug companies.

HOWEVER, for some people they can be beneficial, so don't do anything based on my opinion.

Seek professional advice, and then get a 2nd and 3rd opinion.


Thank you and well said.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gnads on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 2:31pm

Sophia wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 12:20pm:

Gnads wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 12:09pm:

Sophia wrote on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:02am:
If it’s a vitamin company making money that bothers you, then what the pharmaceutical company make should really bother you eh?

Making money from over prescriptions and let’s face it, doctors are not allowed to recommend vitamins, because it’s not linked to the big pharma. And the fact a 4-6 year medical course only covers vitamins in a paltry 45 mins during that whole course is definitely not studying it properly.

Prevention is better than cure.
In this case, I will stay on my course of vitamins AND minerals, and I have avoided prescriptions.

No answer to my question about vitamin B17?
And it’s benefits?
Ask your medical doctor, he won’t know either.


Have a look at the pie chart

Pharmaceutical companies own the vitamin companies

so it is linked to big Pharma.... i.e. Bayer, Pfizer

Even Amway is still in there ... & we know they are crooks.

you didn't dig deep enough. :P


Yet never allow doctors to prescribe that range? Except for vitamin D and holding onto those companies for further allowable proscriptions, or to hold a monopoly on people for money again.
It’s a case of big fish eat little fish, and buying out those particular vitamin companies. For what reason you think?
I never buy any vitamins from those companies, thank goodness.
What I purchase is something a big pharmaceutical company in the USA went to buy out for $1billion to shelve this product.
But these scientists didn’t accept it.
So that’s how the pharmaceutical companies do their dirty work behind the scenes. Did you know that? Monopolising control, who knows what they will do once they have holdings on all the vitamin companies? Start to disappear off shelves?
Bet they would do that with garlic too!


Yes I know..... that's what Newscorp have done with all the regional papers.

They can't touch garlic it's a bulb vegetable food.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by JaSin. on Jul 2nd, 2020 at 11:48pm
Farmers in Europe have to keep buying bags of seed from big Companies which genetically modify the seed not to 'reproduce' for a next crop. Each harvest, the Farmers have to buy new bags of Seed at high cost.
Trade Wars? It's businesses ripping off businesses out there. Nations ripping off Nations.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jul 12th, 2020 at 7:46am
300 new cases on Friday. I see a lot of people denying that the protestors spread the virus. They are the same people denying that Victoria is in a second wave, which forced them to come up with a new term - surge. And they are also saying they are having trouble keeping track of all the contact tracing. I have not seen anything to suggest they would even know if the protest was the source. All the new cases must have come from somewhere. It doesn't just spontaneously appear at a family gathering.


Quote:
Farmers in Europe have to keep buying bags of seed from big Companies which genetically modify the seed not to 'reproduce' for a next crop. Each harvest, the Farmers have to buy new bags of Seed at high cost.


They don't have to. They choose to.


Quote:
So that’s how the pharmaceutical companies do their dirty work behind the scenes. Did you know that? Monopolising control, who knows what they will do once they have holdings on all the vitamin companies? Start to disappear off shelves?


It's generally the make-up companies, not the pharmaceuticals companies. They tend to lean in one direction or the other.


Quote:
Doctors love to push them though, as they get kickbacks from the drug companies.


I don't think they are allowed to. The best they can get is free drug samples and a junket.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by The_Barnacle on Jul 12th, 2020 at 12:24pm

freediver wrote on Jul 12th, 2020 at 7:46am:
300 new cases on Friday. I see a lot of people denying that the protestors spread the virus. They are the same people denying that Victoria is in a second wave, which forced them to come up with a new term - surge. And they are also saying they are having trouble keeping track of all the contact tracing. I have not seen anything to suggest they would even know if the protest was the source. All the new cases must have come from somewhere. It doesn't just spontaneously appear at a family gathering.


The onus of proof is on you
Do you have any evidence that the virus was spread at the rally?
Your hypocrisy is also noted that you defended beach goers but you blame protesters, you can't have it both ways
We already know that the source of the Melbourne outbreak was the security guards



Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jul 12th, 2020 at 12:32pm

Quote:
The onus of proof is on you


Why?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by The_Barnacle on Jul 12th, 2020 at 12:48pm

freediver wrote on Jul 12th, 2020 at 12:32pm:

Quote:
The onus of proof is on you


Why?


Because you are the one making the claim that the protesters spread the virus.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jul 12th, 2020 at 1:22pm
Can you quote me?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Baronvonrort on Jul 12th, 2020 at 1:59pm
Yes they spread it only an idiot would deny it.


blm.jpg (75 KB | 12 )

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Sprintcyclist on Jul 12th, 2020 at 4:46pm
yes.

It has been admitted 3 of the selfloathers illegally gathering in melbourne had it.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Setanta on Jul 12th, 2020 at 7:49pm
3 months wasted because the SJWs just had to think what happened on the other side of the world was more important than keeping fellow Australians safe.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by John Smith on Jul 12th, 2020 at 8:18pm

Setanta wrote on Jul 12th, 2020 at 7:49pm:
3 months wasted because the SJWs just had to think what happened on the other side of the world was more important than keeping fellow Australians safe.


From what I've seen it's got more to do with security guards dining and screwing people they're supposed to be guarding than BLM protestors

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jul 12th, 2020 at 9:42pm
You mean from what you have been told, right? By the politicians who allowed the protest and then told us Victoria was not in a second wave?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Baronvonrort on Jul 14th, 2020 at 6:14pm

John Smith wrote on Jul 12th, 2020 at 8:18pm:

Setanta wrote on Jul 12th, 2020 at 7:49pm:
3 months wasted because the SJWs just had to think what happened on the other side of the world was more important than keeping fellow Australians safe.


From what I've seen it's got more to do with security guards dining and screwing people they're supposed to be guarding than BLM protestors


I doubt the guards screwed as many as the BLM protestors did.

Quarantine started 28th march in Vic the numbers dropped for 10 weeks which includes the more than 100 cases from Cedar Meats before an explosion of numbers 2 weeks after BLM protests.

Since the BLM idiots include people who weren't killed by police we can say this is what they're protesting about.


blmp.jpg (42 KB | 10 )

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Sprintcyclist on Jul 14th, 2020 at 10:20pm
This outbreak happened 14 days after muslims all got together to 'celebrate'  the end of ramadan

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Lols on Jul 15th, 2020 at 9:42am
There we have it.... hence the investigations in place. Just a matter of time to connect where, how and when.
Still more investigations underway.


Black Lives Matter rally linked to public housing towers outbreak

https://apple.news/AE1dmyzloESQL-xfsQp9wBqqA


Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Sir Spot of Borg on Jul 15th, 2020 at 9:44am

Baronvonrort wrote on Jul 14th, 2020 at 6:14pm:

John Smith wrote on Jul 12th, 2020 at 8:18pm:

Setanta wrote on Jul 12th, 2020 at 7:49pm:
3 months wasted because the SJWs just had to think what happened on the other side of the world was more important than keeping fellow Australians safe.


From what I've seen it's got more to do with security guards dining and screwing people they're supposed to be guarding than BLM protestors


I doubt the guards screwed as many as the BLM protestors did.

Quarantine started 28th march in Vic the numbers dropped for 10 weeks which includes the more than 100 cases from Cedar Meats before an explosion of numbers 2 weeks after BLM protests.

Since the BLM idiots include people who weren't killed by police we can say this is what they're protesting about.


No thats not what they are protesting about. What they are protesting is blacks killed by police

Spot

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by greggerypeccary on Jul 15th, 2020 at 9:54am

Sprintcyclist wrote on Jul 14th, 2020 at 10:20pm:
This outbreak happened 14 days after muslims all got together to 'celebrate'  the end of ramadan


What did you do to celebrate, Sprint?

I'm curious.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Frank on Jul 15th, 2020 at 11:56am
Victorian health authorities have confirmed a link between two COVID-19 cases in people who attended the Black Lives Matter protest in Melbourne’s CBD just over a month ago, and the cluster of at least 242 cases in public housing towers in the city’s inner northwest.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Baronvonrort on Jul 15th, 2020 at 8:05pm
More stupidity from the fake news in the US.


nbc.png (40 KB | 14 )

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Bojack Horseman on Jul 16th, 2020 at 9:43am

Baronvonrort wrote on Jul 15th, 2020 at 8:05pm:
More stupidity from the fake news in the US.



I guess you have the evidence to show this is fake? Or is it just the vibe

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by The_Barnacle on Jul 16th, 2020 at 10:22am

Quote:
Victorian health officials have refuted claims there is a link between the Black Lives Matter protest and a coronavirus outbreak in Melbourne’s public housing towers.

The Australian reported on Tuesday authorities that two people who attended the protests more than a month ago were part of the cluster.

However, in a statement to 7NEWS.com.au, the Department of Health and Human Services said there was no evidence linking the two.

“We are aware of six confirmed cases who attended the Black Lives Matter protest. Currently there is no evidence to suggest they acquired the virus from the protest,” a spokesperson said.

https://7news.com.au/lifestyle/health-wellbeing/melbourne-coronavirus-cluster-linked-to-black-lives-matter-protest-as-victoria-records-more-cases-c-1166823


So it's only the right wing media that is reporting a "link" and I suspect that "link" is just clickbait for their target demographic

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Jul 16th, 2020 at 10:25am

freediver wrote on Jun 15th, 2020 at 6:11pm:
The big BLM protests were on June 6. It typically takes about 5 days or more for an infected person to show symptoms. This is the daily number of new cases in Australia from June 6 to yesterday:

4
5
5
2
9
9
5
12
18


1. outdoor gatherings are generally accepted as being low-risk for spreading the virus (and besides the participants did make some attempt to adhere to social distancing)

2. its pretty much confirmed by now that the spread was caused by incompetent security guards breaking quarantine rules at quarantine centres.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Jul 16th, 2020 at 10:37am

Frank wrote on Jul 15th, 2020 at 11:56am:
Victorian health authorities have confirmed a link between two COVID-19 cases in people who attended the Black Lives Matter protest in Melbourne’s CBD just over a month ago, and the cluster of at least 242 cases in public housing towers in the city’s inner northwest.


The Smear-stralian is obviously pay-walled, but this from another Murdoch rag:


Quote:
Two protesters who attended the Black Lives Matter rally have had their COVID-19 cases linked to the outbreak in Melbourne's public housing towers.

Health authorities have confirmed the link without saying if the protesters lived, visited or were close contacts of those in the towers, The Australian reports.


So this is what they mean by "link" - which is clarified a few paragraphs below:


Quote:
The link does not necessarily mean the protesters were the original source of the public housing tower outbreak, which is the state's largest cluster to date.


https://www.dailymercury.com.au/news/black-lives-matter-rally-linked-to-towers-outbreak/4057225/

So by "link", all they mean is that at least 2 people (out of 10 thousand) who attended the protest were infected at the time - but with no evidence whatsoever that attending the protest caused more spreading of the infection.

This is the modus operandi of the Murdoch propaganda - to highlight something ambiguous that they know can and will be misconstrued in a particular way - and de-emphasise the actual truth as much as they can.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Valkie on Jul 16th, 2020 at 12:52pm
But it's very important for all the white sychophants to get together to protest about a fake issue.

Less blacks than whites die in custody.
More blacks die by their own hands or their own people and by whites.
The only persecution blacks have in Australia is when they are asked to actually ....WORK
Which is the same thing as asking a white person to murder their family.

After much research,
I find that the darker the skin, the more predisposed to Lazyness.
No matter what country you look in, the blacks generally represent, as a percentage of their population, abnormally high unemployment.
Additionally, this is usually coupled with a high propensity to crime, do say is violence,  violent behaviour and stupidity.

Pick any country and prove otherwise?

You can't.

Adversely, whites are more likely to be employed
Have a considerably lower, by percentage of population, Unemployment.

Whites also have more legally o trained money, homes and property.
All EARNED through hard work and sensible spending.

This is known as WHITE PREVILEDGE  .

Blacks have a lazy gene
Whites generally don't have that gene, unless mixed with black.

Simple.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Frank on Jul 16th, 2020 at 1:06pm

polite_gandalf wrote on Jul 16th, 2020 at 10:37am:

Frank wrote on Jul 15th, 2020 at 11:56am:
Victorian health authorities have confirmed a link between two COVID-19 cases in people who attended the Black Lives Matter protest in Melbourne’s CBD just over a month ago, and the cluster of at least 242 cases in public housing towers in the city’s inner northwest.


The Smear-stralian is obviously pay-walled, but this from another Murdoch rag:


Quote:
Two protesters who attended the Black Lives Matter rally have had their COVID-19 cases linked to the outbreak in Melbourne's public housing towers.

Health authorities have confirmed the link without saying if the protesters lived, visited or were close contacts of those in the towers, The Australian reports.


So this is what they mean by "link" - which is clarified a few paragraphs below:

[quote]The link does not necessarily mean the protesters were the original source of the public housing tower outbreak, which is the state's largest cluster to date.


https://www.dailymercury.com.au/news/black-lives-matter-rally-linked-to-towers-outbreak/4057225/

So by "link", all they mean is that at least 2 people (out of 10 thousand) who attended the protest were infected at the time - but with no evidence whatsoever that attending the protest caused more spreading of the infection.

This is the modus operandi of the Murdoch propaganda - to highlight something ambiguous that they know can and will be misconstrued in a particular way - and de-emphasise the actual truth as much as they can. [/quote]
Yeah, large gatherings during a pandemic have nuffin' to do wiv nuffin'.
BLM_links.jpg (202 KB | 9 )

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Bobby. on Jul 16th, 2020 at 1:08pm

Valkie wrote on Jul 16th, 2020 at 12:52pm:
But it's very important for all the white sychophants to get together to protest about a fake issue.

Less blacks than whites die in custody.
More blacks die by their own hands or their own people and by whites.
The only persecution blacks have in Australia is when they are asked to actually ....WORK
Which is the same thing as asking a white person to murder their family.

After much research,
I find that the darker the skin, the more predisposed to Lazyness.
No matter what country you look in, the blacks generally represent, as a percentage of their population, abnormally high unemployment.
Additionally, this is usually coupled with a high propensity to crime, do say is violence,  violent behaviour and stupidity.

Pick any country and prove otherwise?

You can't.

Adversely, whites are more likely to be employed
Have a considerably lower, by percentage of population, Unemployment.

Whites also have more legally o trained money, homes and property.
All EARNED through hard work and sensible spending.

This is known as WHITE PREVILEDGE  .

Blacks have a lazy gene
Whites generally don't have that gene, unless mixed with black.

Simple.



But what about Tiger Woods and Obama?

Mixing genes with black and white made stronger, smarter progeny.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Valkie on Jul 16th, 2020 at 1:27pm

Bobby. wrote on Jul 16th, 2020 at 1:08pm:

Valkie wrote on Jul 16th, 2020 at 12:52pm:
But it's very important for all the white sychophants to get together to protest about a fake issue.

Less blacks than whites die in custody.
More blacks die by their own hands or their own people and by whites.
The only persecution blacks have in Australia is when they are asked to actually ....WORK
Which is the same thing as asking a white person to murder their family.

After much research,
I find that the darker the skin, the more predisposed to Lazyness.
No matter what country you look in, the blacks generally represent, as a percentage of their population, abnormally high unemployment.
Additionally, this is usually coupled with a high propensity to crime, do say is violence,  violent behaviour and stupidity.

Pick any country and prove otherwise?

You can't.

Adversely, whites are more likely to be employed
Have a considerably lower, by percentage of population, Unemployment.

Whites also have more legally o trained money, homes and property.
All EARNED through hard work and sensible spending.

This is known as WHITE PREVILEDGE  .

Blacks have a lazy gene
Whites generally don't have that gene, unless mixed with black.

Simple.



But what about Tiger Woods and Obama?

Mixing genes with black and white made stronger, smarter progeny.


Yes, but there is still that lazy gene.

What politician ever did a hard day's WORK?

Tiger woods, playing golf, that's relaxation to a white.

Most American black rich are usually sports people, good at running, from running from crimes.

But again, very few had done any real work.

In the 47 years I have worked, I have seen perhaps a handful of black workers.
Of them a small percentage would actually last a few months or a year or two.

Yep black gene, lazy

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Jul 16th, 2020 at 1:29pm

Quote:
Yeah, large gatherings during a pandemic have nuffin' to do wiv nuffin'.


and no doubt security guards literally sleeping with infected patients and taking them out to restaurants has nuffin to do with nuffin right?

Don't worry frank, it may well emerge that the negligent security guards were black or muslim or BLM activists - then it will be safe for you to focus your rage on that.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by John Smith on Jul 16th, 2020 at 4:52pm

polite_gandalf wrote on Jul 16th, 2020 at 1:29pm:
Don't worry frank, it may well emerge that the negligent security guards were black or muslim or BLM activists - then it will be safe for you to focus your rage on that.



;D ;D ;D ;D


won't that make his day :D

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jul 16th, 2020 at 5:56pm

polite_gandalf wrote on Jul 16th, 2020 at 10:37am:

Frank wrote on Jul 15th, 2020 at 11:56am:
Victorian health authorities have confirmed a link between two COVID-19 cases in people who attended the Black Lives Matter protest in Melbourne’s CBD just over a month ago, and the cluster of at least 242 cases in public housing towers in the city’s inner northwest.


The Smear-stralian is obviously pay-walled, but this from another Murdoch rag:


Quote:
Two protesters who attended the Black Lives Matter rally have had their COVID-19 cases linked to the outbreak in Melbourne's public housing towers.

Health authorities have confirmed the link without saying if the protesters lived, visited or were close contacts of those in the towers, The Australian reports.


So this is what they mean by "link" - which is clarified a few paragraphs below:

[quote]The link does not necessarily mean the protesters were the original source of the public housing tower outbreak, which is the state's largest cluster to date.


https://www.dailymercury.com.au/news/black-lives-matter-rally-linked-to-towers-outbreak/4057225/

So by "link", all they mean is that at least 2 people (out of 10 thousand) who attended the protest were infected at the time - but with no evidence whatsoever that attending the protest caused more spreading of the infection.

This is the modus operandi of the Murdoch propaganda - to highlight something ambiguous that they know can and will be misconstrued in a particular way - and de-emphasise the actual truth as much as they can. [/quote]

They have been closing beaches for months, even when people stay well clear of each other. But now we suddenly need evidence that outdoor gatherings can spread the virus?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Frank on Jul 16th, 2020 at 7:37pm

polite_gandalf wrote on Jul 16th, 2020 at 1:29pm:

Quote:
Yeah, large gatherings during a pandemic have nuffin' to do wiv nuffin'.


and no doubt security guards literally sleeping with infected patients and taking them out to restaurants has nuffin to do with nuffin right?

Don't worry frank, it may well emerge that the negligent security guards were black or muslim or BLM activists - then it will be safe for you to focus your rage on that.



None of those cut price 'security guards' were white Europeans - no Danes, English, Americans, Canadians, Swedes, Germans.

Thirdy worldy Arabs, Islanders, Pakis - people who could not get anything better because they have no language and no skills.  Make a mental note as you walk around shopping centres, banks, etc where security guards are employed. No whites. Anywhere.  Same with the airport security screeners - since 9/11 they have become ALL Arabs or other NESB tinted. you NEVER see a dinky-di Australian at security except in regional airports. In Melbourne, Sydney, Brisbane etc - all bearded Arabs and other foreigners.


Come on, do your victim impersonation, as you always do.  Australia took Muslims in just to make them victims. And Muslims keep wanting to come because they don;t know nuffin'.  Go on, that's your schtik.


You are as incoherent as Paki, Bwian and all the other 'professors of diversity'.







Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Jul 17th, 2020 at 9:38am

freediver wrote on Jul 16th, 2020 at 5:56pm:

polite_gandalf wrote on Jul 16th, 2020 at 10:37am:

Frank wrote on Jul 15th, 2020 at 11:56am:
Victorian health authorities have confirmed a link between two COVID-19 cases in people who attended the Black Lives Matter protest in Melbourne’s CBD just over a month ago, and the cluster of at least 242 cases in public housing towers in the city’s inner northwest.


The Smear-stralian is obviously pay-walled, but this from another Murdoch rag:


Quote:
Two protesters who attended the Black Lives Matter rally have had their COVID-19 cases linked to the outbreak in Melbourne's public housing towers.

Health authorities have confirmed the link without saying if the protesters lived, visited or were close contacts of those in the towers, The Australian reports.


So this is what they mean by "link" - which is clarified a few paragraphs below:

[quote]The link does not necessarily mean the protesters were the original source of the public housing tower outbreak, which is the state's largest cluster to date.


https://www.dailymercury.com.au/news/black-lives-matter-rally-linked-to-towers-outbreak/4057225/

So by "link", all they mean is that at least 2 people (out of 10 thousand) who attended the protest were infected at the time - but with no evidence whatsoever that attending the protest caused more spreading of the infection.

This is the modus operandi of the Murdoch propaganda - to highlight something ambiguous that they know can and will be misconstrued in a particular way - and de-emphasise the actual truth as much as they can.


They have been closing beaches for months, even when people stay well clear of each other. But now we suddenly need evidence that outdoor gatherings can spread the virus?[/quote]

Your logic does not follow FD.

Keeping in mind we are not arguing whether or not the protest (or going to the beach) was a good idea.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jul 17th, 2020 at 7:17pm
What logic is that Gandalf? What is the issue with me pointing out this hypocrisy? They actually closed a pier to fishing in Victoria a few days after the protest, citing failure to follow social distancing guidelines as justification. As with all the beach closures, the articles about it included photos of people clearly maintaining their distance from each other, pretty much the opposite of the protestors. This was followed shortly after by reassurances that the protestors did not spread the virus, without any explanation of how they came to that conclusion, followed shortly after by reassurances that Victoria was not having a second wave.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Lols on Jul 17th, 2020 at 7:42pm
We are not having a second wave, it’s a frigging tsunami!

If after this weekend the daily figures and deaths don’t improve, say hello to stage four and goodbye to what little freedom we had with stage three!!



Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Frank on Jul 18th, 2020 at 7:36pm

polite_gandalf wrote on Jul 16th, 2020 at 1:29pm:

Quote:
Yeah, large gatherings during a pandemic have nuffin' to do wiv nuffin'.


and no doubt security guards literally sleeping with infected patients and taking them out to restaurants has nuffin to do with nuffin right?

Don't worry frank, it may well emerge that the negligent security guards were black or muslim or BLM activists - then it will be safe for you to focus your rage on that.


Emerge??

It's evident.  Since airport checks have been introduced because of Muslim terrorism, almost all the people checking you at airports are... er... bearded and hijabi Muslims.

it's ludicrous.


The sons of Mohammed have been saying that COVID affects only the infidels because they don't pee like Mohammed said. So they have been ignoring all that 'inglis'  colonial guff about social distancing and have gathered, instead, for large Eid celebrations.

NESBy efnic ijits with extra religious chip/stupidity = 'Muslim communities'.  Even Dr Rifi is despairing. (Largely because he does speak English and when you do, the stupidity of the 'efnic community' is startling.)


"Dr Rifi believes some linguistically diverse communities in Sydney are missing out on crucial health messaging, ­social-distancing instructions and updates on the COVID-19 health guidelines."

And of course it's the governments' responsibility to get through to the thick, NESBy numbskulls. THEY have zero responsibility to actually learn the language and to fit in. No - it's the wacist, Islamophobic Australian society's responsibility to hold down the Musselmans, open their thick skulls and pour reason into them.

There is simply NUFFIN' you can expect from Muslims who came here. Assimilate? Integrate? Nooooo!!!!!  It's everyone else's responsibility to get you fvkers see reason (something you have resisted for 1400 years and will certainly not start now). i

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by John Smith on Jul 18th, 2020 at 9:23pm

Frank wrote on Jul 18th, 2020 at 7:36pm:
Since airport checks have been introduced because of Muslim terrorism, almost all the people checking you at airports are... er... bearded and hijabi Muslims.

it's ludicrous.



more bullsh1t.  Do you see muslims in your sleep to?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by UnSubRocky on Jul 19th, 2020 at 8:57am
I have not heard of any sources stating that the current virus spread was sourced from the protesters in BLM. I have heard that 2 or 3 protesters had the virus. But nothing about them spreading it among 40,000. How many protesters had the virus 2 weeks later from the protests?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by The_Barnacle on Jul 19th, 2020 at 10:46am

UnSubRocky wrote on Jul 19th, 2020 at 8:57am:
I have not heard of any sources stating that the current virus spread was sourced from the protesters in BLM. I have heard that 2 or 3 protesters had the virus. But nothing about them spreading it among 40,000. How many protesters had the virus 2 weeks later from the protests?


Thats because groups of people moving around in the outdoors don't spread viruses
freediver accepted this when he argued passionately that beach goers aren't spreading the virus. For some reason he has completely changed his position when it comes to the BLM protests.

For the record, I supported freediver in his argument that beach goers weren't spreading the virus

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jul 19th, 2020 at 1:42pm

Quote:
For some reason he has completely changed his position


No I haven't. You are just telling different lies about what I said.


Quote:
I have not heard of any sources stating that the current virus spread was sourced from the protesters in BLM. I have heard that 2 or 3 protesters had the virus.


The Victorian government is trying to keep people in the dark on this, because they did nothing to stop the protest, instead focusing on preventing people going fishing and reassuring everyone there is no second wave.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8525221/Health-officials-confirm-six-Black-Lives-Matter-protesters-Melbourne-tested-positive-COVID-19.html

At least six protesters who attended a recent Black Lives Matter rally in Melbourne have since tested positive to coronavirus, health officials have confirmed. 

But the department has refuted claims the June 6 protest is linked to an outbreak cluster in Melbourne's public housing towers, which has contributed to a second wave of new infections.

The Department of Health and Human Services previously said four people who attended the 10,000-strong rally last month had tested positive. 

The department has since clarified the figure after it was revealed two protesters were part of the public housing tower cluster where at least 242 cases have been recorded.

And that is just the ones they are aware of. There is a very long list of 'unknown' sources, and I think even the BLM protestors are smart enough to figure out it is a bad look for the movement if they admit to going after testing positive.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Jul 21st, 2020 at 11:07am

freediver wrote on Jul 17th, 2020 at 7:17pm:
What is the issue with me pointing out this hypocrisy?


Nothing. Its just not what this thread started out as. You orginally seemed to want to somehow prove that the protests spread the virus, not point out any hypocricy. The problem of course is that there is no actual evidence that the protests spread the virus. Not even the best efforts of Murdoch propaganda could find any, and no, finding two infected people who attended the protest and dishonestly trumpeting this as a "link" to the spread, is not evidence.

So by all means, point out the hypocricy and the stupidity of having outdoor gatherings - I'll be there cheering you on. But I was responding specifically to the clear insinuation in the OP plus the blatant dishonesty of News Ltd which someone brought up to try and "prove" that the protest spread the virus.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Frank on Jul 21st, 2020 at 5:03pm

polite_gandalf wrote on Jul 21st, 2020 at 11:07am:

freediver wrote on Jul 17th, 2020 at 7:17pm:
What is the issue with me pointing out this hypocrisy?


Nothing. Its just not what this thread started out as. You orginally seemed to want to somehow prove that the protests spread the virus, not point out any hypocricy. The problem of course is that there is no actual evidence that the protests spread the virus. Not even the best efforts of Murdoch propaganda could find any, and no, finding two infected people who attended the protest and dishonestly trumpeting this as a "link" to the spread, is not evidence.

So by all means, point out the hypocricy and the stupidity of having outdoor gatherings - I'll be there cheering you on. But I was responding specifically to the clear insinuation in the OP plus the blatant dishonesty of News Ltd which someone brought up to try and "prove" that the protest spread the virus.

These marches were the BIGGEST outdoor gatherings in recent months.

All other gatherings of much smaller numbers are attracting fines and a stern talking-to. People are told to keep at least 1.5 away from each other, etc. What IS the point of these restrictions if ten thousand people on the street for BLM has nuffin' to do wiv' nuffin'. Coz the woke media said so and the Murdoch Press didn't go along wiv that - that's seems a really strong point in your mind. Coz being a BLM protester is a magic vaccine. Just like you can't get infected if you are a Muslim at a massive Eid celebration.



Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by John Smith on Jul 21st, 2020 at 5:06pm

freediver wrote on Jul 19th, 2020 at 1:42pm:
The Victorian government is trying to keep people in the dark on this, because they did nothing to stop the protest, instead focusing on preventing people going fishing and reassuring everyone there is no second wave.



;D ;D ;D ;D

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jul 21st, 2020 at 6:08pm

polite_gandalf wrote on Jul 21st, 2020 at 11:07am:

freediver wrote on Jul 17th, 2020 at 7:17pm:
What is the issue with me pointing out this hypocrisy?


Nothing. Its just not what this thread started out as. You orginally seemed to want to somehow prove that the protests spread the virus, not point out any hypocricy.


I believe it started out as a question.


Quote:
The problem of course is that there is no actual evidence that the protests spread the virus.


The government controls the evidence. There is no transparency in what they do with it. The government has a clear vested interest in misrepresenting it - for example in claiming that there is no second wave, when there clearly is, and also they do not want to blame the second wave on an event they condoned, against all common sense.


Quote:
Not even the best efforts of Murdoch propaganda could find any


I posted some here. Not sure if it made it into the murdock press, but I expect they all reported the same thing.


Quote:
finding two infected people who attended the protest and dishonestly trumpeting this as a "link" to the spread, is not evidence.


Only two eh?


Quote:
But I was responding specifically to the clear insinuation in the OP plus the blatant dishonesty of News Ltd which someone brought up to try and "prove" that the protest spread the virus.


What blatant dishonesty?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Frank on Jul 21st, 2020 at 6:50pm
Victoria Police’s decision not to issue fines to 10,000 people who attended the June 6 Black Lives Matter protest in Melbourne’s CBD may have been unlawful, according to legal advice prepared by leading workplace relations QC Stuart Wood.
...
“For Victoria Police to … make a general policy decision not to enforce the directions against a certain group of people at a certain time is to effectively refuse to give the assistance requested (to enforce public health directions under the act),” Mr Wood found.

“To simply decide not to enforce the directions against any protester had the practical consequence that (unlike every other Victorian everywhere else in the state), the directions did not apply to those people.”

IPA research fellow Morgan Begg called for the terms of reference of Victoria‘s judicial inquiry into the bungling of its hotel quarantine system to be broadened to include the police and Andrews government’s handling of the protest.
“The legal advice notes the potentially unlawful decision may even expose Victoria Police — and therefore the state’s taxpayers — to civil claims that will add to the enormous cost of the government’s inept pandemic response,” Mr Begg said.
“Thousands of protesters were allowed to take to the streets in an environment in which all other Victorians lived under the strict rules against public gatherings of more than 20 people.
“The state government’s response to the protest highlighted the mismanagement and arbitrary decision-making that has characterised the entire pandemic response.”

On the day of the protest there were 71 known active cases of coronavirus in Victoria, 14 of which had at that stage been linked to breaches in hotel quarantine, and the majority of which were in quarantined overseas travellers.

On Tuesday, Victoria‘s tally of known active cases reached 3147.




Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Frank on Jul 21st, 2020 at 6:52pm

John Smith wrote on Jul 21st, 2020 at 5:06pm:

freediver wrote on Jul 19th, 2020 at 1:42pm:
The Victorian government is trying to keep people in the dark on this, because they did nothing to stop the protest, instead focusing on preventing people going fishing and reassuring everyone there is no second wave.



;D ;D ;D ;D



While the department says only one of the six was likely to have been infectious at the protest and there is “no evidence to suggest” any of them acquired the virus there, it has also refused to say whether a source of acquisition has been identified for the cases or explain why the possibility they caught it at the protest has been ruled out.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by UnSubRocky on Jul 21st, 2020 at 8:32pm

The_Barnacle wrote on Jul 19th, 2020 at 10:46am:

UnSubRocky wrote on Jul 19th, 2020 at 8:57am:
I have not heard of any sources stating that the current virus spread was sourced from the protesters in BLM. I have heard that 2 or 3 protesters had the virus. But nothing about them spreading it among 40,000. How many protesters had the virus 2 weeks later from the protests?


Thats because groups of people moving around in the outdoors don't spread viruses
freediver accepted this when he argued passionately that beach goers aren't spreading the virus. For some reason he has completely changed his position when it comes to the BLM protests.

For the record, I supported freediver in his argument that beach goers weren't spreading the virus


You seem to be missing freediver's point of view about the differences between going to the beach and walking among other protesters. Perhaps it is because I only see beaches of Yeppoon and Emu Park that I don't consider beaches to be overcrowded. But you are in closer contact with people who are protesting the same thing you are doing, that becomes the problem. Protesters are usually in close contact because it gives the idea of "strength in numbers" to improve their message's impact. That is why protests during a pandemic is considered a bad idea.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Baronvonrort on Jul 21st, 2020 at 8:53pm
Of course the BLM idiots spread the Kung Flu only idiots would deny it.


blm_idiots.jpg (75 KB | 17 )

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by John Smith on Jul 21st, 2020 at 9:57pm

Frank wrote on Jul 21st, 2020 at 6:52pm:

John Smith wrote on Jul 21st, 2020 at 5:06pm:

freediver wrote on Jul 19th, 2020 at 1:42pm:
The Victorian government is trying to keep people in the dark on this, because they did nothing to stop the protest, instead focusing on preventing people going fishing and reassuring everyone there is no second wave.



;D ;D ;D ;D



While the department says only one of the six was likely to have been infectious at the protest and there is “no evidence to suggest” any of them acquired the virus there, it has also refused to say whether a source of acquisition has been identified for the cases or explain why the possibility they caught it at the protest has been ruled out.



;D ;D ;D ;D

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Frank on Jul 21st, 2020 at 10:20pm
https://images.app.goo.gl/JJ2dmNfgQUvQpEJX9

Thank you Gino, we see you.


Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Valkie on Jul 22nd, 2020 at 5:57am
It's pretty damn obvious that the Black Lies Morons rally was an incubator for CV.

But the grubberment and their lapdog, the media will never admit it.

Mass protests by "always" ever vocal and worthless groups are an ideal way to spread disease.

Disease of the mind as well as the body.

A logarithmic decline in IQ is noted at these rally.

The higher the number, the lower the collective IQ.

I believe that any attending the Black Lies Morons rally

Should be immediately incarcerated in secure facility, fed their staple diet of KFC and Pizza.

And left for 4 weeks to ensure the virus is dead.
This is started again every time a new case is found, so it could be a very long incarceration indeed.

There will be little or no impact on industry (except the abbo industry of course)

And the crime rate will drop drastically.

Oh, and as it's self inflicted, no treatment for any who get the virus.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jul 23rd, 2020 at 7:00am
Gandalf, did the security guards at the quarantine hotels synchronise their sex with the prisoners to make it look like the BLM protests spread the virus?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Bobby. on Jul 23rd, 2020 at 7:10am

freediver wrote on Jul 23rd, 2020 at 7:00am:
Gandalf, did the security guards at the quarantine hotels synchronise their sex with the prisoners to make it look like the BLM protests spread the virus?



No - it just shows that a standing prick has no conscience.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by UnSubRocky on Jul 23rd, 2020 at 10:43pm
Baron, the virus should not take a month for a massive outbreak of coronavirus after a protest. People would have got it and then spread it near immediately among their crew. I doubt many protesters got the coronavirus in the protests. Most of the virus spread has come from returning 'Australians' from overseas.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jul 24th, 2020 at 8:13pm

UnSubRocky wrote on Jul 23rd, 2020 at 10:43pm:
Baron, the virus should not take a month for a massive outbreak of coronavirus after a protest. People would have got it and then spread it near immediately among their crew. I doubt many protesters got the coronavirus in the protests. Most of the virus spread has come from returning 'Australians' from overseas.


You are confused.

It takes a week or two for symptoms to first appear. People who caught the virus at the protest would have been spreading it around that whole time, until they got symptoms and eventually got tested. And that's assuming they got tested.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Bobby. on Jul 24th, 2020 at 8:28pm



Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by UnSubRocky on Jul 24th, 2020 at 9:19pm

freediver wrote on Jul 24th, 2020 at 8:13pm:

UnSubRocky wrote on Jul 23rd, 2020 at 10:43pm:
Baron, the virus should not take a month for a massive outbreak of coronavirus after a protest. People would have got it and then spread it near immediately among their crew. I doubt many protesters got the coronavirus in the protests. Most of the virus spread has come from returning 'Australians' from overseas.


You are confused.

It takes a week or two for symptoms to first appear. People who caught the virus at the protest would have been spreading it around that whole time, until they got symptoms and eventually got tested. And that's assuming they got tested.


I think I basically said what you said in your second paragraph. The graph shown had a big spike in the month after the protests. I would bet that most protesters just went on with their self-important lives and just spread the disease among their crew. Then their friends and family would have spread it to their friends, family and co-workers. That could account for a spike upward in covid19 cases inside 2 weeks. Not a month.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gnads on Jul 25th, 2020 at 9:11am

UnSubRocky wrote on Jul 23rd, 2020 at 10:43pm:
Baron, the virus should not take a month for a massive outbreak of coronavirus after a protest. People would have got it and then spread it near immediately among their crew. I doubt many protesters got the coronavirus in the protests. Most of the virus spread has come from returning 'Australians' from overseas.


Incorrect.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jul 25th, 2020 at 9:13am
Ultimately the virus came from overseas. But that does not mean the protesters didn't spread it. Even the Victorian government was honest enough to admit that most of the recent cases are local transmission.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by UnSubRocky on Jul 25th, 2020 at 4:31pm
I would be sure that most transmissions are among the locals of recent. But most of the recent arrivals were the reason for the recent local transmissions. Easily 95% of the transmissions, I surmise, would be local. But it was provoked by recent arrivals from overseas.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jul 25th, 2020 at 5:26pm
Did they antagonise the virus?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Jul 30th, 2020 at 1:55pm

freediver wrote on Jul 21st, 2020 at 6:08pm:
The government controls the evidence. There is no transparency in what they do with it. The government has a clear vested interest in misrepresenting it - for example in claiming that there is no second wave, when there clearly is, and also they do not want to blame the second wave on an event they condoned, against all common sense.


Tin foil hat conspiracy nonsense. To demonstrate how little sense this makes, the government, according to you, are too terrified to blame stupid people for participating in a completely unnecessary mass demonstration - but they are evidently not too terrified to blame their own actual direct bungling of the quarantine process. Since you do realise Andrews is now openly admitting this wave was caused by his own incompetence with quarantine right??

Also, the government did not "condone" the BLM event, they were literally begging people not to go. Both federal and state. Nothing would please them more to be able to say "I told you so!" - especially if it could deflect from their onw very direct bungling of the quarantine process. Unfortunately though there's this pesky little thing called evidence. Something which you apparently have no conception of.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by greggerypeccary on Jul 30th, 2020 at 1:58pm

freediver wrote on Jul 21st, 2020 at 6:08pm:
The government has a clear vested interest in misrepresenting it - for example in claiming that there is no second wave, when there clearly is, and also they do not want to blame the second wave on an event they condoned, against all common sense.


The government didn't condone the protests.


Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Frank on Jul 30th, 2020 at 7:05pm

greggerypeccary wrote on Jul 30th, 2020 at 1:58pm:

freediver wrote on Jul 21st, 2020 at 6:08pm:
The government has a clear vested interest in misrepresenting it - for example in claiming that there is no second wave, when there clearly is, and also they do not want to blame the second wave on an event they condoned, against all common sense.


The government didn't condone the protests.


Allowed, condoned - you explain the difference. turd.



Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jul 30th, 2020 at 8:25pm

polite_gandalf wrote on Jul 30th, 2020 at 1:55pm:

freediver wrote on Jul 21st, 2020 at 6:08pm:
The government controls the evidence. There is no transparency in what they do with it. The government has a clear vested interest in misrepresenting it - for example in claiming that there is no second wave, when there clearly is, and also they do not want to blame the second wave on an event they condoned, against all common sense.


Tin foil hat conspiracy nonsense. To demonstrate how little sense this makes, the government, according to you, are too terrified to blame stupid people for participating in a completely unnecessary mass demonstration - but they are evidently not too terrified to blame their own actual direct bungling of the quarantine process. Since you do realise Andrews is now openly admitting this wave was caused by his own incompetence with quarantine right??

Also, the government did not "condone" the BLM event, they were literally begging people not to go. Both federal and state. Nothing would please them more to be able to say "I told you so!" - especially if it could deflect from their onw very direct bungling of the quarantine process. Unfortunately though there's this pesky little thing called evidence. Something which you apparently have no conception of.


It is not a conspiracy Gandalf. The Victorian government actually said we are not in a second wave. They lied when it suited them. It was also within the Victorian government's power to prevent the protest from happening. The whole "begging them not to" bit was their way of signalling that they did not intend to exercise that authority.

Why do you think that judge in Sydney upheld the ban on the more recent protest if the Victorian government was being honest in it's claim that the previous protest did not spread the virus? If the Victorian government was not lying through it's teeth, it would be proof that the protests are not an unreasonable risk to take.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Bam on Jul 31st, 2020 at 10:28am
There's no real evidence about protesters spreading the virus, but we can say for sure that it was spread into the country by wealthy people who are rich enough to afford to go overseas by plane or sail on cruise ships. This is a virus spread into Australia by wealthy people. Once it gets into the country it spreads far and wide, but it wasn't the poor who brought it into the country.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Jul 31st, 2020 at 12:18pm

freediver wrote on Jul 30th, 2020 at 8:25pm:
It was also within the Victorian government's power to prevent the protest from happening. The whole "begging them not to" bit was their way of signalling that they did not intend to exercise that authority.


The whole "begging them not to" bit is first and foremost an emphatic demonstration of them not condoning the protest. But do continue shifting the goalposts.


freediver wrote on Jul 30th, 2020 at 8:25pm:
Why do you think that judge in Sydney upheld the ban on the more recent protest if the Victorian government was being honest in it's claim that the previous protest did not spread the virus?


Logical fallacy. Public gatherings at this time of any sort are a bad idea full stop - regardless of whether or not a previous gathering did in fact cause a fresh outbreak. This is a no-brainer for the Sydney judge - irrespective of what the Melbourne protest did or didn't cause.


freediver wrote on Jul 30th, 2020 at 8:25pm:
If the Victorian government was not lying through it's teeth, it would be proof that the protests are not an unreasonable risk to take.


Rubbish. Any public gatherings are an unreasonable risk to take - and citing just one particular gathering that seems to have fluked it and dodged a bullet, does not magically make them not unreasonable. You may as well say not wearing seatbelts in a reasonable risk to take - because I can show you one example where someone drove without one, and no one got hurt. Actually I could show you a thousand.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Jul 31st, 2020 at 12:21pm

Bam wrote on Jul 31st, 2020 at 10:28am:
There's no real evidence about protesters spreading the virus, but we can say for sure that it was spread into the country by wealthy people who are rich enough to afford to go overseas by plane or sail on cruise ships. This is a virus spread into Australia by wealthy people. Once it gets into the country it spreads far and wide, but it wasn't the poor who brought it into the country.


Wealthy people who test positive, told to quarantine, and then get taken out to restaurants by the people supposed to be keeping them in quarantine.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by greggerypeccary on Jul 31st, 2020 at 12:24pm

Bam wrote on Jul 31st, 2020 at 10:28am:
There's no real evidence about protesters spreading the virus, but we can say for sure that it was spread into the country by wealthy people who are rich enough to afford to go overseas by plane or sail on cruise ships. This is a virus spread into Australia by wealthy people. Once it gets into the country it spreads far and wide, but it wasn't the poor who brought it into the country.


This wealthy prick is trying to spread it further:

If Clive Palmer wins in the High Court, is that the end of WA's pandemic defence?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Jul 31st, 2020 at 4:55pm

Quote:
The whole "begging them not to" bit is first and foremost an emphatic demonstration of them not condoning the protest. But do continue shifting the goalposts.


It was already illegal. Yet somehow it went ahead with the Victorian government asking them nicely nice to go.


Quote:
Logical fallacy. Public gatherings at this time of any sort are a bad idea full stop


They were a bad idea a month ago as well.


Quote:
Rubbish. Any public gatherings are an unreasonable risk to take


Including the earlier BLM protests?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Aug 4th, 2020 at 2:00pm

freediver wrote on Jul 31st, 2020 at 4:55pm:
It was already illegal. Yet somehow it went ahead with the Victorian government asking them nicely nice to go.


I don't know if they were technically illegal or not. What I do know is that you originally said the government "condoned" the protests, and are now trying to shift the goalposts after being proven wrong.


freediver wrote on Jul 31st, 2020 at 4:55pm:
Including the earlier BLM protests?


Of course. But being a bad idea in terms of risking the spread of infection doesn't mean it actually did spread the infection.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Aug 4th, 2020 at 6:13pm

Quote:
Of course. But being a bad idea in terms of risking the spread of infection doesn't mean it actually did spread the infection.


And what does?


Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Aug 4th, 2020 at 6:44pm
correlation is not causation FD.

Why don't I just show you the exact same graph with a pointer showing when the security guards started taking out infected people to restaurants?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Aug 4th, 2020 at 6:47pm
Yes please. I have already asked you about this alleged synchronised inmate rooting. But you ran away.

What percentage of the 2nd wave infections can be traced back to this rooting?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Aug 4th, 2020 at 6:48pm
Also, weren't there BLM protests all around the country?

Why did it only cause a second wave in Victoria hmmm?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by JaSin. on Aug 4th, 2020 at 6:51pm

polite_gandalf wrote on Aug 4th, 2020 at 6:48pm:
Also, weren't there BLM protests all around the country?

Why did it only cause a second wave in Victoria hmmm?

:-/

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Aug 4th, 2020 at 7:11pm

freediver wrote on Aug 4th, 2020 at 6:47pm:
Yes please. I have already asked you about this alleged synchronised inmate rooting. But you ran away.

What percentage of the 2nd wave infections can be traced back to this rooting?


The synchronised rooting was your invention, so I'll leave that for you to explain.

That the quarantine bungle was the spark that lit the blaze is not seriously in dispute:

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-07-11/fuel-spark-victoria-response-virus-public-health-bushfire/12443982

But you tell me FD, applying some actual common sense here - which I know is usually a challenge for you - what is more likely? An outbreak caused by known infected people supposed to be in quarantine who we know infected their security guards, who were all at the time breaking quarantine protocol, visiting prime incubating areas like restaurants and gyms, or people attending an outdoor rally, not a high-chance infection event - and besides which the attendees were known to be practicing social distancing and hand sanitizing - only two of which are known to be infected at the time?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Aug 4th, 2020 at 7:13pm

Quote:
That the quarantine bungle was the spark that lit the blaze is not seriously in dispute:


That's just what I'd expect from a politician trying to blame the second wave on anything other than the protests, without actually providing any facts.

Where is that graph you offered?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Frank on Aug 4th, 2020 at 7:15pm

polite_gandalf wrote on Aug 4th, 2020 at 2:00pm:

freediver wrote on Jul 31st, 2020 at 4:55pm:
It was already illegal. Yet somehow it went ahead with the Victorian government asking them nicely nice to go.


I don't know if they were technically illegal or not. What I do know is that you originally said the government "condoned" the protests, and are now trying to shift the goalposts after being proven wrong.


freediver wrote on Jul 31st, 2020 at 4:55pm:
Including the earlier BLM protests?


Of course. But being a bad idea in terms of risking the spread of infection doesn't mean it actually did spread the infection.



It was contrary to the rules in place, rules brought in legislatively. You know, lawfully.
But woke bedwetting-yet-jihadi ijits like you and this woman and hundreds of others shouted about 'wacism' is a gweater thweat than Covid-19" and Victoria, being run by a woke fapper, bent its OWN rules to not enforce them if you broke them for BLM idiocy reasons. PC kills. We see it now every day.

https://theconversation.com/profiles/lakshmi-manoharan-1014558
https://theconversation.com/why-protesting-racism-during-a-pandemic-is-important-an-epidemiologist-explains-140824
https://theintercept.com/2020/06/11/systemic-racism-protests-coronavirus-health-risk/

Either we are all equal under the law or we are not (your jihadi angle). If the law is an ass and the rules are arbitrary, you change them first. You don't disobey them because of your woke/jihadi/wace-baiting moral preening - and then insist that everyone ELSE obey them.

You are not a libertarian advocating that all rule be ignored. You are opportunistic jihadi advocating the destruction of the equality of all before the law because it is an idea completely non-compliant with your plan to have Islamic rule across the face of the earth.

You cannot be, and so you are not, a liberal Muslim who want a democratic, open, enlightened-yet-Muslim society. You are not stupid enough to spend your life on a contradiction and impossibility.


Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Aug 4th, 2020 at 7:44pm

freediver wrote on Aug 4th, 2020 at 7:13pm:

Quote:
That the quarantine bungle was the spark that lit the blaze is not seriously in dispute:


That's just what I'd expect from a politician trying to blame the second wave on anything other than the protests, without actually providing any facts.




Except its not from politicians in this case.

Blaming the second wave on something without actually providing any facts? Stop it FD, you're killing me. I'll bet you don't even see the irony in such a statement.


Quote:
Where is that graph you offered?


Just imagine the same graph except with a marker showing when the quarantine protocol breaches happened - which coincidentally were just before the second wave.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Aug 4th, 2020 at 7:45pm

Frank wrote on Aug 4th, 2020 at 7:15pm:
It was contrary to the rules in place, rules brought in legislatively. You know, lawfully.


So were the quarantine protocol breaches. What exactly is your point Frank?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Aug 4th, 2020 at 8:13pm

Quote:
Blaming the second wave on something without actually providing any facts? Stop it FD, you're killing me. I'll bet you don't even see the irony in such a statement.


You haven't provided any facts Gandalf. You have offered to provide them, but then you ran away.


Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Aug 4th, 2020 at 8:43pm

freediver wrote on Aug 4th, 2020 at 8:13pm:
You haven't provided any facts Gandalf. You have offered to provide them, but then you ran away.


And then I linked an ABC article with a whole bunch of facts.

Did you bother reading it?


Quote:
The first case of a security guard working in a quarantine hotel being infected was reported on May 27, at a similar time to the first family outbreaks being identified.

From there, infections spiralled to the point where at least 60 cases have now been linked to clusters at two hotels in Melbourne.

The hotel infections have been linked to spread in the community, including a family outbreak in south-eastern Melbourne.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Aug 4th, 2020 at 9:35pm
Wow, at least 60 cases.

How does this demonstrate that the protestors did not spread the virus?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Aug 5th, 2020 at 10:09am

freediver wrote on Aug 4th, 2020 at 9:35pm:
How does this demonstrate that the protestors did not spread the virus?


It doesn't. It just demonstrates that the quarantine bungle theory has legs, whereas the protest theory has no legs whatsoever. Since I just gave you clear evidence that the quarantine bungle caused *AN* outbreak at a critical point in time - whereas you have provided precisely zero evidence that the protests caused any outbreak whatsoever. Like I said, correlation is not causation. And yes, 60 cases certainly is a "wow" in the context of a so-called "second wave" that is still only causing daily infections in the hundreds.

And here's some more of those pesky "facts" for you:


Quote:
The state's Chief Health Officer Brett Sutton confirmed all of the strains were different from those found in the first wave: "There is no evidence of any original virus from February, March around currently," Professor Sutton said last Tuesday.

Which means it most likely came from overseas.

Mandatory hotel quarantine is widely accepted to be one of the biggest factors that helped Australia flatten the curve the first time, but now it seems likely that a single failure in that program sparked a wave of cases far bigger than the first.


If this wave originated from infected people arriving from overseas (as the state's chief medical officer suggests), then it means its a failure of quarantine that caused the outbreak. Since all overseas arrivals automatically go into mandatory quarantine.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Jest on Aug 5th, 2020 at 11:39am

polite_gandalf wrote on Aug 5th, 2020 at 10:09am:

freediver wrote on Aug 4th, 2020 at 9:35pm:
How does this demonstrate that the protestors did not spread the virus?


It doesn't. It just demonstrates that the quarantine bungle theory has legs, whereas the protest theory has no legs whatsoever. Since I just gave you clear evidence that the quarantine bungle caused *AN* outbreak at a critical point in time - whereas you have provided precisely zero evidence that the protests caused any outbreak whatsoever. Like I said, correlation is not causation. And yes, 60 cases certainly is a "wow" in the context of a so-called "second wave" that is still only causing daily infections in the hundreds.


So do you think god threw his magic cloak around the protesters and stopped them spreading the virus because he/she is a BLM supporter from way way back 

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gnads on Aug 5th, 2020 at 11:39am

polite_gandalf wrote on Aug 4th, 2020 at 8:43pm:

freediver wrote on Aug 4th, 2020 at 8:13pm:
You haven't provided any facts Gandalf. You have offered to provide them, but then you ran away.


And then I linked an ABC article with a whole bunch of facts.

Did you bother reading it?


Quote:
The first case of a security guard working in a quarantine hotel being infected was reported on May 27, at a similar time to the first family outbreaks being identified.

From there, infections spiralled to the point where at least 60 cases have now been linked to clusters at two hotels in Melbourne.

The hotel infections have been linked to spread in the community, including a family outbreak in south-eastern Melbourne.


Tell me why... as cases ramp up around Sydney is this being allowed?  ::) ::)


Quote:
Auburn Gallipoli Mosque granted coronavirus exemption for 400 people to celebrate Eid-al-Adha


https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-07-31/auburn-mosque-granted-coronavirus-exemption-for-eid-al-adha/12508358

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by greggerypeccary on Aug 5th, 2020 at 11:45am

Gnads wrote on Aug 5th, 2020 at 11:39am:

polite_gandalf wrote on Aug 4th, 2020 at 8:43pm:

freediver wrote on Aug 4th, 2020 at 8:13pm:
You haven't provided any facts Gandalf. You have offered to provide them, but then you ran away.


And then I linked an ABC article with a whole bunch of facts.

Did you bother reading it?


Quote:
The first case of a security guard working in a quarantine hotel being infected was reported on May 27, at a similar time to the first family outbreaks being identified.

From there, infections spiralled to the point where at least 60 cases have now been linked to clusters at two hotels in Melbourne.

The hotel infections have been linked to spread in the community, including a family outbreak in south-eastern Melbourne.


Tell me why... as cases ramp up around Sydney is this being allowed?  ::) ::)

[quote]Auburn Gallipoli Mosque granted coronavirus exemption for 400 people to celebrate Eid-al-Adha


https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-07-31/auburn-mosque-granted-coronavirus-exemption-for-eid-al-adha/12508358[/quote]

That doesn't seem to be as bad as I first thought.

"Under NSW coronavirus restrictions, places of worship are limited to 100 people, or one visitor per four square metres."

"The mosque's president Abdurrahman Asaroglu said those attending the annual festival of Eid al-Adha, also known as the festival of sacrifice, would be subject to temperature checks, sign-in sheets, and it would be mandatory to wear a mask.

"Worshippers at the mosque will be expected to bring their own prayer mats and abide by social distancing rules while praying.

"Dr Asaroglu said attendees would be spread out across "four zones" including the two levels of the mosque, an adjoining function hall and carpark.

"In a statement, NSW Health said exemptions were only considered under "exceptional circumstances" and the mosque had developed a comprehensive COVID-19 Safety Plan.

"It said none of the separate zones would exceed 100 worshippers and would not be allowed to mix between areas."




Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Aug 5th, 2020 at 12:12pm

Jest wrote on Aug 5th, 2020 at 11:39am:

polite_gandalf wrote on Aug 5th, 2020 at 10:09am:

freediver wrote on Aug 4th, 2020 at 9:35pm:
How does this demonstrate that the protestors did not spread the virus?


It doesn't. It just demonstrates that the quarantine bungle theory has legs, whereas the protest theory has no legs whatsoever. Since I just gave you clear evidence that the quarantine bungle caused *AN* outbreak at a critical point in time - whereas you have provided precisely zero evidence that the protests caused any outbreak whatsoever. Like I said, correlation is not causation. And yes, 60 cases certainly is a "wow" in the context of a so-called "second wave" that is still only causing daily infections in the hundreds.


So do you think god threw his magic cloak around the protesters and stopped them spreading the virus because he/she is a BLM supporter from way way back 


Its not too much to ask - just some shred of evidence that the protest caused the second wave. FD throws us a graph that shows the protest happening just before the second wave, and says "voila - correlation = causation!" - which we all know is one of the most well known of all logical fallacies. And its entirely plausible that the protest did not cause the outbreak - given what we know about the relative low risk of outdoor events and the social distancing and hand sanitising measures the protestors took. Not for a minute saying it was a good idea though.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by JaSin. on Aug 5th, 2020 at 12:22pm
How about both BLM Protesters & people coming in from Overseas - to blame for the 2nd Wave. Along with a lack lustre priority of Governments?
Send in the Military, that'll cure the Viral spreads - for lack of a adequate Medical system.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Aug 5th, 2020 at 6:23pm

polite_gandalf wrote on Aug 5th, 2020 at 10:09am:

freediver wrote on Aug 4th, 2020 at 9:35pm:
How does this demonstrate that the protestors did not spread the virus?


It doesn't. It just demonstrates that the quarantine bungle theory has legs, whereas the protest theory has no legs whatsoever.


You just admitted it was a risk of spreading the virus. Have you changed your mind?


Quote:
FD throws us a graph that shows the protest happening just before the second wave, and says "voila - correlation = causation!"


You are lying Gandalf. Again.


Quote:
Not for a minute saying it was a good idea though.


Why was it not a good idea, given that the theory of the virus spreading at the protest "has no legs?


Quote:
Mandatory hotel quarantine is widely accepted to be one of the biggest factors that helped Australia flatten the curve the first time, but now it seems likely that a single failure in that program sparked a wave of cases far bigger than the first.


Thanks Gandalf. Are you saying that the Victorian government, which has long denied a link between the protest and the outbreak the came right after it, does not actually know what is to blame?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Aug 5th, 2020 at 6:31pm

polite_gandalf wrote on Aug 5th, 2020 at 10:09am:

freediver wrote on Aug 4th, 2020 at 9:35pm:
How does this demonstrate that the protestors did not spread the virus?


It doesn't. It just demonstrates that the quarantine bungle theory has legs, whereas the protest theory has no legs whatsoever. Since I just gave you clear evidence that the quarantine bungle caused *AN* outbreak at a critical point in time - whereas you have provided precisely zero evidence that the protests caused any outbreak whatsoever.


Do you think we should track down all the evidence that the government either didn't find or won't share?

Have you seen any government official give a straight answer on how many cases can be traced to the BLM protest?


Quote:
And yes, 60 cases certainly is a "wow" in the context of a so-called "second wave" that is still only causing daily infections in the hundreds.


But it is still a long way from even being evidence that the BLM protestors didn't spread the virus, right?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Aug 5th, 2020 at 6:34pm

polite_gandalf wrote on Jul 30th, 2020 at 1:55pm:
Since you do realise Andrews is now openly admitting this wave was caused by his own incompetence with quarantine right??


What did Andrews actually say Gandalf?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Aug 6th, 2020 at 6:44pm

freediver wrote on Aug 5th, 2020 at 6:23pm:
You just admitted it was a risk of spreading the virus. Have you changed your mind?



freediver wrote on Aug 5th, 2020 at 6:23pm:
Why was it not a good idea, given that the theory of the virus spreading at the protest "has no legs?


In terms of actual evidence pointing to it spreading this particular outbreak - the theory has no legs. This is completely irrespective of whether or not it was advisable - which it clearly wasn't.

Please tell me you understand the difference between posing a risk of spreading the infection and actually causing the spread.


freediver wrote on Aug 5th, 2020 at 6:31pm:
But it is still a long way from even being evidence that the BLM protestors didn't spread the virus, right?


No FD, we go through this every time. I don't need to prove anything here. Why is it that whenever we have these "FD please show us evidence it happened" discussions, it always ends up with you thinking I need to prove it didn't happen? Its uncanny.


freediver wrote on Aug 5th, 2020 at 6:31pm:
Do you think we should track down all the evidence that the government either didn't find or won't share?

Have you seen any government official give a straight answer on how many cases can be traced to the BLM protest?


Frankly I'll settle with sticking to what we do know before getting out our tin foil hats.


freediver wrote on Aug 5th, 2020 at 6:23pm:
You are lying Gandalf. Again.


You posted that completely useless graph literally in direct response to my request for evidence. It is of course understandable that you want to backpeddle now that you realise its not actually evidence - but its pretty obvious you wanted us to think that the graph showing nothing whatsoever except correlation between the protest and the outbreak somehow constituted as legit evidence.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Aug 6th, 2020 at 6:59pm

Quote:
No FD, we go through this every time. I don't need to prove anything here. Why is it that whenever we have these "FD please show us evidence it happened" discussions, it always ends up with you thinking I need to prove it didn't happen? Its uncanny.


Because you were defending the Victorian government's claims that the BLM protest did not spread the virus. If you don;t actually know what you are talking about, now would be the time to fess up.


Quote:
You posted that completely useless graph literally in direct response to my request for evidence.


Yes Gandalf. That's because it is evidence.


polite_gandalf wrote on Jul 30th, 2020 at 1:55pm:
Since you do realise Andrews is now openly admitting this wave was caused by his own incompetence with quarantine right??


What did Andrews actually say Gandalf?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Aug 6th, 2020 at 8:32pm

freediver wrote on Aug 6th, 2020 at 6:59pm:
Because you were defending the Victorian government's claims that the BLM protest did not spread the virus. If you don;t actually know what you are talking about, now would be the time to fess up.


Victorian government's claims that the BLM protest did not spread the virus eh? News to me. What did they actually say FD?

And again you are confused. I am not defending anything - least of all a claim I didn't even know was made (and assume wasn't made). I have contributed a few different points in this discussion - including refuting your idiotic claim that the government "condoned" the protest, refuting your claim that your graph is evidence that the protest caused the spread, providing actual evidence that the quarantine bungle caused the spread. But mostly its been about exposing the patently BS idea being spruiked not just by you, but the usual suspects as well, that somehow its a fait-accompli that the protest caused the spread - and furthermore the suggestion that any actual evidence is required to establish this is to be mercilessly ridiculed.

Precisely zero percent of my contribution in this thread has consisted of defending the Victorian government - in any way.


freediver wrote on Aug 6th, 2020 at 6:59pm:
Yes Gandalf. That's because it is evidence.


LOL. Its evidence of when the outbreak started in relation to when the protest happened. Thats all. It is *NOT* evidence that the protest caused the outbreak, which is the only relevant type of evidence we need here. Like I keep saying, correlation is not causation.


freediver wrote on Aug 6th, 2020 at 6:59pm:
What did Andrews actually say Gandalf?


Fine I got that wrong. He has not "openly admitted" anything in that regard. So shoot me. It was hardly my key point though. What was a more key point here though, and which is in no way disputed by this, is that it makes no freaking sense to suggest the government is embarassed that it might be caused by an event they clearly discouraged and begged not to happen. Saying the government "condoned" the BLM protest is by an order of magnitude far more ridiculous than anything I said here.

In any case, basically everyone *BUT* the government openly agrees that the quarantine bungle was the cause of it. Everyone that matters, that is (doctors, scientists, experts etc).

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Aug 6th, 2020 at 9:15pm

Quote:
Fine I got that wrong. He has not "openly admitted" anything in that regard. So shoot me. It was hardly my key point though. What was a more key point here though, and which is in no way disputed by this, is that it makes no freaking sense to suggest the government is embarassed that it might be caused by an event they clearly discouraged and begged not to happen.


Yes it does. They allowed it to happen. They signalled beforehand that they would allow it, even though they had already made it illegal. You split hairs over whether this counts as "condoning" it, but the protestors obviously aren't going to care whether it upsets Andrews. They do care about getting arresting and copping massive fines. It was a massive blunder, which they allowed to happen for political reasons, and they followed it up with transparent BS rhetoric, which people like you swallowed hook line and sinker. And it has taken me a dozen pages to get you to look at what he actually said rather than what you wanted him to say.


Quote:
In any case, basically everyone *BUT* the government openly agrees that the quarantine bungle was the cause of it.


Back to square one. What do they actually say? The closest you have come to abandoning mindless rhetoric for a substantive claim was attributing 60 cases to it.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Aug 7th, 2020 at 11:59am

freediver wrote on Aug 6th, 2020 at 9:15pm:
Yes it does. They allowed it to happen. They signalled beforehand that they would allow it, even though they had already made it illegal.


What did they say exactly FD? No one actually turned around and said it suddenly wasn't illegal anymore. Fines were still issued to organisers. You do however have to be practical. You can't always just magically stop thousands of people intending to protest - no matter how much you stress how illegal it is. Sometimes you just have to manage it as best you can.

My understanding is that it was the police who decided they would not be issuing fines, arresting or getting into any potential physical situation with thousands of protestors. And if you actually stopped and thought about it for 2 seconds, thats actually the safest option if you are interested in avoiding potential spraed of the virus. The last thing you want is for police and protestors getting into open scuffles, which obviously would involve significant physical contact, and thus maximising the potential spread of an infection. That would be the worst case scenario, and what would most certainly have happened if the illegal protest (which remained illegal) was actually policed.

Says deputy police commissioner:


Quote:
"We don’t want to be applying any use of force whatsoever … we don’t even want this to go ahead, but if it does, we will try and have a peaceful [event], but people have to be accountable for their actions," he said.

"If it goes ahead we'll probably have to apply a lot of discretion because you can't practically issue thousands and thousands of infringements."


https://www.theage.com.au/national/victoria/melbourne-organisers-of-stop-black-deaths-in-custody-rally-defy-authorities-pleas-to-call-it-off-20200605-p54zv6.html

So thats two suspect statements you've attributed to the Victorian government FD - 1. that they claimed the BLM protest didn't cause the spread of the virus and 2. that they "signalled" (whatever that means) they would allow it after they previously had already made it illegal. For someone who glibly claims the moral high ground about the need to stick to "substantive claims", this all looks suspiciously like BS to me.

Of course none of this addresses the key point that there is still zero evidence that the protest caused the outbreak. And are you still running with the BS idea that your correlation graph is somehow evidence it caused the outbreak?


freediver wrote on Aug 6th, 2020 at 9:15pm:
Back to square one. What do they actually say? The closest you have come to abandoning mindless rhetoric for a substantive claim was attributing 60 cases to it.


"what they actually say" is pretty well summed up in the article you still refuse to read. And apparently you are still clueless as to how significant 60 cases can be to an outbreak of such an infectious virus, in the actual numbers (still only in the hundreds of new infections each day) that we are seeing.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Aug 7th, 2020 at 8:52pm

Quote:
What did they say exactly FD? No one actually turned around and said it suddenly wasn't illegal anymore. Fines were still issued to organisers. You do however have to be practical. You can't always just magically stop thousands of people intending to protest - no matter how much you stress how illegal it is. Sometimes you just have to manage it as best you can.


Sure you can. It worked in Sydney. There were no practical barriers. It had nothing to do with being practical. All that was missing was political will. And that's why they are tapdancing around the consequences.


Quote:
My understanding is that it was the police who decided they would not be issuing fines, arresting or getting into any potential physical situation with thousands of protestors.


Do you really think the police made this decision in isolation? And if so, why did Andrews signal to the public that there would be no legal consequences to turning up?


Quote:
So thats two suspect statements you've attributed to the Victorian government FD - 1. that they claimed the BLM protest didn't cause the spread of the virus and 2. that they "signalled" (whatever that means) they would allow it after they previously had already made it illegal.


It was from your own evidence. I merely quoted it back to you and pointed out what he actually said.


Quote:
"what they actually say" is pretty well summed up in the article you still refuse to read


Yes Gandalf, I refuse to read articles that I do not know about.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by The_Barnacle on Aug 8th, 2020 at 10:49am

Gordon wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 10:10am:
Professor Brett Sutton has previously revealed that genomic sequencing carried out by Melbourne's Doherty Institute shows a significant proportion – if not all – of Victoria's second-wave cases may be traced back to quarantine breaches at hotels.



I agree with Gordon

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Aug 8th, 2020 at 12:49pm

The_Barnacle wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 10:49am:

Gordon wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 10:10am:
Professor Brett Sutton has previously revealed that genomic sequencing carried out by Melbourne's Doherty Institute shows a significant proportion – if not all – of Victoria's second-wave cases may be traced back to quarantine breaches at hotels.



I agree with Gordon


So, somewhere between 1% and 100%, based on your opinion, which is based on nothing?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by The_Barnacle on Aug 8th, 2020 at 1:09pm

freediver wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 12:49pm:

The_Barnacle wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 10:49am:

Gordon wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 10:10am:
Professor Brett Sutton has previously revealed that genomic sequencing carried out by Melbourne's Doherty Institute shows a significant proportion – if not all – of Victoria's second-wave cases may be traced back to quarantine breaches at hotels.



I agree with Gordon


So, somewhere between 1% and 100%, based on your opinion, which is based on nothing?


No.  "A significant proportion, if not all", based on the findings of Professor Brett Sutton

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by JaSin. on Aug 8th, 2020 at 1:18pm
Gandalf's and Freediver's stoushes are the best.

There was Gordon's and LTYC's there for a while.
It_is_the_Light and Sad Kangaroo.
Mothra and Lisa Jones.
Agnes and Aussie.
Setanta's and Smith's.
Cods v Emma
Bobby v Monk
Trump v Peccary
Aged Care v Cliff (poor bugger)
and much more like JaSin and Lols. :D

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Aug 8th, 2020 at 1:28pm

The_Barnacle wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 1:09pm:

freediver wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 12:49pm:

The_Barnacle wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 10:49am:

Gordon wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 10:10am:
Professor Brett Sutton has previously revealed that genomic sequencing carried out by Melbourne's Doherty Institute shows a significant proportion – if not all – of Victoria's second-wave cases may be traced back to quarantine breaches at hotels.



I agree with Gordon


So, somewhere between 1% and 100%, based on your opinion, which is based on nothing?


No.  "A significant proportion, if not all", based on the findings of Professor Brett Sutton


What did he find? Is he the one who came up with "Victoria is not having a second wave"?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by SadKangaroo on Aug 8th, 2020 at 1:36pm
Notice that anything under the watch of a Labor leader is 100% their fault and they should be held to account.  But Liberal leaders, there is always someone else to blame.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by The_Barnacle on Aug 8th, 2020 at 1:41pm

freediver wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 1:28pm:

The_Barnacle wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 1:09pm:

freediver wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 12:49pm:

The_Barnacle wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 10:49am:

Gordon wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 10:10am:
Professor Brett Sutton has previously revealed that genomic sequencing carried out by Melbourne's Doherty Institute shows a significant proportion – if not all – of Victoria's second-wave cases may be traced back to quarantine breaches at hotels.



I agree with Gordon


So, somewhere between 1% and 100%, based on your opinion, which is based on nothing?


No.  "A significant proportion, if not all", based on the findings of Professor Brett Sutton


What did he find? Is he the one who came up with "Victoria is not having a second wave"?


Professor Brett Sutton has previously revealed that genomic sequencing carried out by Melbourne's Doherty Institute shows a significant proportion – if not all – of Victoria's second-wave cases may be traced back to quarantine breaches at hotels

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Aug 8th, 2020 at 1:54pm

The_Barnacle wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 1:41pm:

freediver wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 1:28pm:

The_Barnacle wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 1:09pm:

freediver wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 12:49pm:

The_Barnacle wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 10:49am:

Gordon wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 10:10am:
Professor Brett Sutton has previously revealed that genomic sequencing carried out by Melbourne's Doherty Institute shows a significant proportion – if not all – of Victoria's second-wave cases may be traced back to quarantine breaches at hotels.



I agree with Gordon


So, somewhere between 1% and 100%, based on your opinion, which is based on nothing?


No.  "A significant proportion, if not all", based on the findings of Professor Brett Sutton


What did he find? Is he the one who came up with "Victoria is not having a second wave"?


Professor Brett Sutton has previously revealed that genomic sequencing carried out by Melbourne's Doherty Institute shows a significant proportion – if not all – of Victoria's second-wave cases may be traced back to quarantine breaches at hotels


So, somewhere between 1% and 100%?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by SadKangaroo on Aug 8th, 2020 at 2:40pm
Before we get too hung up on blaming the state govt, or the federal govt, or China for our covid situation let’s review some facts,

1. We had to bring in mandatory quarantining in hotels, because we couldn’t trust people to stay home after returning from overseas.

2. We then had to bring in security, because we couldn’t trust people to stay in those hotels.

3. We then had to bring in ADF, because we couldn’t trust the security guards not to have sex with those in quarantine in the hotels.

4. We had to get police to door knock and check up on people, because we couldnt trust those who were meant to be self-isolating to actually stay at home.

5. We also have to have police and ADF reinforce the metropolitan melb zone and state borders, because we can’t trust people to follow the restrictions.

6. We are now being asked to use masks, because we cannot trust people to social distance when they are in public.

7. Through it all, our supermarkets have had to introduce shopping restrictions because we couldn’t trust people to not to take more than what they needed.

So we can get as mad as we want at politicians or health officials for imposing restrictions, or the country where the virus originated, but essentially it’s our own fault that we find ourselves here.

Selfishness and lack of empathy seems to be as much of a disease as covid itself.

The quicker people start following directions, the quicker this situation will improve.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by The_Barnacle on Aug 9th, 2020 at 10:48am

freediver wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 1:54pm:

The_Barnacle wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 1:41pm:

freediver wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 1:28pm:

The_Barnacle wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 1:09pm:

freediver wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 12:49pm:

The_Barnacle wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 10:49am:

Gordon wrote on Aug 8th, 2020 at 10:10am:
Professor Brett Sutton has previously revealed that genomic sequencing carried out by Melbourne's Doherty Institute shows a significant proportion – if not all – of Victoria's second-wave cases may be traced back to quarantine breaches at hotels.



I agree with Gordon


So, somewhere between 1% and 100%, based on your opinion, which is based on nothing?


No.  "A significant proportion, if not all", based on the findings of Professor Brett Sutton


What did he find? Is he the one who came up with "Victoria is not having a second wave"?


Professor Brett Sutton has previously revealed that genomic sequencing carried out by Melbourne's Doherty Institute shows a significant proportion – if not all – of Victoria's second-wave cases may be traced back to quarantine breaches at hotels


So, somewhere between 1% and 100%?


no. you are as bad as lee with your deliberate obfuscation. In fact your whole debating style is very similar to lee.
Professor Brett Sutton has previously revealed that genomic sequencing carried out by Melbourne's Doherty Institute shows a significant proportion – if not all – of Victoria's second-wave cases may be traced back to quarantine breaches at hotels
Even of it is only a "significant proportion" that doesn't automatically mean that the BLM protests account for the rest of it.
So it is actually 0%, unless you can find any evidence, which you have failed to do 


Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Aug 9th, 2020 at 11:27am
What do you mean by no? Are you actually disagreeing with my interpretation?


Quote:
Even of it is only a "significant proportion" that doesn't automatically mean that the BLM protests account for the rest of it.


So all you really have is a statement that is either irrelevant to the question of whether the protestors spread the virus, or does not offer a direct answer?

Did any of the quarantine breaches occur before the protest?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by The_Barnacle on Aug 9th, 2020 at 11:35am

freediver wrote on Aug 9th, 2020 at 11:27am:
What do you mean by no? Are you actually disagreeing with my interpretation?


Quote:
Even of it is only a "significant proportion" that doesn't automatically mean that the BLM protests account for the rest of it.


So all you really have is a statement that is either irrelevant to the question of whether the protestors spread the virus, or does not offer a direct answer?

Did any of the quarantine breaches occur before the protest?


I'm saying that it is a flawed interpretation.
The facts we have are that a significant proportion, if not all, of the second wave were caused by quarantine breaches.
The onus of proof is on you to prove that any part of the second wave was caused by the BLM protests (and there are more than 2 options for the cause of the second wave)


Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Aug 9th, 2020 at 12:59pm

Quote:
I'm saying that it is a flawed interpretation.


In what way is it flawed? Is it incorrect, or just not how the Victorian government wants it spinned?


Quote:
The onus of proof is on you to prove that any part of the second wave was caused by the BLM protests (and there are more than 2 options for the cause of the second wave)


Why?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by The_Barnacle on Aug 9th, 2020 at 1:10pm

freediver wrote on Aug 9th, 2020 at 12:59pm:

Quote:
I'm saying that it is a flawed interpretation.


In what way is it flawed? Is it incorrect, or just not how the Victorian government wants it spinned?

[quote]The onus of proof is on you to prove that any part of the second wave was caused by the BLM protests (and there are more than 2 options for the cause of the second wave)


Why?[/quote]

In that case your white flag is accepted.
If you have nothing to contribute we can all accept that Professor Brett Sutton's study is correct and move on.
The question you posed in the thread title can be answered "No".
end of debate 

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Aug 9th, 2020 at 2:58pm

Quote:
The question you posed in the thread title can be answered "No".


Is there any onus on you to back this up?

Do you actually disagree with my interpretation, or do you merely dislike the fact I am not trying to spin it the way the Victorian government did?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Aug 10th, 2020 at 8:20am
Does anyone else think it is dangerous that the Victorian government is either not attempting to answer this question, or is withholding the answer, with apparent public support?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Bobby. on Aug 10th, 2020 at 8:31am

freediver wrote on Aug 10th, 2020 at 8:20am:
Does anyone else think it is dangerous that the Victorian government is either not attempting to answer this question, or is withholding the answer, with apparent public support?




Dick head Dan did answer it on TV one day a few weeks ago.
The state didn't have anywhere to put 20,000 people in jail
and neither did they have enough cops to give them all fines or enforce the law.
There were just too many protestors.


Yesterday there was a protest but as only 7 people turned up
they all get arrested and fined.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Aug 10th, 2020 at 8:36am

Quote:
Yesterday there was a protest but as only 7 people turned up
they all get arrested and fined.


Only 7 people turned up because they were getting arrested and fined. The organisers announced that it was cancelled as a result. Dan basically told the first round of protestors that they would not get arrested or fined.

You don't need to arrest them all. You don't even need to fine them all.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Bobby. on Aug 10th, 2020 at 8:44am

freediver wrote on Aug 10th, 2020 at 8:36am:

Quote:
Yesterday there was a protest but as only 7 people turned up
they all get arrested and fined.


Only 7 people turned up because they were getting arrested and fined. The organisers announced that it was cancelled as a result. Dan basically told the first round of protestors that they would not get arrested or fined.

You don't need to arrest them all. You don't even need to fine them all.



Dan told the BLM protestors that they would be fined but
nothing happened-
they all ignored it.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Aug 10th, 2020 at 9:14am
All the quotes I have seen here show him asking them politely not to go.

Even if he had a good excuse for letting them protest, that is not an excuse for misinforming the public about the consequences.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by J.D. on Aug 10th, 2020 at 10:28am
Between the BLM pricks, the 3rd world non English speaking immigrants being jammed into towers along with the Muslim and black African security guards Australia is in a dark place, a blackened place, at least immigration has ceased and the Abbos have been appeased with another massive handout, for now.

Oh and the Chinaman who spread this virus and who live 15 to a flat eating all sorts of animals.

The bubonic plague is looking like the next pandemic compliments of the Chinese.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Bobby. on Aug 10th, 2020 at 2:49pm

Bobby. wrote on Aug 10th, 2020 at 8:31am:

freediver wrote on Aug 10th, 2020 at 8:20am:
Does anyone else think it is dangerous that the Victorian government is either not attempting to answer this question, or is withholding the answer, with apparent public support?




Dick head Dan did answer it on TV one day a few weeks ago.
The state didn't have anywhere to put 20,000 people in jail
and neither did they have enough cops to give them all fines or enforce the law.
There were just too many protestors.


Yesterday there was a protest but as only 7 people turned up
they all get arrested and fined.






freediver wrote on Aug 10th, 2020 at 9:14am:
All the quotes I have seen here show him asking them politely not to go.

Even if he had a good excuse for letting them protest, that is not an excuse for misinforming the public about the consequences.



I don't remember him being so polite.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Ye Grappler on Aug 10th, 2020 at 7:26pm
Did the virus spread the protestors?  If so, was it:-

a)  In a public gathering
b)  On a slab
c)  At an arrest (spread 'em!)
d)  On toast as the idiots they are


... ten seconds......... ummm... lock in.... oh jeez.... lock in d), Eddie!

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by J.D. on Aug 10th, 2020 at 8:59pm
  Tens of thousands of Abbos running rampant in city streets across Australia during a pandemic had no effect on death rates increasing, everybody should wash their hands and social distance in lockup.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Aug 19th, 2020 at 8:30am

freediver wrote on Aug 7th, 2020 at 8:52pm:
Sure you can. It worked in Sydney. There were no practical barriers. It had nothing to do with being practical. All that was missing was political will. And that's why they are tapdancing around the consequences.


umm... they marched in Sydney during the same protest on June 6 FD. As well as Perth, Adelaide and Brisbane. Keep up.

"At least 20,000 attended the Sydney march which passed off peacefully, except for ugly scenes when police officers used pepper spray on protesters who had flowed into Central station after the rally finished."
https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2020/jun/06/australian-black-lives-matter-protests-tens-of-thousands-demand-end-to-indigenous-deaths-in-custody

So where was/is the second wave in Sydney hmmm?



Quote:
It was from your own evidence. I merely quoted it back to you and pointed out what he actually said.


He never said the BLM protest didn't cause the second wave. You made that up.


Quote:
Yes Gandalf, I refuse to read articles that I do not know about.


Great. Except you do know about it - I told you. It clearly sets out the evidence that the quarantine bungle caused the second wave. Thats what its about.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Aug 19th, 2020 at 8:43am
Two points for you FD, and I'm afraid it includes more of that pesky evidence that terrorizes you so...

1. Turns out Andrews did attribute the quarantine infections to at least some of the outbreak - lucky I caught this week's 4 corners:


Quote:
"This morning I received the most comprehensive genomics briefing I have received throughout the pandemic and what that briefing provided and put to me very clearly is that at least a significant number, and potentially more, of the outbreaks in the north of the city are attributable via genomic sequencing to staff members in hotel quarantine breaching well-known and well understood infection control protocols," Premier Andrews said.

https://www.nzherald.co.nz/world/news/article.cfm?c_id=2&objectid=12344413


2. in case you need any more proof that the quarantine bungle caused the second wave - this just in:


Quote:
The vast majority of the cases of Covid-19 in Victoria can be traced back to a single family that returned to Australia in mid-May who were kept in hotel quarantine at the Rydges Hotel, an inquiry has heard.



Quote:
Dr Charles Alpren, an epidemiologist with the Victorian Department of Health and Human Services, confirmed to the hotel quarantine inquiry over 90% of cases since the end of May could be linked to the one outbreak at the Rydges Hotel, while almost all of the other cases could be linked to an outbreak at the Stamford Plaza Hotel.



Quote:
99% of current cases in Victoria linked to hotel quarantine
Alpren said that based on the data obtained by the department from 3,234 of the over 12,000 cases in the past month, 3,183 are linked to the Rydges Hotel cluster.

For the 1,589 cases sequenced from cases with symptom onset in the past month, Alpren said all but 12 were linked to Rydges.

The remaining 12 were linked to a cluster at the Stamford Plaza Hotel, where 46 cases were connected to a man who tested positive after returning to Australia on 1 June, or a couple who tested positive after arriving in Australia in mid-June.

Although there had been two other cases that weren’t linked to either outbreak, Alpren said he was “satisfied to conclude” that 99% of current cases of Covid-19 in Victoria had arisen from the Rydges or Stamford Plaza hotels used for hotel quarantine.


https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2020/aug/18/hotel-quarantine-linked-to-99-of-victorias-covid-cases-inquiry-told

pffft scientists - what do they know?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Aug 19th, 2020 at 5:54pm

polite_gandalf wrote on Aug 19th, 2020 at 8:43am:
Two points for you FD, and I'm afraid it includes more of that pesky evidence that terrorizes you so...

1. Turns out Andrews did attribute the quarantine infections to at least some of the outbreak - lucky I caught this week's 4 corners:


Quote:
"This morning I received the most comprehensive genomics briefing I have received throughout the pandemic and what that briefing provided and put to me very clearly is that at least a significant number, and potentially more, of the outbreaks in the north of the city are attributable via genomic sequencing to staff members in hotel quarantine breaching well-known and well understood infection control protocols," Premier Andrews said.

https://www.nzherald.co.nz/world/news/article.cfm?c_id=2&objectid=12344413


2. in case you need any more proof that the quarantine bungle caused the second wave - this just in:

[quote]The vast majority of the cases of Covid-19 in Victoria can be traced back to a single family that returned to Australia in mid-May who were kept in hotel quarantine at the Rydges Hotel, an inquiry has heard.



Quote:
Dr Charles Alpren, an epidemiologist with the Victorian Department of Health and Human Services, confirmed to the hotel quarantine inquiry over 90% of cases since the end of May could be linked to the one outbreak at the Rydges Hotel, while almost all of the other cases could be linked to an outbreak at the Stamford Plaza Hotel.



Quote:
99% of current cases in Victoria linked to hotel quarantine
Alpren said that based on the data obtained by the department from 3,234 of the over 12,000 cases in the past month, 3,183 are linked to the Rydges Hotel cluster.

For the 1,589 cases sequenced from cases with symptom onset in the past month, Alpren said all but 12 were linked to Rydges.

The remaining 12 were linked to a cluster at the Stamford Plaza Hotel, where 46 cases were connected to a man who tested positive after returning to Australia on 1 June, or a couple who tested positive after arriving in Australia in mid-June.

Although there had been two other cases that weren’t linked to either outbreak, Alpren said he was “satisfied to conclude” that 99% of current cases of Covid-19 in Victoria had arisen from the Rydges or Stamford Plaza hotels used for hotel quarantine.


https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2020/aug/18/hotel-quarantine-linked-to-99-of-victorias-covid-cases-inquiry-told

pffft scientists - what do they know?[/quote]

Can you explain how this answers the question at hand?


Quote:
So where was/is the second wave in Sydney hmmm?


Perhaps it disappeared into a black hole along with Sydney's quarantine hotels.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Aug 20th, 2020 at 1:57pm

freediver wrote on Aug 19th, 2020 at 5:54pm:
Can you explain how this answers the question at hand?


And which question is currently "at hand" FD? I was dealing with two particular claims of mine that you seemed to take issue with - 1. that Andrews acknowledged that the quarantine bungle was responsible for the second wave and 2. that there is clear evidence that the quarantine bungle caused the second wave. I present evidence which clearly substantiates those claims.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Aug 20th, 2020 at 6:43pm

polite_gandalf wrote on Aug 20th, 2020 at 1:57pm:

freediver wrote on Aug 19th, 2020 at 5:54pm:
Can you explain how this answers the question at hand?


And which question is currently "at hand" FD? I was dealing with two particular claims of mine that you seemed to take issue with - 1. that Andrews acknowledged that the quarantine bungle was responsible for the second wave and 2. that there is clear evidence that the quarantine bungle caused the second wave. I present evidence which clearly substantiates those claims.


did the protestors spread the virus?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Setanta on Aug 20th, 2020 at 7:03pm

freediver wrote on Aug 20th, 2020 at 6:43pm:

polite_gandalf wrote on Aug 20th, 2020 at 1:57pm:

freediver wrote on Aug 19th, 2020 at 5:54pm:
Can you explain how this answers the question at hand?


And which question is currently "at hand" FD? I was dealing with two particular claims of mine that you seemed to take issue with - 1. that Andrews acknowledged that the quarantine bungle was responsible for the second wave and 2. that there is clear evidence that the quarantine bungle caused the second wave. I present evidence which clearly substantiates those claims.


did the protestors spread the virus?


Did any of the ethnics guarding the hotel take part in the BLM rally and did they or those they were in contact with live in those highrise incubation chambers in Melbourne?


Quote:
NSW Police Commissioner Fuller said:
"From our perspective it was obviously big numbers in Victoria, a number of people who came to the protest were living in those vertical towers so that certainly is enough for me."

But in a statement to the ABC last week, the Victorian Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) said that of the six protesters who subsequently tested positive to COVID-19, none were known to live in a "major public housing complex".
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-07-24/coronacheck-black-lives-matter-melbourne-andrew-bolt-masks/12481360


You don't have to live there, and it's not saying they don't, only have friends or family that do.

There seems to have been a perfect storm in Melbourne that was different from other states, the army guarding other state's quarantine. Using young, poor and immoral ethnics as guards is obviously a big part of it but then when you take the highrise ethnic covid factories and BLM whiners into consideration, it'd be hard not to draw links. These "coincidences" were not in any other state.

edit: The only way we could know for certain is if genetic samples were taken from the marchers, we haven't been provided with this information and only the Vic govt can. All the Vic govt has said is the genetics point at the quarantine hotel but that is only half the info we need and they haven't provided the other half, does that also match the marcher's covid genetics.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Aug 20th, 2020 at 8:42pm

Quote:
Using young, poor and immoral ethnics as guards is obviously a big part of it


People likely to attend a BLM protest?

Where is this from? I have seen vague references to it a few times.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Setanta on Aug 21st, 2020 at 10:40am

freediver wrote on Aug 20th, 2020 at 8:42pm:

Quote:
Using young, poor and immoral ethnics as guards is obviously a big part of it


People likely to attend a BLM protest?

Where is this from? I have seen vague references to it a few times.


Look at those that have spoken to the media.
https://www.news.com.au/world/coronavirus/australia/coronavirus-victoria-melbourne-hotel-quarantine-guards-paid-18hour-received-no-training/news-story/2810bf7d9c44e6ab903de662b0a3a39f
https://www.news.com.au/world/coronavirus/australia/coronavirus-victoria-more-bombshell-hotel-quarantine-claims-aired/news-story/14d587880d83bc3b195d52a27e2d88dd
https://9now.nine.com.au/today/melbourne-security-guard-claims-coronavirus-hotel-quarantine-staff-blamed-for-new-outbreak-given-five-minutes-of-training/03616853-77d5-4388-bac4-d7813ea71c87

If they don't work, google - victorian quarantine guards

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by The_Barnacle on Aug 21st, 2020 at 12:07pm

Setanta wrote on Aug 20th, 2020 at 7:03pm:
There seems to have been a perfect storm in Melbourne that was different from other states, the army guarding other state's quarantine. Using young, poor and immoral ethnics as guards is obviously a big part of it but then when you take the highrise ethnic covid factories and BLM whiners into consideration, it'd be hard not to draw links. These "coincidences" were not in any other state.


Actually the security companies are to blame
They didn't provide the guards any training or satisfactory protective gear.
They were more interested in profit margins than keeping the public safe

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Aug 25th, 2020 at 6:02pm
Do people think that the Victorian government has provided an answer to the question with their latest pronouncements?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by The_Barnacle on Aug 26th, 2020 at 7:00am

freediver wrote on Aug 25th, 2020 at 6:02pm:
Do people think that the Victorian government has provided an answer to the question with their latest pronouncements?


Do you?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Aug 26th, 2020 at 6:04pm
Of course not.

Do you?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Sep 6th, 2020 at 4:44pm
Has everyone changed their mind?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by UnSubRocky on Sep 9th, 2020 at 2:10am

freediver wrote on Sep 6th, 2020 at 4:44pm:
Has everyone changed their mind?


Some months back, I thought that the coronavirus case numbers were going to be about 60,000 before the general decline and cessation of the virus. A couple of months ago, with 6,000 cases and probably 100 deaths, I figured that my prediction was greatly exaggerated. Tonight, I have concluded that there might be a middle ground for my previous predictions. Say, 35,000 cases (we are in the final stages) and perhaps 1,000 deaths (I hope not).

I do not think there was a considerable influence of the BLM protest to have spread the covid19. I figure it was those that had jetted into Australia from overseas hotspots that had reactivated the spread of covid19, because they did not want to quarantine properly.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Sep 14th, 2020 at 11:28am

freediver wrote on Aug 20th, 2020 at 6:43pm:

polite_gandalf wrote on Aug 20th, 2020 at 1:57pm:

freediver wrote on Aug 19th, 2020 at 5:54pm:
Can you explain how this answers the question at hand?


And which question is currently "at hand" FD? I was dealing with two particular claims of mine that you seemed to take issue with - 1. that Andrews acknowledged that the quarantine bungle was responsible for the second wave and 2. that there is clear evidence that the quarantine bungle caused the second wave. I present evidence which clearly substantiates those claims.


did the protestors spread the virus?


Sensible people stick to the evidence. And there is no shred of evidence that the protestors spread the virus.

What the evidence does say is that this so called "second wave" is a new strain of the virus that was not previously in the community - meaning that it was imported from overseas. The evidence also points to two specific quarantine hotels in Melbourne.

Here you go, I'll give you yet another article about it so you can ignore that too, and bury your head back into your tin-foil hat conspiracies:

https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2020/aug/18/hotel-quarantine-linked-to-99-of-victorias-covid-cases-inquiry-told

and the abc article I posted for you to ignore as well - explaining why the 2nd wave strain most likely came from overseas:

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-07-11/fuel-spark-victoria-response-virus-public-health-bushfire/12443982

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Sep 14th, 2020 at 6:20pm

polite_gandalf wrote on Sep 14th, 2020 at 11:28am:

freediver wrote on Aug 20th, 2020 at 6:43pm:

polite_gandalf wrote on Aug 20th, 2020 at 1:57pm:

freediver wrote on Aug 19th, 2020 at 5:54pm:
Can you explain how this answers the question at hand?


And which question is currently "at hand" FD? I was dealing with two particular claims of mine that you seemed to take issue with - 1. that Andrews acknowledged that the quarantine bungle was responsible for the second wave and 2. that there is clear evidence that the quarantine bungle caused the second wave. I present evidence which clearly substantiates those claims.


did the protestors spread the virus?


Sensible people stick to the evidence. And there is no shred of evidence that the protestors spread the virus.

What the evidence does say is that this so called "second wave" is a new strain of the virus that was not previously in the community - meaning that it was imported from overseas. The evidence also points to two specific quarantine hotels in Melbourne.

Here you go, I'll give you yet another article about it so you can ignore that too, and bury your head back into your tin-foil hat conspiracies:

https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2020/aug/18/hotel-quarantine-linked-to-99-of-victorias-covid-cases-inquiry-told

and the abc article I posted for you to ignore as well - explaining why the 2nd wave strain most likely came from overseas:

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-07-11/fuel-spark-victoria-response-virus-public-health-bushfire/12443982


The virus came from China Gandalf. We know that. But it does not mean the protestors did not spread it.

Sensible people know that equating absence of evidence with evidence of absence is a logical fallacy. But Dan Andrews knows that must people are not sensible.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Sep 14th, 2020 at 6:39pm

freediver wrote on Sep 14th, 2020 at 6:20pm:
Sensible people know that equating absence of evidence with evidence of absence is a logical fallacy.


You've used this idiotic line to try and legitimise baseless BS statements before. Its possibly even more inappropriate and idiotic in this instance. Its like anyone who reasonably insists that claims need to be substantiated with evidence before they can be taken seriously - can simply be dismissed as equating absense of evidence with evidence of absense. And hey, you get to spout cool sounding phrases like "logical fallacy" to cover up the fact that you have no freaking clue what you are talking about.


freediver wrote on Sep 14th, 2020 at 6:20pm:
The virus came from China Gandalf. We know that. But it does not mean the protestors did not spread it.


Never mind FD. The point obviously went straight over your head. Next time it might help if you actually read what I'm talking about. The dummies version is that the strain that caused the second wave can be traced to a specific place and time - which given what and when this place and time actually was, absolutely does mean that the protestors almost certainly didn't spread it. But of course you would have understood this if you actually read what I was talking about.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Sep 14th, 2020 at 6:44pm

polite_gandalf wrote on Sep 14th, 2020 at 6:39pm:

freediver wrote on Sep 14th, 2020 at 6:20pm:
Sensible people know that equating absence of evidence with evidence of absence is a logical fallacy.


You've used this idiotic line to try and legitimise baseless BS statements before. Its possibly even more inappropriate and idiotic in this instance. Its like anyone who reasonably insists that claims need to be substantiated with evidence before they can be taken seriously - can simply be dismissed as equating absense of evidence with evidence of absense. And hey, you get to spout cool sounding phrases like "logical fallacy" to cover up the fact that you have no freaking clue what you are talking about.


I am asking a question Gandalf. Did the protestors spread the virus? You seem to think that not having evidence answers the question. Why is that?


Quote:

freediver wrote on Sep 14th, 2020 at 6:20pm:
The virus came from China Gandalf. We know that. But it does not mean the protestors did not spread it.


Never mind FD. The point obviously went straight over your head. Next time it might help if you actually read what I'm talking about. The dummies version is that the strain that caused the second wave can be traced to a specific place and time - which given what and when this place and time actually was, absolutely does mean that the protestors almost certainly didn't spread it. But of course you would have understood this if you actually read what I was talking about.


When was this place and time?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Sep 15th, 2020 at 10:43am

freediver wrote on Sep 14th, 2020 at 6:44pm:
I am asking a question Gandalf. Did the protestors spread the virus? You seem to think that not having evidence answers the question. Why is that?


Of course it answers the question FD. Just pause for a moment and consider how utterly absurd you are being in these four sentences.

If you really can't understand how pointing out the lack of evidence answers the question perfectly, then there's not much else I can do to help you. No wonder that you fumble around with completely inapropriate idiotic retorts like 'absense of evidence does not equate evidence of absense'. Presumably the only answer you would accept is one that is based on complete ignorance and without any basis in actual fact - you know like the BS you dish out on a daily basis.


freediver wrote on Sep 14th, 2020 at 6:44pm:
When was this place and time?


I'm not going to endlessly repeat myself just because you refuse to read and comprehend what I post.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gazza on Sep 16th, 2020 at 7:39am

polite_gandalf wrote on Sep 15th, 2020 at 10:43am:

freediver wrote on Sep 14th, 2020 at 6:44pm:
I am asking a question Gandalf. Did the protestors spread the virus? You seem to think that not having evidence answers the question. Why is that?


Of course it answers the question FD. Just pause for a moment and consider how utterly absurd you are being in these four sentences.

If you really can't understand how pointing out the lack of evidence answers the question perfectly, then there's not much else I can do to help you. No wonder that you fumble around with completely inapropriate idiotic retorts like 'absense of evidence does not equate evidence of absense'. Presumably the only answer you would accept is one that is based on complete ignorance and without any basis in actual fact - you know like the BS you dish out on a daily basis.


freediver wrote on Sep 14th, 2020 at 6:44pm:
When was this place and time?


I'm not going to endlessly repeat myself just because you refuse to read and comprehend what I post.


This assumes, of course, that we truly do have all the evidence. We don't!

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Sep 16th, 2020 at 10:15am
There is evidence that the second wave was caused by quarantine bungling. See the expert testimony quoted in the Guardian article that FD can't bring himself to read.

There is precisely zero evidence that it was caused by protestors. Thats the sensible person's answer to the question "did the protestors cause the second wave". But of course if you point this out to FD he accuses you of equating absense of evidence to evidence of absense, or some such nonsense.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gazza on Sep 16th, 2020 at 1:01pm

polite_gandalf wrote on Sep 16th, 2020 at 10:15am:
There is evidence that the second wave was caused by quarantine bungling. See the expert testimony quoted in the Guardian article that FD can't bring himself to read.

There is precisely zero evidence that it was caused by protestors. Thats the sensible person's answer to the question "did the protestors cause the second wave". But of course if you point this out to FD he accuses you of equating absense of evidence to evidence of absense, or some such nonsense.


After Chairman Dan's refusal to share information on the medical advice and science used to back his decisions, his outright lies re curfew, and his obvious dislike of transparency and accountability, even the skeptics might wonder if certain evidence has been conveniently "disappeared", as they say in China.

Just because we are not seeing evidence does not mean it does not exist. At least anecdotally, us mere mortals can see the correlation between the sudden growth in new infections following the BLM protest, followed by the swat style lock-down of the towers, and then the potential link with hotel quarantine security staff. I say anecdotal, because that's all we've been given to go on...it's all been very hush-hush!

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by The_Barnacle on Sep 16th, 2020 at 2:55pm
Hey Freediver, do you have Fairies at the bottom of your Garden?

remember sensible people know that equating absence of evidence with evidence of absence is a logical fallacy.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by JaSin. on Sep 16th, 2020 at 3:33pm
They may not have spread it.
But they certainly jumped at the chance to.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by UnSubRocky on Sep 16th, 2020 at 4:15pm
https://www.news.com.au/lifestyle/health/health-problems/blood-tests-find-thousands-of-covid19-cases-could-have-gone-undetected/news-story/05b50d7acd84318aff5656a99151464f


Quote:
“This suggests that instead of 11,000 cases we know about from nasal swab testing, about 70,000 people had been exposed overall.”


We may have reached my predictions sooner than I thought.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Sep 16th, 2020 at 9:21pm

polite_gandalf wrote on Sep 15th, 2020 at 10:43am:

freediver wrote on Sep 14th, 2020 at 6:44pm:
I am asking a question Gandalf. Did the protestors spread the virus? You seem to think that not having evidence answers the question. Why is that?


Of course it answers the question FD. Just pause for a moment and consider how utterly absurd you are being in these four sentences.

If you really can't understand how pointing out the lack of evidence answers the question perfectly, then there's not much else I can do to help you. No wonder that you fumble around with completely inapropriate idiotic retorts like 'absense of evidence does not equate evidence of absense'. Presumably the only answer you would accept is one that is based on complete ignorance and without any basis in actual fact - you know like the BS you dish out on a daily basis.


freediver wrote on Sep 14th, 2020 at 6:44pm:
When was this place and time?


I'm not going to endlessly repeat myself just because you refuse to read and comprehend what I post.


Gandalf this is what you posted:


Quote:
The dummies version is that the strain that caused the second wave can be traced to a specific place and time - which given what and when this place and time actually was, absolutely does mean that the protestors almost certainly didn't spread it.


You have not posted this evidence before. Where is it?

All you have is baseless claims and no evidence. You seem to think both of these answer the question. Neither do. If you really do have the evidence to shut this question down, why are you afraid to post it?

It looks to me like you are merely so gullible that you believe what the Victorian government wants you to believe, without them even having to say it.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Sep 17th, 2020 at 9:17am

freediver wrote on Sep 16th, 2020 at 9:21pm:
You have not posted this evidence before. Where is it?


Yes I have FD, repeatedly. I even started a thread about it. You just refuse to read it. But since I'm so nice and patient, I'll give you a hint to get you started: two hotels in Melbourne being used for quarantine.


freediver wrote on Sep 16th, 2020 at 9:21pm:
It looks to me like you are merely so gullible that you believe what the Victorian government wants you to believe


As I have pointed out repeatedly, it is not coming from the government.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by The_Barnacle on Sep 17th, 2020 at 11:37am
Freediver, how many times do you need to be told?

There is no evidence that the protesters spread the virus
There is plenty of evidence that poor Hotel Quarantine practices spread the virus

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Gazza on Sep 17th, 2020 at 12:23pm

The_Barnacle wrote on Sep 17th, 2020 at 11:37am:
Freediver, how many times do you need to be told?

There is no evidence that the protesters spread the virus
There is plenty of evidence that poor Hotel Quarantine practices spread the virus


"There is plenty of evidence that poor Hotel Quarantine practices spread the virus". Agree.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by FRED. on Sep 17th, 2020 at 12:31pm

Gazza wrote on Sep 17th, 2020 at 12:23pm:

The_Barnacle wrote on Sep 17th, 2020 at 11:37am:
Freediver, how many times do you need to be told?

There is no evidence that the protesters spread the virus
There is plenty of evidence that poor Hotel Quarantine practices spread the virus


"There is plenty of evidence that poor Hotel Quarantine practices spread the virus". Agree.

Coronavirus (COVID-19) statistics
Victoria cases
Updated 17 Sep at 12:13 pm local
Confirmed
19,943
+32
Deaths
737
+8
Recovered
18,153
+74
Australia cases
Updated 17 Sep at 12:13 pm local
Confirmed
26,779
+41
Deaths
824
+8
Recovered
23,721
+74

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Sep 17th, 2020 at 6:36pm

The_Barnacle wrote on Sep 17th, 2020 at 11:37am:
Freediver, how many times do you need to be told?

There is no evidence that the protesters spread the virus
There is plenty of evidence that poor Hotel Quarantine practices spread the virus


I'll give you a quick lesson in logic Barny, as you have obviously missed the previous 20 or so pages. Neither of these is evidence that the protestors did not spread the virus.

Gandalf this is what you posted:


Quote:
The dummies version is that the strain that caused the second wave can be traced to a specific place and time - which given what and when this place and time actually was, absolutely does mean that the protestors almost certainly didn't spread it.


You have not posted this evidence before. Where is it? You have posted other evidence, but you keep running away from this particular claim, even though it appears to be the crux of your argument.

All you have is baseless claims and no evidence. You seem to think both of these answer the question. Neither do. If you really do have the evidence to shut this question down, why are you afraid to post it?

It looks to me like you are merely so gullible that you believe what the Victorian government wants you to believe, without them even having to say it.

As you both seem to have forgotten, this is the question: did the protestors spread the virus?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Sep 18th, 2020 at 1:27pm

freediver wrote on Sep 17th, 2020 at 6:36pm:
I'll give you a quick lesson in logic Barny, as you have obviously missed the previous 20 or so pages. Neither of these is evidence that the protestors did not spread the virus.


clearly its you who needs lessons in logic. No one is required to prove a negative. I cannot fathom why you continually fall back on this non-logic.


freediver wrote on Sep 17th, 2020 at 6:36pm:
You have not posted this evidence before. Where is it? You have posted other evidence, but you keep running away from this particular claim


The Guardian article I posted was entirely about "tracing the second wave to a specific place and time."

The vast majority of the cases of Covid-19 in Victoria can be traced back to a single family that returned to Australia in mid-May who were kept in hotel quarantine at the Rydges Hotel, an inquiry has heard.

https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2020/aug/18/hotel-quarantine-linked-to-99-of-victorias-covid-cases-inquiry-told

That single case could be linked to an estimated 90% of cases since the end of May. Another 9% could be linked to another Hotel. All there in the article FD.

Read it, I dare you.

And yes, I accept your apology for making me repost things all because you can't be arsed reading the evidence the first 2 or 3 times I post it. What are the odds you'll ignore it this time and come back tomorrow wondering where my evidence is?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by The_Barnacle on Sep 18th, 2020 at 4:05pm

freediver wrote on Sep 17th, 2020 at 6:36pm:

The_Barnacle wrote on Sep 17th, 2020 at 11:37am:
Freediver, how many times do you need to be told?

There is no evidence that the protesters spread the virus
There is plenty of evidence that poor Hotel Quarantine practices spread the virus


I'll give you a quick lesson in logic Barny, as you have obviously missed the previous 20 or so pages. Neither of these is evidence that the protestors did not spread the virus.


I haven't missed the previous 20 pages, it's just that you don't seem to understand that the onus of proof is on you.
It's up to you to provide evidence to support your claim.
You have failed to do so

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Sep 18th, 2020 at 6:32pm

polite_gandalf wrote on Sep 18th, 2020 at 1:27pm:

freediver wrote on Sep 17th, 2020 at 6:36pm:
I'll give you a quick lesson in logic Barny, as you have obviously missed the previous 20 or so pages. Neither of these is evidence that the protestors did not spread the virus.


clearly its you who needs lessons in logic. No one is required to prove a negative. I cannot fathom why you continually fall back on this non-logic.


freediver wrote on Sep 17th, 2020 at 6:36pm:
You have not posted this evidence before. Where is it? You have posted other evidence, but you keep running away from this particular claim


The Guardian article I posted was entirely about "tracing the second wave to a specific place and time."

The vast majority of the cases of Covid-19 in Victoria can be traced back to a single family that returned to Australia in mid-May who were kept in hotel quarantine at the Rydges Hotel, an inquiry has heard.

https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2020/aug/18/hotel-quarantine-linked-to-99-of-victorias-covid-cases-inquiry-told

That single case could be linked to an estimated 90% of cases since the end of May. Another 9% could be linked to another Hotel. All there in the article FD.

Read it, I dare you.

And yes, I accept your apology for making me repost things all because you can't be arsed reading the evidence the first 2 or 3 times I post it. What are the odds you'll ignore it this time and come back tomorrow wondering where my evidence is?


Gandalf this is what you posted:


Quote:
The dummies version is that the strain that caused the second wave can be traced to a specific place and time - which given what and when this place and time actually was, absolutely does mean that the protestors almost certainly didn't spread it.


You have not posted the evidence for this. Where is it? You keep running away from this particular claim, even though it appears to be the crux of your argument and the only claim relevant to the question at hand.

All you have is baseless claims and no evidence. You seem to think both of these answer the question. Neither do. If you really do have the evidence to shut this question down, why are you afraid to post it?

It looks to me like you are merely so gullible that you believe what the Victorian government wants you to believe, without them even having to say it.

As you seem to have forgotten, this is the question: did the protestors spread the virus?


Quote:
I haven't missed the previous 20 pages, it's just that you don't seem to understand that the onus of proof is on you.
It's up to you to provide evidence to support your claim.


What claim?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Sep 18th, 2020 at 6:37pm
Debating with FD.

Good luck everyone.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Sep 18th, 2020 at 6:42pm
You are failing at logic Gandalf. Can you explain why you think that is evidence for the claim you made about the protestors spreading the virus?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Sep 18th, 2020 at 7:02pm

The_Barnacle wrote on Sep 18th, 2020 at 4:05pm:

freediver wrote on Sep 17th, 2020 at 6:36pm:

The_Barnacle wrote on Sep 17th, 2020 at 11:37am:
Freediver, how many times do you need to be told?

There is no evidence that the protesters spread the virus
There is plenty of evidence that poor Hotel Quarantine practices spread the virus


I'll give you a quick lesson in logic Barny, as you have obviously missed the previous 20 or so pages. Neither of these is evidence that the protestors did not spread the virus.


I haven't missed the previous 20 pages, it's just that you don't seem to understand that the onus of proof is on you.
It's up to you to provide evidence to support your claim.
You have failed to do so


In a discussion with FD that opens up by him asking if something, of which there is no evidence for, but which validates his world view happened, it can go one of two ways:

1. you say "yep, you bet!" - in which case you get a gold sticker, go to the top of the class, and join the illustrious ranks of those who 'stick it to the apologists'

2. you point out the simple fact that there is no evidence - in which case you are labelled as someone who equates absense of evidence with evidence of absense, and haughtily told you haven't proven it didn't happen - so there! - followed by 15 pages of endless waffling and deflection.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Sep 18th, 2020 at 7:23pm

Quote:
you point out the simple fact that there is no evidence


Have you changed your mind Gandalf?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Sep 18th, 2020 at 7:36pm

freediver wrote on Sep 18th, 2020 at 6:42pm:
You are failing at logic Gandalf. Can you explain why you think that is evidence for the claim you made about the protestors spreading the virus?


Little by little FD eventually reveals what the hell he is actually on about. I thought you were whinging about my claim about the origin and time of the start of the outbreak. If you meant the third claim about the protestors spreading the virus - why didn't you just say it in the first place? Why are you always so damned cryptic?

And to clarify, by "spread" I was talking about what was the origin of this second wave. Yes, it is conceivable that individual transmissions occurred between protestors at the protest, and the fact that the second wave started in hotel quarantine does not preclude the possibility of such individual transmissions. We just don't have any evidence that this happened. But we do have evidence that it was spread by people and gatherings that had nothing to do with the protest - such as at an abbattoirs and a school.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Sep 18th, 2020 at 7:46pm
How you could possibly be confused about what "spreading the virus" means?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Sep 18th, 2020 at 7:56pm
How could you possibly object to the answer "there is no evidence" to the question "did the protestors spread the virus"?

How could you possibly accuse someone who gave that answer as equating absense of evidence with evidence of absense - with a straight face?

How could you possibly think that responding with "you haven't proven that it didn't happen" could ever be valid?

I wouldn't be pointing to any one elses lack of logic in this thread if I were you FD.


Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Sep 18th, 2020 at 8:00pm

Quote:
How could you possibly accuse someone who gave that answer as equating absense of evidence with evidence of absense - with a straight face?


That's what you did. Though I realise now this may be due to you not understanding what I meant by "did the protestors spread the virus". Did you think I was asking whether the protestors brought it into the country from overseas?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Sep 18th, 2020 at 9:21pm
actually, it was you who tried to justify the claim by bringing up the figures of the start of the second wave - as if those very first infections were caused by the protest - when we know now they came from other clusters not related to the protests. This was pointed out to you at the time. Still you talked about incubation rates, and the sudden spike in cases after the 5 day mark after the protests (the very spike that signified the start of the second wave). Then you came out with that graph showing the time of the second wave in relation to the protest - apparently thinking that proved something. Its not as if you ever acknowledged that the second wave was started because non-protest clusters - you've never stopped pushing the 'BLM caused the second wave' barrow. Interestingly, you also seemed keen to talk up an apparent second wave in Sydney - presumably because of the BLM protests there. I'm not sure how the non-eventuation of this second wave fits in to your world view.

Not once have you qualified your question with a "...even if/though the cause of the second wave had nothing to do wtih the protests". In fact you've been implying the exact opposite throughout the thread. You are being dishonest and disingeuous pretending this was never the main issue. You yourself established the perameters of the debate in your first few posts. But now you would have us believe you were asking a question that need not have been about any noticeable or meaningful impact on the second wave. Yeah right.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by J.D. on Sep 18th, 2020 at 9:57pm
There could well be a link between all the black security guards which is most of them and the BLM BS, its not like any of those guards have to tell the authorities if they went to the BLM riots so why would they.

The Blacks turned out in their tens of thousands protesting in a pandemic.

We don't like them kind around here.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Sep 18th, 2020 at 10:14pm

Quote:
actually, it was you who tried to justify the claim by bringing up the figures of the start of the second wave - as if those very first infections were caused by the protest - when we know now they came from other clusters not related to the protests.


How do you know this?


Quote:
you've never stopped pushing the 'BLM caused the second wave' barrow


Can you quote me?


Quote:
Not once have you qualified your question


Why does a question need to be qualified?


Quote:
even if/though the cause of the second wave had nothing to do wtih the protests


What does that even mean?


Quote:
You are being dishonest and disingeuous pretending this was never the main issue.


What are you talking about Gandalf?


Quote:
You yourself established the perameters of the debate in your first few posts. But now you would have us believe you were asking a question that need not have been about any noticeable or meaningful impact on the second wave. Yeah right.


The question is in the thread title. Did the protesters spread the virus? What exactly is your issue with that?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Sep 18th, 2020 at 10:18pm

polite_gandalf wrote on Sep 14th, 2020 at 6:39pm:

freediver wrote on Sep 14th, 2020 at 6:20pm:
The virus came from China Gandalf. We know that. But it does not mean the protestors did not spread it.


Never mind FD. The point obviously went straight over your head. Next time it might help if you actually read what I'm talking about. The dummies version is that the strain that caused the second wave can be traced to a specific place and time - which given what and when this place and time actually was, absolutely does mean that the protestors almost certainly didn't spread it. But of course you would have understood this if you actually read what I was talking about.


Gandalf given that you were quoting me pointing out the difference between spreading the virus and the original source, and you yourself made the distinction between spreading the virus and tracing a common origin, how did you come to confuse spreading the virus with identifying a single common origin? Were you trying to talk in circles? I am reading what you actually posted, and it makes no sense at all. I have been quoting this back at you for 4 days, so it's not like you forgot what I was asking you about.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by JaSin. on Sep 18th, 2020 at 10:35pm
Gandalf    v     Freediver


gotta be the best long running stoushes on the Forum.  ;D

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by JaSin. on Sep 18th, 2020 at 11:32pm
A Virus designed by Greta to cull the over-population and bring down the over-indulgent economies.

We live in a great era!
The world will be saved!

An era where the children will say "Where have all the old people and adults gone?"

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Sep 21st, 2020 at 10:58am

freediver wrote on Sep 18th, 2020 at 10:14pm:
Can you quote me?


Your opening post. You were pointing out an apparent jump in the number of cases at a time which would be consistent with incubation after the protests. In plain English: You tried to link the sudden spike in cases that marked the start of the second wave to the protests.

I merely point out this is BS - since we now know where those infections came from - and it wasn't from the protest. (see the two article I keep referencing that you never read). As it turns out, you were being told at the time on this thread that almost all those infections were non-protest related, with just a tiny number of "unknown origin" (and I'm pretty sure even those have since been tracked down too to non-protest related origin). News articles saying this were quoted to you.


Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by polite_gandalf on Sep 21st, 2020 at 12:03pm

freediver wrote on Sep 18th, 2020 at 10:18pm:

polite_gandalf wrote on Sep 14th, 2020 at 6:39pm:

freediver wrote on Sep 14th, 2020 at 6:20pm:
The virus came from China Gandalf. We know that. But it does not mean the protestors did not spread it.


Never mind FD. The point obviously went straight over your head. Next time it might help if you actually read what I'm talking about. The dummies version is that the strain that caused the second wave can be traced to a specific place and time - which given what and when this place and time actually was, absolutely does mean that the protestors almost certainly didn't spread it. But of course you would have understood this if you actually read what I was talking about.


Gandalf given that you were quoting me pointing out the difference between spreading the virus and the original source, and you yourself made the distinction between spreading the virus and tracing a common origin, how did you come to confuse spreading the virus with identifying a single common origin? Were you trying to talk in circles? I am reading what you actually posted, and it makes no sense at all. I have been quoting this back at you for 4 days, so it's not like you forgot what I was asking you about.


Because in this case at least, the "origins" of the outbreak leads us directly to how it "spread" - since we then can trace the where, who and how of those individuals that comprised the first jump in cases that you documented in the OP. Especially when it was you who brought up the matter of how those initial infections were caused. Its not as if you entertained any sort of notion that the "genie was already out" at the time of the protests - especially given the numbers we were talking about were tiny - still under 20.

As for the sentence that I quoted, it was a stupid throw-away comment, that only demonstrates how disingenuous you are being in regards to what pieces of information are important for understanding how an outbreak actually started. If a protester gets infected by another protester, that virus did not "come from China" - anymore than when I catch the common cold the virus "came from Europe" 200 years earlier. Needless to say, when scientists are trying to find the origins of a particular outbreak to see exactly how it spread, telling them "hey, it came from China" like a grinning idiot, is rather less than helpful.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Sep 21st, 2020 at 12:16pm

polite_gandalf wrote on Sep 21st, 2020 at 12:03pm:

freediver wrote on Sep 18th, 2020 at 10:18pm:

polite_gandalf wrote on Sep 14th, 2020 at 6:39pm:

freediver wrote on Sep 14th, 2020 at 6:20pm:
The virus came from China Gandalf. We know that. But it does not mean the protestors did not spread it.


Never mind FD. The point obviously went straight over your head. Next time it might help if you actually read what I'm talking about. The dummies version is that the strain that caused the second wave can be traced to a specific place and time - which given what and when this place and time actually was, absolutely does mean that the protestors almost certainly didn't spread it. But of course you would have understood this if you actually read what I was talking about.


Gandalf given that you were quoting me pointing out the difference between spreading the virus and the original source, and you yourself made the distinction between spreading the virus and tracing a common origin, how did you come to confuse spreading the virus with identifying a single common origin? Were you trying to talk in circles? I am reading what you actually posted, and it makes no sense at all. I have been quoting this back at you for 4 days, so it's not like you forgot what I was asking you about.


Because in this case at least, the "origins" of the outbreak leads us directly to how it "spread" - since we then can trace the where, who and how of those individuals that comprised the first jump in cases that you documented in the OP. Especially when it was you who brought up the matter of how those initial infections were caused. Its not as if you entertained any sort of notion that the "genie was already out" at the time of the protests - especially given the numbers we were talking about were tiny - still under 20.

As for the sentence that I quoted, it was a stupid throw-away comment, that only demonstrates how disingenuous you are being in regards to what pieces of information are important for understanding how an outbreak actually started. If a protester gets infected by another protester, that virus did not "come from China" - anymore than when I catch the common cold the virus "came from Europe" 200 years earlier. Needless to say, when scientists are trying to find the origins of a particular outbreak to see exactly how it spread, telling them "hey, it came from China" like a grinning idiot, is rather less than helpful.


When you say "spread", do you mean spread?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Oct 7th, 2020 at 6:27pm
Is anyone else still under the mistaken belief that Dan has proven that the protestors did not spread the virus?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by The_Barnacle on Oct 9th, 2020 at 6:02am

freediver wrote on Oct 7th, 2020 at 6:27pm:
Is anyone else still under the mistaken belief that Dan has proven that the protestors did not spread the virus?


Is there any proof that they did?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Bam on Oct 9th, 2020 at 10:05am
It does no harm to ask whether protesters may have spread the virus.

September 20 - Maskless "Freedom day" protesters gather at Chadstone Shopping Centre.
October 2 - A coronavirus cluster at Chadstone Shopping Centre grows to 11.


Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by The_Barnacle on Oct 9th, 2020 at 2:19pm

Bam wrote on Oct 9th, 2020 at 10:05am:
It does no harm to ask whether protesters may have spread the virus.

September 20 - Maskless "Freedom day" protesters gather at Chadstone Shopping Centre.
October 2 - A coronavirus cluster at Chadstone Shopping Centre grows to 11.


Exactly

Freediver is committing an "appeal to possibility" fallacy

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Oct 9th, 2020 at 7:27pm

The_Barnacle wrote on Oct 9th, 2020 at 6:02am:

freediver wrote on Oct 7th, 2020 at 6:27pm:
Is anyone else still under the mistaken belief that Dan has proven that the protestors did not spread the virus?


Is there any proof that they did?


Who knows? All we know is, Dan is not providing any evidence either way.

Which makes sense of course. A stuff-up in quarantine hotels is exactly the sort of incompetence you would expect from the government. Yet micromanaging people's lives to the nth degree for months on end, then permitting a huge protest that (quite predictably) spread a second wave, tanked the economy, and killed thousands of Australians is the sort of colossal stupidity that gets governments turfed out of office.

Yet Gandalf expects us to believe that the government trying to shift the blame to the hotels as much as possible proves they can be trusted.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Oct 16th, 2020 at 6:36pm
Barnacle are you still under the mistaken belief that Dan has proven that the protestors did not spread the virus?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by John Smith on Oct 16th, 2020 at 6:41pm

freediver wrote on Oct 16th, 2020 at 6:36pm:
Barnacle are you still under the mistaken belief that Dan has proven that the protestors did not spread the virus?


FD are you under the mistaken impression that you have proven they did spread the virus?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by The_Barnacle on Oct 17th, 2020 at 11:44am

freediver wrote on Oct 16th, 2020 at 6:36pm:
Barnacle are you still under the mistaken belief that Dan has proven that the protestors did not spread the virus?


Dan doesn't have to, the burden of proof is on you freediver

Although the fact that you just can't seem to let this go says more about you

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Oct 17th, 2020 at 11:57am

Quote:
Dan doesn't have to, the burden of proof is on you freediver


Why is that?

And what do you think I need to prove?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by The_Barnacle on Oct 17th, 2020 at 12:11pm

freediver wrote on Oct 17th, 2020 at 11:57am:

Quote:
Dan doesn't have to, the burden of proof is on you freediver


Why is that?

And what do you think I need to prove?


Because if you want to claim that the BLM protests spread the virus, you have to provide evidence to back up that claim.
And using an "appeal to possibility" fallacy doesn't cut it.

There have been pages of evidence that the virus was spread by security guards at the quarantine hotels and you have provided ZERO evidence that it was spread at the BLM protests. But you ignore this and continue your "appeal to possibility" fallacy.

And then you just refuse to let it go, and every few weeks start beating the dead horse again
very odd 

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Oct 17th, 2020 at 12:22pm

Quote:
There have been pages of evidence that the virus was spread by security guards at the quarantine hotels and you have provided ZERO evidence that it was spread at the BLM protests. But you ignore this and continue your "appeal to possibility" fallacy.


Can you quote me?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by The_Barnacle on Oct 17th, 2020 at 12:41pm

freediver wrote on Oct 17th, 2020 at 12:22pm:

Quote:
There have been pages of evidence that the virus was spread by security guards at the quarantine hotels and you have provided ZERO evidence that it was spread at the BLM protests. But you ignore this and continue your "appeal to possibility" fallacy.


Can you quote me?



freediver wrote on Jul 12th, 2020 at 7:46am:
I have not seen anything to suggest they would even know if the protest was the source. All the new cases must have come from somewhere. It doesn't just spontaneously appear at a family gathering.


I think you are using lee's debating tactic. Not actually having a position on anything but merely trying to discredit anything that opposes your ideology. 
It's called sea-lioning and it's a very dishonest form of debate

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Oct 17th, 2020 at 2:14pm

The_Barnacle wrote on Oct 17th, 2020 at 12:41pm:

freediver wrote on Oct 17th, 2020 at 12:22pm:

Quote:
There have been pages of evidence that the virus was spread by security guards at the quarantine hotels and you have provided ZERO evidence that it was spread at the BLM protests. But you ignore this and continue your "appeal to possibility" fallacy.


Can you quote me?



freediver wrote on Jul 12th, 2020 at 7:46am:
I have not seen anything to suggest they would even know if the protest was the source. All the new cases must have come from somewhere. It doesn't just spontaneously appear at a family gathering.


I think you are using lee's debating tactic. Not actually having a position on anything but merely trying to discredit anything that opposes your ideology. 
It's called sea-lioning and it's a very dishonest form of debate


Why is it dishonest to not have a position when faced with the withholding of evidence?

Also, are you claiming that that is an example of your so-called "appeal to possibility fallacy," or are you changing your mind?

The only thing I am trying to discredit here are the lies from those (and there are many of them) who claim that the Victorian government has somehow proven that the protestors did not spread the virus. Do you think that is dishonest?

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by Ye Grappler on Oct 17th, 2020 at 3:27pm
Eureka Moment - protestors didn't spread it, someone gave it to them beforehand so it's not the fault of protestors for spreading it to others at protests......

Sure I recall that vapid comment somewhere in this discussion....

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Oct 17th, 2020 at 3:32pm

Sir Grappler Truth Teller OAM wrote on Oct 17th, 2020 at 3:27pm:
Eureka Moment - protestors didn't spread it, someone gave it to them beforehand so it's not the fault of protestors for spreading it to others at protests......

Sure I recall that vapid comment somewhere in this discussion....


Gandalf has backpedaled himself into that position, with all the grace and subtlety of a scuba diver on a mountain top.

Title: Re: did the protestors spread the virus?
Post by freediver on Dec 12th, 2020 at 10:50am

John Smith wrote on Oct 16th, 2020 at 6:41pm:

freediver wrote on Oct 16th, 2020 at 6:36pm:
Barnacle are you still under the mistaken belief that Dan has proven that the protestors did not spread the virus?


FD are you under the mistaken impression that you have proven they did spread the virus?


It's a bit hard to prove anything when Dan is hiding all the evidence.

Australian Politics Forum » Powered by YaBB 2.5.2!
YaBB Forum Software © 2000-2025. All Rights Reserved.