Because Booby does not like slurs of his boyfriend, tho he is more than happy to slur others.

The lies of David DuByne

1. Denied Booby gave him my details that IQ gave him in the first place. The person who gave Booby my details then set up a Twitter account in my full name and made some posts, one a threatening one that they would use my name to doxx my address in Tasmania. Charming place, the sewer. Got rid of that one and another account using my name was created.œ

2. Made a YouTube predicting that the NW Passage would be full of thick ice the following summer. That summer a cruise ship sailed the NW Passage without needing the accompanying ice breaker. Dubyne’s response—admit error? Nope the lousy prick pulled the YouTube where he made his prediction! Laff!

3. Used to say (can’t say it this year) frequently that Arctic sea ice was getting thicker or that it was growing—Arctic ice has been in decline since the 1970s!

4. I think late 2017 made a joke about the Arctic not having warmed in the NH winter. It had. Forgetting that—he really is not very bright—he then, couple months later, posted “Arctic temperatures had recovered.” Recovered from what? He had lied about the Arctic not warming! What a dumbarse, can’t keep his lies straight!

5. Talking about being a dumbarse, he said, couple months ago, that the heatwave in Paris (was heatwave in most of Europe not just Paris or France) was not real because the thermometer was on a “ceramic roof.” That “thermometer” was a rain gauge! Dubyne does not care about the truth or he could have done what someone on Twitter did, Google the Paris weather station then used Google Earth to find it—in a park. But, hey, DuByne, could make the mentally subnormal who follow him happy for a day, donating and watching his monetised videos.

6. More lies—the cretin claimed the European heat wave, the huge melt on Greenland and record low Arctic sea ice “were not signficant.” What a lie! Holland got to over 40°C for the first time, got to 18°C in February—deepest winter. This is significant, of course. How braindead do you have to be to believe Dubyne? 99%?

7. A recurring theme in his lying videos—crops have failed. Couple years ago “The Australian wheat harvest has failed because of late start in planting and a cold winter.” Couple minutes searching—Australian wheat harvest was above average and the winter, as winters here have been, was warm! Year before was a bumper crop, that year definitely above average.

8. That theme resurfaced this year: parts of the MidWest were cold (not global cold, just local) and flooded and DuByne has been raving on at record speed:

8.1. Bare shelves planet wide. I showed that was a lie

8.2. Corn prices were rising rapidly—somebody showed corn prices were normal.

8.3. The USDA was lying about the extent of the problem, there would be famine blah blah blah. Nah, forecasts show a good corn crop likely, wheat down a tad (probably the drought in NSW.)

These were very dangerous lies but, hey, if more people bought his “survival food” everything was fine for DuByne! If they also donated and watched his monetised lying videos even better for Davo the Liar!

Fact is, the world is warming at the fastest rate in geological history, faster than the Permian-Triassic extinction event.
https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-49086783



https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EDnwuEFWsAAE9_9?format=png&name=360x360

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EDuofkcXsAMwQYh?format=jpg&name=360x360


Previous thread on Dubyne and Booby’s lies:
http://www.ozpolitic.com/forum/YaBB.pl?num=1421385253/4305

Note how Booby could not answer any of the accusations against liar Dubyne? He could noyt answer mine either, so deleted them!

Dubyne often talks of lots of hail and big hailstones as proof of his imaginary GSM and ice age.

Hail is ice, true enough. But where it the ice formed? Way up high in the troposphere. Thermals in thunderstorms send moist air up high where it cools, condenses, freezes, accretes more ice then falls, accreting more ice, merging with adjacent hail stones until it forms below cloud level.

The higher the moist air is sent the longer it has to fall and so the bigger the hailstones become.

AGW warms the surface and so boosts the thermals in thunderstorms so the hail forms higher up and so grows more before reaching cloud level.

A child could work this out. Dubyne (apparently) and Booby (definitely) are too stupid to work it out. Look at the recent record:

Dec 2018 in Sydney: tennis ball sized hail

Mexico Jul 2019: so much hail fell in the mountains that when the hail slid into the village below it looked like snow!

Jul-Aug 2019 in France, Spain and Italy: orange-sized hail fell—during or just after the heatwave there, note, not during cold. Intense thunderstorms fed by warm surface: if we were cooling there would be little hail and the hailstones woud be a few mm across.

Frequent hail and large hailstones a definite consequence of warming.

And another lie:

He has claimed that the current stratospheric warming event was a result of GSM (it isn't) and here are my findings from the last one:

The last stratospheric sudden warming event occured in 2002 - this was during a solar PEAK of over 150-180 sunspots during cycle 23. Absolutely no correlation to solar minimum.


(from @Adapt20301 which is not me. A parody account as is allowed by Twitter. Twitter is a marvellous forum, you meet experts there in many fields and you can ask them questions and they answer! I talked to a Dutch meteorologist there about the 41.6°C temperature reading in Holland: that was not officially recognised but a reading that was recognised(reliable) was 40.7 first Dutch temperature over 40°C, that heat waves had been occurring in Holland etc. Interesting.

Of course you also meet liars and grifters (like Dubyne) but you can block them.

And again (from @Adapt2030)

And again:

He claimed the current drought in Australia is a result of the GSM. We know it isn't and here are my findings on the last significant droughts:

The last major drought happened between 1996 -2010, this occured during both solar peaks and lows during solar cycle 22, 23 &24.

Before that there was the QLD drought during 1990-1995, which was during solar maximums (sunspots were recorded over 230 at some points) and this was during solar cycle 22.

Again, no correlation to low solar output


And (in relation to another lie by Dubyne about snow depths at Spencers Creek.)

http://www.ozpolitic.com/album/forum-attachments/Snow_depths_Spencers_Crk.png

Copy of a post by @Adapt20301 that Booby deleted but could not refute, did not even try to refute—how weak is that?


quote author=Adapt20301 link=1568435498/22#22 date=1568496871]
So I'm Adapt20301 on twitter and debunk David's BS about Australia.

You said - where does be mention 60+ years? Go to timestamp 4:41-4:47 in the video and he says, and I quote: "a feat that has only happened 3 times in the last 65yrs".

He is Wrong.

The chart posted? Well that's my own research from the snowy hydro website which can be used by anyone  go to the website - choose the year and find the peak snow depth over 2m in spring. It's simple.

The claims he made about snow level above 2m from only 3 years since 2000? Wrong.

The fact is this - Dubyne lies blatantly and when I see it I call him out on it. Hence creating my amazing Twitter account. He does absolutely no research and posts garbage that other people "find". And when confronted with the actual truth? Oh well, that's just ignored. [/quote]
:(
See? Even new members despise Booby and laugh at the idea of an ice age any time soon.

Yup, dubyne is copying material from other Tweeters and denier blogs. Electroverse net, another grifter posts dubious (at least, outright rubbish mostly) “news” that Dubyne just copies—too lazy, too stupid to do his own research.

So I recreated my posts that Booby deleted from the Dubyne MRB rather than try to argue the information I put up.

We are warming and in another thread here I spell out some dangerous consequences—flooding, huge hail etc. Much more warming and you can say goodbye to wheat. You can try to move agriculture further polewards—certainly the permafrost is thawing out rapidly, another consequence of AGW—but long hot summer days at high latitudes will not be pleasant for people, cattle or crops!

Better get CSIRO to breeding much more heat tolerant wheat, barley and rye! Rice is already losing nutrient content thanks to rising CO2.

I told that loser Booby I would reinstate these posts here if he deleted them from the Dubyne MRB. I am fully justified now in posting science, including AGW science, here and not in his Dubyne Adoration Society.

Booby made not ONE attempt to refute anything I said, the lies by Dubyne that I pointed out. Not ONE attempt. How pissweak is that?

Youre a regular one man army Monk 8-)

From the original thread -

A list posted by Monk with no source and manufactured
in Photoshop with Monk's writing.
http://www.ozpolitic.com/album/forum-attachments/Snow_depths_Spencers_Crk.png


I thought I'd investigate one of Monk's claims at random
and I tore it to pieces.



http://www.ozpolitic.com/forum/YaBB.pl?num=1464603949/6135#6135

The above  news got a mention on the latest Adapt2030 video:

Jump to 4:08

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S8bcAm6DTog

He says "only 3 of the last 20 years have seen this much snow."

Where is the mention of 60 years?
Where did Monk's list come from - no link.

In other words - Monk has lied.

I only checked one of Monk's claims and it's a lie.
The source article which I used and David quoted was  here:
https://www.weatherzone.com.au/news/australian-snow-depth-update/530176

It says
"Only three of the last 20 years have seen this much snow measured at Spencers Creek during spring.
These were in 2019, 2017 and 2000."


Therefore - Monk is a liar.

hey goober, who's the bitch in your relationship, you or DeByne?

@Adapt20301 posted details of Dubyne’s lying claim and the Snowy Mts website he got the truth from.

John Smith wrote on Sep 16^th, 2019 at 4:26pm:

hey goober, who's the bitch in your relationship, you or DeByne?

why so mean?

Bobby. wrote on Sep 16^th, 2019 at 3:18pm:

From the original thread - A list posted by Monk with no source and manufactured in Photoshop with Monk's writing. I thought I'd investigate one of Monk's claims at random and I tore it to pieces. The above  news got a mention on the latest Adapt2030 video: Jump to 4:08 He says "only 3 of the last 20 years have seen this much snow." Where is the mention of 60 years? Where did Monk's list come from - no link. In other words - Monk has lied. I only checked one of Monk's claims and it's a lie. The source article which I used and David quoted was  here: It says "Only three of the last 20 years have seen this much snow measured at Spencers Creek during spring. These were in 2019, 2017 and 2000." Therefore - Monk is a liar.

I am the author of the chart that Monk has shown, I sent it to him over Twitter and am also the owner of "adapt20301" on twitter - debunking Davids' BS.

You said - where does be mention 60+ years? Go to timestamp 4:41-4:47 in the video and he says, and I quote: "a feat that has only happened 3 times in the last 65yrs".

This is blatantly wrong.

The chart I pulled together was taken from the Snowy Hydro Depth Measurement Website, anyone can visit it and see that the spring snowfall is not at all unique, not at all related to GSM and not at all noteworthy.

Oh and for the record, that graph was done on my phone lol. Not photoshop. Why would anyone create that in photoshop? Do you even know what it is for?

Booby is just not that bright.

Bobby. wrote on Sep 16^th, 2019 at 3:18pm:

From the original thread - A list posted by Monk with no source and manufactured in Photoshop with Monk's writing. I thought I'd investigate one of Monk's claims at random and I tore it to pieces. The above  news got a mention on the latest Adapt2030 video: Jump to 4:08 He says "only 3 of the last 20 years have seen this much snow." Where is the mention of 60 years? Where did Monk's list come from - no link. In other words - Monk has lied. I only checked one of Monk's claims and it's a lie. The source article which I used and David quoted was  here: It says "Only three of the last 20 years have seen this much snow measured at Spencers Creek during spring. These were in 2019, 2017 and 2000." Therefore - Monk is a liar.

Also - you asked where the data came from for my research into major droughts in Australia:

The last major drought happened between 1996 -2010, this occured during both solar peaks and lows during solar cycle 22, 23 &24.

Before that there was the QLD drought during 1990-1995, which was during solar maximums (sunspots were recorded over 230 at some points) and this was during solar cycle 22.

Again, no correlation to low solar output

The solar output data can be found from the spaceweatherlive website, a commonly quoted source from Dubyne.

Research into our major droughts can be found via simple google search. I also see you live in Melbourne, you would no doubt know of our major drought we had in the late 2000's and early 2010's - you would also note that this did not correspond to any solar lows.

DDD said:

Quote:

I also see you live in Melbourne, you would no doubt know of our major drought we had in the late 2000's and early 2010's - you would also note that this did not correspond to any solar lows.

You don’t think Booby is bright enough to think of that all by himself do you?

Jovial Monk wrote on Sep 17^th, 2019 at 2:38pm:

DDD said: Quote: I also see you live in Melbourne, you would no doubt know of our major drought we had in the late 2000's and early 2010's - you would also note that this did not correspond to any solar lows. You don’t think Booby is bright enough to think of that all by himself do you?

Based on what I have seen so far? Not in the least.

I find it rather ironic that the "environment" subforum is run by someone who has:
An agenda;
A willingness to silence anyone that disagrees with his world view;
Prefers to belittle rather than debate.

What a fun place this is!

I know. If Booby was made Mod of Fringe and his ice age nonsense was moved there then someone sensible could return what was the Environment board back to what it was. That would see more posts which results in more ad revenue for the owner of this dump.

Debunking David Dubyne wrote on Sep 17^th, 2019 at 7:58pm:

What a fun place this is!

you haven't seen anything yet. Wait until you see the forum owner attack gays or call for the raping of women with a cactus :D :D


welcome

Debunking David Dubyne wrote on Sep 17^th, 2019 at 1:19pm:

Bobby. wrote on Sep 16th, 2019 at 3:18pm: From the original thread - A list posted by Monk with no source and manufactured in Photoshop with Monk's writing. I thought I'd investigate one of Monk's claims at random and I tore it to pieces. The above  news got a mention on the latest Adapt2030 video: Jump to 4:08 He says "only 3 of the last 20 years have seen this much snow." Where is the mention of 60 years? Where did Monk's list come from - no link. In other words - Monk has lied. I only checked one of Monk's claims and it's a lie. The source article which I used and David quoted was  here: It says "Only three of the last 20 years have seen this much snow measured at Spencers Creek during spring. These were in 2019, 2017 and 2000." Therefore - Monk is a liar. I am the author of the chart that Monk has shown, I sent it to him over Twitter and am also the owner of "adapt20301" on twitter - debunking Davids' BS. You said - where does be mention 60+ years? Go to timestamp 4:41-4:47 in the video and he says, and I quote: "a feat that has only happened 3 times in the last 65yrs". This is blatantly wrong. The chart I pulled together was taken from the Snowy Hydro Depth Measurement Website, anyone can visit it and see that the spring snowfall is not at all unique, not at all related to GSM and not at all noteworthy. Oh and for the record, that graph was done on my phone lol. Not photoshop. Why would anyone create that in photoshop? Do you even know what it is for?

Hi DDD,
That's the problem.
The video is here:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S8bcAm6DTog

timestamp 4:41-4:47  is not exactly what Monk said.
Monk never gave the time stamp info.
I was forced to try & find what he meant.
The info read out by David DuByne was from John Clarkson -
I don't know who he is.
You manufactured a list of events on your phone -
I don't know who you are -
I had no way of checking that.
So - I quite rightly debunked what Monk was writing.
Monk is a raving lunatic who doesn't source any info with links -
that's all I was asking him to do.
I gave him 24 hours & he couldn't supply a single link to back up his ravings so
I hid the thread.
Let's hope you'll do better?

here is the site for DDD
https://twitter.com/adapt20301?lang=en

Dubyne tells lies.

His “evidence” for the non-existent “global cooling” is . . . local weather. No science. He also lies a LOT.

Globe is warming and there is no GSM for quite a while!

When a GSM does happen it will cool by 0.2°C maximum. That is not enough to cause an ice age.

While you have been boring 99% of OzPol, who have stopped reading your junk, Arctic, Greenland and Antarctic ice has been melting and the globe warming. Remember last summer? Record heat over all the continent! Holland got to over 40°C! And had 18°C days in February!

Jovial Monk wrote on Sep 18^th, 2019 at 5:02am:

Dubyne tells lies. His “evidence” for the non-existent “global cooling” is . . . local weather. No science. He also lies a LOT. Globe is warming and there is no GSM for quite a while! When a GSM does happen it will cool by 0.2°C maximum. That is not enough to cause an ice age. While you have been boring 99% of OzPol, who have stopped reading your junk, Arctic, Greenland and Antarctic ice has been melting and the globe warming. Remember last summer? Record heat over all the continent! Holland got to over 40°C! And had 18°C days in February!

Supply links you raving drunken lunatic.

I have provided the links you cretin.

Jovial Monk wrote on Sep 18^th, 2019 at 5:07am:

I have provided the links you cretin.

At least DDD tried to explain your ravings so I un-hid the thread:
http://www.ozpolitic.com/forum/YaBB.pl?num=1568435498/45#53

David Dubyne Debunked explained his info re snow. He showed your boyfriend LIED about snow cover.

John Clarkson is a truck driver, an opinionated fool spouting crap. Your boyfriend then puts that lying crap in one of his lying crap videos.

Bobby. wrote on Sep 18^th, 2019 at 4:54am:

Debunking David Dubyne wrote on Sep 17th, 2019 at 1:19pm: Bobby. wrote on Sep 16th, 2019 at 3:18pm: From the original thread - A list posted by Monk with no source and manufactured in Photoshop with Monk's writing. I thought I'd investigate one of Monk's claims at random and I tore it to pieces. The above  news got a mention on the latest Adapt2030 video: Jump to 4:08 He says "only 3 of the last 20 years have seen this much snow." Where is the mention of 60 years? Where did Monk's list come from - no link. In other words - Monk has lied. I only checked one of Monk's claims and it's a lie. The source article which I used and David quoted was  here: It says "Only three of the last 20 years have seen this much snow measured at Spencers Creek during spring. These were in 2019, 2017 and 2000." Therefore - Monk is a liar. I am the author of the chart that Monk has shown, I sent it to him over Twitter and am also the owner of "adapt20301" on twitter - debunking Davids' BS. You said - where does be mention 60+ years? Go to timestamp 4:41-4:47 in the video and he says, and I quote: "a feat that has only happened 3 times in the last 65yrs". This is blatantly wrong. The chart I pulled together was taken from the Snowy Hydro Depth Measurement Website, anyone can visit it and see that the spring snowfall is not at all unique, not at all related to GSM and not at all noteworthy. Oh and for the record, that graph was done on my phone lol. Not photoshop. Why would anyone create that in photoshop? Do you even know what it is for? Hi DDD, That's the problem. The video is here: timestamp 4:41-4:47  is not exactly what Monk said. Monk never gave the time stamp info. I was forced to try & find what he meant. The info read out by David DuByne was from John Clarkson - I don't know who he is. You manufactured a list of events on your phone - I don't know who you are - I had no way of checking that. So - I quite rightly debunked what Monk was writing. Monk is a raving lunatic who doesn't source any info with links - that's all I was asking him to do. I gave him 24 hours & he couldn't supply a single link to back up his ravings so I hid the thread. Let's hope you'll do better? here is the site for DDD

You said Dubyne did not say "a feat that has only happened 3 times in the last 65yrs" - which is plainly false, perhaps turn on closed captions if you are hard of hearing. Now the fact that Dubyne quoted another source does not expunge him from fact checking his sources, which as shown were false.

I explained to you where the spring snow depths were taken from, why do you ignore it? Because you can't accept it was being true?

As I said - Visit the Snowyhydro Snowdepth Website and look at the years quoted. I'd link them for you however as a new member I cannot post URLS apparently...

Attached is a screenshot of one year I mentioned.

---

He still won’t accept that Dubyne plain lied.

The items I mentioned have all been discussed before, Booby’s silly Ice Age thread is 250 pages long, I was not going to hunt for the links! I always give links to scientific papers I quote, Booby has not read a single one, of course, prefers YouTubes to reading!

Yes, not easy reading scientific papers but not trying is just a copout.

Debunking David Dubyne wrote on Sep 18^th, 2019 at 7:47am:

Bobby. wrote on Sep 18th, 2019 at 4:54am: Debunking David Dubyne wrote on Sep 17th, 2019 at 1:19pm: Bobby. wrote on Sep 16th, 2019 at 3:18pm: From the original thread - A list posted by Monk with no source and manufactured in Photoshop with Monk's writing. I thought I'd investigate one of Monk's claims at random and I tore it to pieces. The above  news got a mention on the latest Adapt2030 video: Jump to 4:08 He says "only 3 of the last 20 years have seen this much snow." Where is the mention of 60 years? Where did Monk's list come from - no link. In other words - Monk has lied. I only checked one of Monk's claims and it's a lie. The source article which I used and David quoted was  here: It says "Only three of the last 20 years have seen this much snow measured at Spencers Creek during spring. These were in 2019, 2017 and 2000." Therefore - Monk is a liar. I am the author of the chart that Monk has shown, I sent it to him over Twitter and am also the owner of "adapt20301" on twitter - debunking Davids' BS. You said - where does be mention 60+ years? Go to timestamp 4:41-4:47 in the video and he says, and I quote: "a feat that has only happened 3 times in the last 65yrs". This is blatantly wrong. The chart I pulled together was taken from the Snowy Hydro Depth Measurement Website, anyone can visit it and see that the spring snowfall is not at all unique, not at all related to GSM and not at all noteworthy. Oh and for the record, that graph was done on my phone lol. Not photoshop. Why would anyone create that in photoshop? Do you even know what it is for? Hi DDD, That's the problem. The video is here: timestamp 4:41-4:47  is not exactly what Monk said. Monk never gave the time stamp info. I was forced to try & find what he meant. The info read out by David DuByne was from John Clarkson - I don't know who he is. You manufactured a list of events on your phone - I don't know who you are - I had no way of checking that. So - I quite rightly debunked what Monk was writing. Monk is a raving lunatic who doesn't source any info with links - that's all I was asking him to do. I gave him 24 hours & he couldn't supply a single link to back up his ravings so I hid the thread. Let's hope you'll do better? here is the site for DDD You said Dubyne did not say "a feat that has only happened 3 times in the last 65yrs" - which is plainly false, perhaps turn on closed captions if you are hard of hearing. Now the fact that Dubyne quoted another source does not expunge him from fact checking his sources, which as shown were false. I explained to you where the spring snow depths were taken from, why do you ignore it? Because you can't accept it was being true? As I said - Visit the Snowyhydro Snowdepth Website and look at the years quoted. I'd link them for you however as a new member I cannot post URLS apparently... Attached is a screenshot of one year I mentioned.

Doesn't look like your manufactured graph:

http://www.ozpolitic.com/album/forum-attachments/Snow_depths_Spencers_Crk.png

Post it in the environment forum not here.

Bobby. wrote on Sep 18^th, 2019 at 8:16am:

Debunking David Dubyne wrote on Sep 18th, 2019 at 7:47am: Bobby. wrote on Sep 18th, 2019 at 4:54am: Debunking David Dubyne wrote on Sep 17th, 2019 at 1:19pm: Bobby. wrote on Sep 16th, 2019 at 3:18pm: From the original thread - A list posted by Monk with no source and manufactured in Photoshop with Monk's writing. I thought I'd investigate one of Monk's claims at random and I tore it to pieces. The above  news got a mention on the latest Adapt2030 video: Jump to 4:08 He says "only 3 of the last 20 years have seen this much snow." Where is the mention of 60 years? Where did Monk's list come from - no link. In other words - Monk has lied. I only checked one of Monk's claims and it's a lie. The source article which I used and David quoted was  here: It says "Only three of the last 20 years have seen this much snow measured at Spencers Creek during spring. These were in 2019, 2017 and 2000." Therefore - Monk is a liar. I am the author of the chart that Monk has shown, I sent it to him over Twitter and am also the owner of "adapt20301" on twitter - debunking Davids' BS. You said - where does be mention 60+ years? Go to timestamp 4:41-4:47 in the video and he says, and I quote: "a feat that has only happened 3 times in the last 65yrs". This is blatantly wrong. The chart I pulled together was taken from the Snowy Hydro Depth Measurement Website, anyone can visit it and see that the spring snowfall is not at all unique, not at all related to GSM and not at all noteworthy. Oh and for the record, that graph was done on my phone lol. Not photoshop. Why would anyone create that in photoshop? Do you even know what it is for? Hi DDD, That's the problem. The video is here: timestamp 4:41-4:47  is not exactly what Monk said. Monk never gave the time stamp info. I was forced to try & find what he meant. The info read out by David DuByne was from John Clarkson - I don't know who he is. You manufactured a list of events on your phone - I don't know who you are - I had no way of checking that. So - I quite rightly debunked what Monk was writing. Monk is a raving lunatic who doesn't source any info with links - that's all I was asking him to do. I gave him 24 hours & he couldn't supply a single link to back up his ravings so I hid the thread. Let's hope you'll do better? here is the site for DDD You said Dubyne did not say "a feat that has only happened 3 times in the last 65yrs" - which is plainly false, perhaps turn on closed captions if you are hard of hearing. Now the fact that Dubyne quoted another source does not expunge him from fact checking his sources, which as shown were false. I explained to you where the spring snow depths were taken from, why do you ignore it? Because you can't accept it was being true? As I said - Visit the Snowyhydro Snowdepth Website and look at the years quoted. I'd link them for you however as a new member I cannot post URLS apparently... Attached is a screenshot of one year I mentioned. Doesn't look like your manufactured graph: Post it in the environment forum not here.

It appears you are also incapable of reading.

One of the dates and snowdepths I listed in that screenshot is the same as the attachment i provided.

Why you are incapable of seeing that?

And why would I post in the Environment subforum when it is managed by someone who:
Believes bloggers over Scientists
Actively silences others who have different opinions

You're doing nothing to strengthen your case that you are right and if anything you're showing the extreme ignorance you hold.